4 ms·
I think there is an overwhelming preponderance of evidence that if the starting point is some society and it changes to be more free, the outcome is more wealth
by roenxi 6y ago
I think there is an overwhelming preponderance of evidence that if the starting point is some society and it changes to be more free, the outcome is more wealth and comfort. I'd rather live in a free society.
That being said, the greatest improvement in the greatest number of people at the fastest rate is almost certainly a title held by the totalitarian government in China. Short-term but nevertheless evidence-based thinkers would struggle to see what the problem is with totalitarianism.
Also; reminder of my favourite thing-I-picked-up-from-a-bit-of-history, the other big advantage of democracies is they tend to be pretty reliable at winning wars. Voters are remarkably good at making armies work.
- lordnacho 6y ago> I think there is an overwhelming preponderance of evidence that if the starting point is some society and it changes to be more free, the outcome is more wealth and comfort. On issues of political economy, I always like to reverse the arrow of causality to see if that could also be an explanation. Is it increased wealth, or economic power, that leads to more freedom? I think there's a line of thinking that the US civil rights movement was caused by blacks becoming more economically important, thought I'm not familiar with the evidence. Likewise you could argue that UK industrial growth preceded women's right to vote, and various other freedom related things that happened. Of course it could also be a virtuous circle, they both cause each other, and sometimes one or the other is ignited by some other thing.
- Hokusai 6y ago> the totalitarian government in China Yes, except that it started to work out when China stopped to try to be a fully planned economy (that killed millions) and started to work towards a more free market economy where people had more choices on where, and how to work. It's to be seen how the young Chinese, more educated and more ambitious than the previous generation is going to work with the still totalitarian part of their government.
- ur-whale 6y agoYou're conflating market freedom and individual rights. There are plenty of places (e.g. Singapore) where you had (still true today btw) very much of the first and precious little of the second and that can bee by many metrics regarded as great "social" successes.
- unishark 6y ago> That being said, the greatest improvement in the greatest number of people at the fastest rate is almost certainly a title held by the totalitarian government in China. If you're talking about the recent two decades, then specifically it's a totalitarian government adopting market reforms (i.e. freedoms) which imitate successful liberal democracies on their borders. I'd also note that prior to the "Chinese miracle" was the "South Korean miracle" and before that the "Japanese miracle". China was the slowest and last, just the biggest population.
- eloisius 6y agoAlso worth noting that Taiwan has a far higher GDP per capita. Admittedly, not a perfect comparison with China since they received decades of Japanese infra development.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoDid the Japanese infra development come from a more free market Japan? I would think there is a chain involved somewhere along there.
- eloisius 6y agoThe Japanese infra came from imperial Japan prior to the conclusion of WWII so I’m not sure how “free” market I would consider that since it was more of a totalitarian command economy.
- roenxi 6y agoI'm pretty extreme; I see all forms of government 'help' as the precursors for disaster. So I totally accept the argument that they are doing the correct thing by backing away from totalitarianism. But unfortunately, the twin arguments that 'they aren't pure in their beliefs' and 'they are copying good ideas from elsewhere' and both devastatingly weak arguments if someone challenges them. I would call on Western governments to copy what China has done that worked, except I don't trust them to identify it. I think they'd just import the surveillance state and ignore the "what about letting the capitalists capitalise?" idea.
- sasaf5 6y ago> Short-term but nevertheless evidence-based thinkers would struggle to see what the problem is with totalitarianism. Their growth was due to copying the strategies and technologies developed in the free world, not due to totalitarianism. If anything, totalitarianism only slowed them down, just see the results of the cultural revolution.
- machiaweliczny 6y agoI would argue that authoritarian government helped, as it's hard to bootstrap economy with open markets and democracy (bribery). Democracy would work better if peoole would be paid better but also put to jail more. It's unfortunate dynamic od if not me then another one (will take bribe) is a weakness. Authoritarian govs require bigger foes (nation state) - see Irak, Libia etc. It makes me think that USA legal bribes might be a genius move. At least there's way to fight malicious actors in legal way.
- bloak 6y agoThe modernisation of the Soviet Union under Stalin was also very impressive. They went from a feudal society with serfs, like Europe in the Middle Ages, to the first man in space rather quickly. Of course, in both cases, China and the Soviet Union, ideas were being imported from elsewhere, though in the case of the Soviet Union, a lot of the space technology came from Nazi Germany ... Probably best not to try to infer simple rules from history.
- smallnamespace 6y agoSerfs were emancipated in 1861, well before the 1917 Communist revolution.
- dmos62 6y agoChina is totalitarian, but that might not be the reason why its economy is booming.
- watwut 6y ago> reminder of my favourite thing-I-picked-up-from-a-bit-of-history, the other big advantage of democracies is they tend to be pretty reliable at winning wars. Voters are remarkably good at making armies work. Are they really? WWII was won by alliance of democracy and dictatorship. Same for WWI. Vietnam War does not seem to be clearly won by democracy either.
- jordan_curve 6y agoIt didn’t work out so well for the Athenians... My naive guess (as someone who is not at all a historian) would be that democratic states historically tended to have more functional economies and thus won wars more often. On the other hand, democracies can be particularly susceptible to demagoguery during wartime. This is what caused the collapse of the Athenian empire (at least if we’re to trust Thucydides’ account).
- nimbleal 6y agoDemocracy in the modern sense (universal suffrage, very large polities) is too recent an experiment to have strong data on that — the vast majority of the democratic experiment has been conducted under a US hegemony. I’m not sure the (also very limited) Ancient Greek example bears enough resemblance to the modern idea to be a useful comparison (I suggest also as a non-historian).
- Proven 6y ago> That being said, the greatest improvement in the greatest number of people at the fastest rate is almost certainly a title held by the totalitarian government in China. Nonsense. North Korea could beat them simply because communism has done so much more damage there. Would that make you think the Kim family really gets how to advance a society?