4 ms·
The solution is decentralized, verifiable forms of authority. Not unelected, unaccountable corporations that selectively (and with repeated obvious bias) choose
by keiferski 6y ago
The solution is decentralized, verifiable forms of authority. Not unelected, unaccountable corporations that selectively (and with repeated obvious bias) choose what is “true.” Especially not YouTube, of all places, who has about as much authority as McDonalds, as far as I’m concerned.
That’s it. No attempt to have a single source of authoritative information is going to work post-Internet. The cat is already out of the bag. This model of the world is outdated and needs to be put out to pasture.
- 3np 6y agoThis. YouTube should be free to allow or block any content they want on their privately owned and permissions platform. At the same time, no company should have the power to decide what content can be shared and spread. It’s all of our responsibilities to take back the power we always had and give it back to individuals. The other their is through open protocols through decentralized / federated permissionless infrastructure.
- owlbynight 6y agoBut how do you take the power back? How do you yell shark and get people to listen when they've been desensitized by an ocean full of fake sharks?
- 3np 6y agoStart with yourself. Prefer better alternatives whenever possible. If you have the means: Start hosting. Contribute (code, tutorials, docs). Spread the word. Contribute funds to projects. Answer support questions/GH issues/forum posts from people who are having issues. When it comes to people you know and interact with, start with the “low-hanging fruit” (individuals who have skills/interest in technology or are already agreeing about the problem).
- minerjoe 6y agoBe the change you wish to see in the world. I used to be outwardly and loudly critical of the system and people supporting it, but that got me nowhere, just isolated. When I stopped all criticism and just started aligning my life how I would like others to live, I finally started to get somewhere.
- owlbynight 6y agoIs this solution possible with misinformation campaigns being waged against it from its inception? I'm not disagreeing with you on an ideological level, but this solution is pie in the sky. How do you propose this solution be enacted while the supporters it would need to come to fruition are actively being lobbied by the problem its supposed to solve?
- keiferski 6y agoI think it will occur naturally over the next few decades. Each misstep that Big Tech / Big Media makes chips off a tiny sliver of their edifice. Over time this will splinter into a thousand pieces, and some attempt to unify information across them will be invented and adopted. It’s easy to forget that the modern Internet itself is only about thirty years old. We’re still at the very, very early stages.
- owlbynight 6y agoI was on the early Internet. I miss it greatly, but also, it was the wild west, which was awesome when I was essentially living in the woods secluded from the outside world. The freedom was intoxicating. It ended up shaping my entire life. I've watched the Internet grow and evolve into what it is and spent the majority of my free time participating in it from 1993 until today and probably until I die. The thing is, the problem has always existed but its now being scaled up. There were kids pretending to be adults and puffing up their chests at the expense of decency. There was child porn. There were racists. There were pockets of criminals. There weren't many flat out idiots because using the Internet required at least a mononom of intellect to participate. Yes, it's still early for the Internet, but America is just getting dumber while the Internet is getting easier and easier to use. How does it get better before it gets much worse?
- keiferski 6y agoI think it’s just a natural part of the technology adoption process. Only early adopters use it > widespread usage > simplified, centralized solutions eat the usage market (FB, etc.) > the normal people learn how to be technical users, at least enough to go independent > decentralization takes hold. We’re now in between the last two steps. Compare it to something like reading and writing or paper. Roughly the same process happened.
- nl 6y agoWhy is this a solution. No one doubts Alan Jones identity for example.
- refurb 6y agoThis has to be one of the most frightening proposals I’ve seen. How would this body be formed? What body currently exists that is completely unbiased? There have been numerous examples of Western gov’ts outright lying to the more citizens, often for decades. That would be the official truth, with any dissenting opinions deemed “illegal”. This literally sounds like 1984 and the Ministry of Truth. Edit: replied to subcomment, not parent comment, very regrettable.
- keiferski 6y agoI think you meant to reply to a different comment.