3 ms·
But as I've pointed out before, how do I as a user of this site, get access to the very evidence I need? There are numerous suspicious posts - which may just b
by throwaway_pdp09 6y ago
But as I've pointed out before, how do I as a user of this site, get access to the very evidence I need?
There are numerous suspicious posts - which may just be my biases, or not - such as this thread with a guy posting a lot of facts https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24746397 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24746397
I applaud this because we need facts, but one guy there has an astonishing level of facts ready to go and a rather slick and way of putting things which I recognise. Why? because I used to work in publicity (though not of the spinning kind). I recognise the style. I want the guy here and posting because we need facts not shouting but if he has a financial interest, we need to know. It should not stop him being there if there is because in some respects his pro-niclear posts are pretty good but it needs to be open.
Other problems - there's a certain style of posting that proposes stuff with zero facts and magically gets voted to the top of the thread. No facts, slight whiff of fud, pushed to the top. That's not actually how the HN crowd tends to react to info-free posts (or myabe there's a subset who does, I may be mistaken). But how do I analyse the voting patterns when I don't have the voting data?
I'll not mention what happens when china becomes the subject.
Is it me? I don't know. But then I can't tell without evidence. There seem to be other problems. Is it me? I dunno. I'm posting less here because I feel good stuff is getting swamped (not just my stuff, a lot of other people's stuff. My posts aren't generally a pinnacle).
Edit: so how do I get the evidence you require?
- krageon 6y agoIt has already been pointed out that discussing anti-astroturfing measures in detail is not done, for reasons that have been explained. It doesn't seem reasonable to keep demanding explanations given what has been said before.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago"The difference is evidence, and that's what we require." So how do I supply the required?
- ratww 6y agoYou can always contact the moderators in private if you're unsure, or do lots of research, like Troy did here.
- troydavis 6y agoNew submissions appear here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newest https://news.ycombinator.com/newest. Eventually, consider enabling "showdead" on the settings/profile page.