7 ms·
Mozilla RegretsReporter
- animal_spirits 6y agoWhat kind of useful information can this provide? What actual use could Mozilla make from this information? Mozilla used to be about privacy and technology, but now its asking us to share with them our embarrassing habits of video watching?
- endgame 6y agoI have an idea for Mozilla: cut the random activism projects, keep Firefox competitive and resume the experimental stuff once you've got the browser sorted. A browser that's not pushed by an advertising company is really important. If we lose Firefox, we lose badly, and these diversions are putting that key bulwark at risk.
- dralley 6y agoThis is a project by the Mozilla Foundation (as you can see from the URL), it has nothing to do with Mozilla Corporation or the Firefox browser. "Activism stuff" is precisely what the Mozilla _Foundation_ is for.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThis should probably be made clearer to people who consider donating to the Mozilla Foundation, then. Because I bet many donate because they want to support Firefox.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoHow should they make it clearer? Their donate page says the donations are to "carry out our mission to keep the Web open and free" and links to a FAQ that details what the donations are used for and how Firefox is separate.
- freshsqueeze 6y agoshould say something like "goes to some non-profit exec leeches"
- jessaustin 6y agoIt's a non-profit charity, right? Is any potential donor unaware of this phenomenon?
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThe Mozilla Foundation's 8 person board of directors seems to receive no salary, so your donation wouldn't pay for that.
- tmzt 6y agoExcept, "keep the web open and free" was a big part of the marketing around Firefox when the target was IE. The New York Times ad was paid for through donations to present an alternative to the closed ecosystem dominated by one browser that didn't follow open standards. https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2017/11/14/fast-for-good-launching-the-new-firefox-into-the-world/nyt_ad_large_2004/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2017/11/14/fast-for-good-launc... Early versions of Firefox featured links to various news organizations and stories pulled from their feeds, until certain jurisdictions threatened to block the browser entirely. At some point their missions may have diverged, but the marketing of both were closely intertwined. MoFo accepted donations and other sources of funds which it used, in part, to fund development of a browser by MoCo. Other projects came later, but the community's understanding of their respective roles remained the same. As a long-term observer I followed this closely when the Foundation and Commercial split was announced, and remember reassurance s about the core mission being loudly proclaimed. Here it is from the former CLW herself: https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2007/08/09/firefox-is-a-public-asset/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2007/08/09/firefox-is-a-public...
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>The New York Times ad was paid for through donations While true, those donations were largely from sources connected to Netscape. If they had built a normal corporation, it'd be startup capital. >MoFo accepted donations and other sources of funds which it used, in part, to fund development of a browser by MoCo Mozilla Corporation saw $60 million in revenue in the first year, at no point were the donations a significant source of income. >remember reassurance s about the core mission being loudly proclaimed. Here's the actual "core mission" they launched at the time, note the pledge containing >Use the Mozilla assets (intellectual property such as copyrights and trademarks, infrastructure, funds, and reputation) to keep the Internet an open platform; https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/manifesto/details/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/manifesto/details/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- csande17 6y agoIf the Mozilla Foundation really has nothing to do with the organization that develops Mozilla Firefox, they should consider using a name that isn't "Mozilla" or "Firefox". As it stands, the primary activity of the Foundation is to take money and goodwill earned by Firefox and divert it to unrelated activism.
- freshsqueeze 6y agothey don't care, millions have been going to mitchell baker's pocket for the last decades
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cbsks 6y ago“nothing to do with Mozilla Corporation or the Firefox browser” is a little strong “Firefox is maintained by the Mozilla Corporation, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Mozilla Foundation” https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/faq/ https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/faq/
- wyldfire 6y ago> A browser that's not pushed by an advertising company is really important. If we lose Firefox, we lose badly Agreed. I'm encouraged at the thought of Google being forced to divest from Chrome by US antitrust action [1] [2]. [1] https://www.marketplace.org/2020/10/13/what-would-google-be-without-chrome/ https://www.marketplace.org/2020/10/13/what-would-google-be-... [2] https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/10/feds-may-target-googles-chrome-browser-for-breakup-428468 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/10/feds-may-target-goo...
- burnte 6y agoI'm not a fan of making Google break up, nor Facebook. I don't think breaking them up serves the public interest best. I'd rather have stricter oversight and regulation of certain aspects. How would Chrome as a standalone business generate revenue?
- tylerflick 6y agoThey could sell their product, Chrome. People used to pay for software.
- cgriswald 6y agoI paid for Netscape back in the day and I’d pay quite a bit annually for Firefox or some other browser. But people are used to not paying for browsers and I’m not very convinced most or maybe not even enough people would.
- freeopinion 6y agoUm. Maybe get a boat load of money from a company like... Google? You know, same as Firefox does?
- burnte 6y agoSo how does that change things? If they're dependent on Google for revenue, then they're vulnerable to Google's influence.
- freshsqueeze 6y agomaybe cost of $10000s (or even $100K+) to build. this is where your donations go towards!
- gruez 6y agoAs opposed to... firefox? It's frequently pointed out in firefox/mozilla threads that donations to mozilla foundation does not go toward firefox development, since that's done by mozilla corporation (the for-profit subsidiary of mozilla foundation).
- nshepperd 6y agoThere are frequently comments on such threads from people discovering this fact for the first time, so it does seem to be a point worth repeating.
