13 ms·
This is interesting for a couple reasons. 1) While I agree with the article's assessment that superconduction along huge distances is a likely no-go given pres
by shadowgovt 6y ago
This is interesting for a couple reasons.
1) While I agree with the article's assessment that superconduction along huge distances is a likely no-go given pressures involved, it's not out of the realm of possibility that we could find a way to apply massive static pressure loads to small high-performance circuits.
2) If the pressures are 75% the Earth's core, that raises interesting geologic questions about what's going on in the Earth's core. Perhaps the model for Earth's magnetic field (or the material that causes it) will need to be adjusted to account for the possibility of naturally-occurring superconductors.
- anonuser123456 6y agoEarth's core is pretty hot IIRC.
- formerly_proven 6y ago4500-6000 °C
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stretchwithme 6y agoAnd probably unlikely for the same material to occur naturally.
- culopatin 6y agoWell, how likely is that we even exist to begin with? And how likely is that we are alive because of a ball of hydrogen and helium really far away?
- unwoundmouse 6y agobruv this some gamblers fallacy shyt
- posterboy 6y agowell it is, but it's an accurate response to somebody already engaged in it. It is the GP who finds it "probably unlikely" without any indication of actual probabilities, chiefly rounding down from a haphazard guess, after all.
- roywiggins 6y agoOne very unlikely thing happening doesn't make another unlikely thing any more likely.
- gibolt 6y agoNo, but it does show how significantly unlikely things can happen given enough time and billions of moving variables.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt doesn’t seem to just be one very unlikely thing, but a huge series of unlikely things...
- p1mrx 6y agoThe universe is pretty big, and there are lots of places where unlikely things didn't happen. When the next unlikely thing happens, it most likely won't happen here.
- vagrantJin 6y agoCarbon based life is unlikely in the universe and yet here we are. Watching tiktok. Just can't rule anything out.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoI don't know, this isn't some esoteric ceramic, it's hydrogen sulfide and methane, both of which occur in nature. You may be interested to know that the same logic applied to concentrations of U-235 needed to run a fission reactor turns out to be false: https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/oklo-reactor https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/oklo-reactor In modern industry, getting enough U-235 to run a reactor requires separating and enriching the ore, but this happened by chance in the distant past.
- njarboe 6y agoThe key to why the Oklo reactor was possible was not that a natural process separated U-235 from U-238 from a Uranium ore, but that the reactor existed 1.7 billion years ago. U-235 has a half life of about 700 million years so the ratio of U-235 to U-238 in naturally occuring Uranium decreases over time. U-235 was about 3.1% of Uranium in ores 1.7 billion years ago and is what can be used in some reactors today. Uranium ore today has only about %0.72, so an Oklo type natural reactor could not form on today's Earth. See [1] for a good description; the atlasobscura article is poor and factually incorrect in places. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reacto...
- brlewis 6y agoBut in a molten core, won't hydrogen sulfide and methane bubble out from the center, leaving only iron and heavier elements and compounds in the super high pressure depths?
- Balgair 6y agoVery likely. But more studies would be needed. The best phase diagram for H2S and methane that I could find only went up to ~140 barr. Though there were some interesting papers on clathrates and methane in the kilo-barr range, but I'd not think those were interesting for deep earth experiments. The deep earth is ~3.3 mega-barr, for comparison. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/hydrogen-sulfide-H2S-properties-d_2034.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/hydrogen-sulfide-H2S-prop... https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/methane-d_1420.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/methane-d_1420.html
- dheera 6y agoIt's also super interesting for engineering reasons: - Maglev trains can be built at much lower cost - Other levitating transportation via the Meissner effect - Quantum computing - Entertainment, theme parks Lots of things I can think of.
- gipp 6y agoGP was talking specifically about the approach in the article, which requires massively high pressures to sustain, not superconduction in general. I don't think the required pressures are really practical for any of the things you listed.
- dheera 6y agoSure, it's not ready for those use cases yet, but the fact that it has been achieved at room temperature is a milestone, and those use cases are things that would benefit from room temperature superconductivity.
- hutzlibu 6y agoNo, it is not. Even though the goal at "room temperature" is technically met, it is misleading, because the goal "room temperature" meant superconducting under quite normal conditions to be of practical use. And when you have to apply that immense pressure it means we did not really come closer to superconducting in the normal world. Still a success, yes, but probably not a milestone, unless that discovery leads to other findings, but I do not see anything indicating such.
- gorgoiler 6y ago> they stress that the newfound compound will never find its way into lossless power lines or frictionless high-speed trains
- silvestrov 6y agoYou can transport electricity from wind mills from far, far away. The wind will always blow somewhere, so the storage problem goes away. Or solar power transported from the south to the north of US or EU. Superconductors are the ultimate joker in green energy.
- asdfman123 6y agoI'm not so sure there's geologic implications. This kind of superconductivity only occurs in very specific compounds at very specific temperatures -- way cooler than what's going on in the earth's core. We've found a few substances that are superconductive at very low temperatures, but it doesn't have any impact on geology because those conditions simply aren't found on earth.
- m-watson 6y agoNot necessarily, the point of the article is that there is a high/room temperature superconducting material. That doesn't mean it is naturally occurring or that there are any, but the understanding that you can achieve superconductivity at higher temperatures when at (significantly) higher pressures could lead to some new geological hypothesis to try and test.