- zdragnar 6y agoThis is the sort of thing I find myself frequently forgetting, too. After all, it stands to reason that the open source browser would be funded by the non-profit Mozilla entity, not the for-profit Mozilla entity. Honestly, short of going and looking it up, I haven't got a clue what the for-profit mozilla entity does other than the browser. Sign deals exchanging money for the default search engine position?
- derefr 6y ago> After all, it stands to reason that the open source browser would be funded by the non-profit Mozilla entity, not the for-profit Mozilla entity. Why would that stand to reason? Firefox makes Mozilla money (through search provider sponsorship), and therefore needs to be a company to receive that revenue. Nothing else Mozilla does makes them money, and therefore nothing else they do needs to be a company. What would you imagine the Mozilla Corporation exists to do, if not to make money from Firefox (and then plow that money back into Firefox development)?
- 6y ago
- neltnerb 6y agoWow, just straight out installing an add-on just to help Google train it's YouTube recommendation algorithm. Why are you devoting resources to an extension instead of letting Google do it?
- jand 6y agoI do not feel comfortable about this. From my point of view the proper way to solve this is to educate people and build up "media competence". Who defines what a harmful video is? Such classification is always influenced by current trends, social norms and so on. What might be harmful to a child might be not even worth a shrug to an adult. What is fact today, might be laughable tomorrow and heresy the day after. Have fun navigating this. If you think that youtube guides people on downward spirals towards extremism and is not willing to acknowledge or change it - talk to your kids and peers about it. Repeat this until they are able to decide for themselves. But pushing some information (sort of propaganda) and hiding some information (sort of censorship) both lead down a dangerous path. I can't put my finger right on the spot, but it seems like nuking a hurricane.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>But pushing some information (sort of propaganda) and hiding some information (sort of censorship) both lead down a dangerous path What information is this pushing or hiding? This is trying to better understand how YouTube is making these recommendations, so it is a known factor when you talk to your kids and peers.
- jand 6y ago> What information is this pushing or hiding? This is trying to better understand how YouTube is making these recommendations, so it is a known factor when you talk to your kids and peers. Well, I personally doubt that this project aims at purely understanding the recommendation logic and then doing nothing. But i might be mistaken. Time will tell.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoWhat do you think it is for? I can't imagine any nefarious plans providing this level of control over what data you send them.
- derefr 6y agoThere’s a sucker born every minute. Or more than one sucker per minute, even. Far more people join the Internet every day than could possibly be reached by education. That’s kinda what “Eternal September” was: the moment when the Internet began growing too quickly for the existing social mores of IT people to become impressed onto the next generation of Internet users. Barnum’s sideshows eventually stopped, but it wasn’t education that stopped them. Mostly, it was government regulation stripping away all the big draws (the big-top shows) by making a lot of them (rightfully) illegal. That just required a few experts and politicians to achieve consensus on the subject; a secular shift in public opinion wasn’t required.
- seppel 6y agoAt first I thought it is a tool to fight against clickbait / spam videos, which could be quite useful. But no, it is a tool to report videos about opinions that made you feel uneasy. Wow.
- microcolonel 6y agoHacker culture is dead, and someone somewhere is saying good riddance with a smug look on their face.
- radicalriddler 6y agoWhat is hacker culture, and what does it have to do with this RegretsReporter thing from Mozilla?
- googthrowaway42 6y agoHacker culture is about challenging orthodoxies and fostering a spirit of play and irreverence. RegretsReporter at the very least is about reinforcing orthodoxies.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoAttempting to figure out how a hidden system works is a keystone of hacker culture.
- Ayesh 6y agoCan it report Mozilla Decision Regrets? Because this is such a out of focus feature from a company that develops the only browser that's not developed by for-profit company and not chromium based. This looks even worse to after reading that many brilliant engineers were let go due to financial reasons.
- Canada 6y agoAs if the internet needs even more services designed to make people angry.
- hu3 6y agoTo think amazing Servo engineers were let go to save funds while this project still exists.
- nyanpasu64 6y agoOpened this site, turns out it does scrolljacking. Every time I press Page Down, it skips forwards two slides.
- OliverGilan 6y agoFunnily enough, if Mozilla just focused on keeping Firefox competitive they would do more good for the world than whatever these random activist projects are supposed to be
- camdenlock 6y agoIt’s pretty stunning to me that this tool could have been made without its authors recognizing that it serves a very specific belief system. No mention of that fact anywhere. A simple act of etiquette would be to recognize your own astounding biases and at least put up a little warning sign or something: “Made by and for American Progressivism Activists”.
- chris_wot 6y agoDoes the extension name itself? If so, how do we report it?
- phodge 6y agoThe reason you stumble upon youtube videos that make you uncomfortable is because we have a free and open web where anyone can publish whatever they want (except the most extreme content such as terrorism how-tos). I don't see how this Mozilla tool could ever contribute to making the web more free and more open; in fact it seems to be designed by activists to make the web _less_ free and _less_ open.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoUnderstanding how YouTube's algorithm works provides a more free and open web as it would be easier for anyone to use the algorithm to improve their views. I really don't understand why people think this makes the web less free and open. Somebody voicing their opinion about a video to a third party doesnt block the video.