- eloff 6y agoThe earth's core is north of 4000 degrees Celsius. It's a huge leap to imagine any superconductor at those temperatures, nevermind such a precisely engineered mix of elements occurring naturally. We're squarely in the realm of fantasy here, not geology.
- hanselot 6y agoI think the only way to answer that question is to do more research, as opposed to squarely assuming that something is impossible simply because you didn't think of it.
- marksbrown 6y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y ago"Fantasy" seems a little bit harsh to me, when our deepest borehole reaches only 12,2km down. Also our acceptance of continental drift/plate tectonics is rather young. In other words: We have a few vague assumptions of what happens down there, based on our current understanding of physics, which we base on what we could veri-/falsify by experimenting with things which are accessible or at least visible to us. Nobody has been down there, we have no pristine samples, nor the ability to get them(for now).
- lumost 6y agoI wouldn't rule out extremely high internal pressures in static materials as a future research direction. Prince Rupert drops reach a pressure of 700 Megapascals, roughly 2-3 orders of magnitude less than the required pressure for this experiment. I'd imagine that more advanced processes and materials can already manage internal pressures substantially greater than the Prince Rupert Drop.
- salty_biscuits 6y agoIt is hard to imagine a material strong enough to maintain residual stresses this high! Maybe in diamond? And what happens when it fractures and all comes apart? (unless it is contained in a very small volume so has bugger all potential energy)
- lumost 6y agoLooks like some recent synthetic diamonds manage pressure in the TPa regime! 1 order of magnitude higher than that required for this experiment. https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/7/e1600341 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/7/e1600341
- peterwoerner 6y agoMaterials do a little better under compression than tension. But yea, 267 GPa is a lot. The working stress for most high strength metals is about 1 GPa. With that being said under shock conditions for instance. That said you can locally get huge stresses without out breaking the material.
- kortex 6y agoI can readily imagine some cross-discipline techniques achieving this. A little lithography, some selective dissolution like Gorilla glass, perhaps some tricks from the optical fiber industry, and bam, you have a fine coaxial filament which creates a region of 100's-of -MPa stress along the length of the fiber. Maybe even GPa, though that's tensile-strength-of-nanotubes territory. Certainly it's years away but I dunno...This feels possible in an engineering sense.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y ago> superconduction along huge distances is a likely no-go given pressures involved, Pedantic note: they said only for this material, not a no-go in general. Not sure if you caught that. "Strained silicon" is a technique for achieving faster frequencies in modern CPU by applying force to the lattice with another deposition layer. I wonder if properties of the lattice under pressure can be instigated either by similar process, or even during phase change when creating the material. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strained_silicon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strained_silicon
- pmarreck 6y agowow, I literally just had a very similar idea but what inspired me to think of it was the phenomenon of Prince Rupert's Drops https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xe-f4gokRBs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xe-f4gokRBs I commented on the quantamagazine article but it's awaiting moderator approval
- djaque 6y agoOff the top of my head, that sounds like you're off in the pressure requirement by multiple orders of magnitude. The pressure used for the superconductor is enough to shatter diamond. Creating strain in a lattice like that would just shear the materials apart.
- throwaway189262 6y agoMaterial tensile strength can be orders of magnitude higher than compression. I wouldn't dismiss the possibility of microscopic level internally stressed materials reaching such pressures. I also know nothing about material science so it's baseless speculation
- StrangeOrange 6y agoI enjoyed this schizophrenic approach to scientific enquiry.
- Pick-A-Hill2019 6y agoWhile I agree that it is an interesting finding, the lede of "at room temperatures" buries the fact that using a median of 330-360 gigapascals as a measure of the earths' internal pressure equates to a pressure of 8223639745.0093 pounds per square foot. (Rough calculations based on 3,300,000 to 3,600,000 atm for the Earths' inner core) [Edit to correct the maths] = 5325785739.6251 pounds per square foot.
- handol 6y agoCouldn't the pinch effect be used to crush two superconducting filaments into each other? My rough calculation is something like 5 MA(in each conductor, spaced by 1mm) would do the trick, assuming that much current and B don't interfere with superconductivity (I have no idea). Looks like the highest current ever achieved is 100 kA. A mere 100 fold increase and we should be good to go.
- Misdicorl 6y agoCurrent and magnetic field are damping effects on a material's superconductivity. Breach the conductance threshold in particular and you get catastrophic material failure
- aqme28 6y agoThis wouldn't exist on our earth, but there are superconducting neutron stars out there (at pressures far greater than we can produce on earth). I wonder if this has any implications for those.
- User23 6y agoThe core is computing the ultimate question.
- larrydag 6y agoThat's an interesting hypothesis. So are there layers in the Earth's mantle that are superconductors?
- hinkley 6y agoOne of the interesting conversations about a new technology is figuring out the 'ladder' of applications for the tech as more or larger versions become available in a particular price class. Portable MRIs are one application, once you can make a big enough chunk of the stuff, but earlier than that, couldn't you use small pieces of superconductor in communications equipment? Power supplies, ranging from IC power regulators up to mains power transformers?
- yamrzou 6y agoFor anyone interested, I recommend a BBC Horizon documentary about the earth's core called "The Core". I found about it on HN and quite enjoyed it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4035519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4035519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13486960 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13486960
- mmwelt 6y agoSounds interesting, but the video doesn't seem to be available anymore. I'd be interested if anyone has a working link!
- yamrzou 6y agoYou can download it from this archive.org collection (s2011e12): https://archive.org/download/BBCHorizonCollection512Episodes https://archive.org/download/BBCHorizonCollection512Episodes