3 ms·
> Countries that locked down late, came out of lock down too early, did not effectively test and quarantine, or only used a partial lockdown—including Brazil, M
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
> Countries that locked down late, came out of lock down too early, did not effectively test and quarantine, or only used a partial lockdown—including Brazil, Mexico, Netherlands, Peru, Spain, Sweden, the U.S. and the U.K.—have almost uniformly done worse in rates of infection and death.
I'm skeptical of this kind of underspecified hypothesis. Is there some concrete definition of for example "came out of lockdown too early" being applied here? Or is it just the post-hoc reasoning of "well, they didn't achieve good results, so their methods must have been bad"? You could probably explain any pattern in the data with such vague criteria.
- Tarsul 6y agoThe question your posing for the author is how thorough s/he would have to go into the details to capture his/her audience. I don't know exactly the audience but I know that the argument (s)he makes is more than enough for me. As I've followed the news especially regarding US, UK, Sweden and [as a good example - for now!] Germany and just nod along when I read the quote. It has been pretty clear to the avid (real) newsreader how much impact letting it spread has (and going out of lockdown when the R0 has not sufficiently subsided). We can currently watch in awe how the second wave manifests in Europe because we did not react fast enough when the numbers shot up again... I mean the pattern is always the same. It's not exactly rocket science...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe question I'm posing is whether the hypothesis is well-specified and true, not whether it's persuasive to the target audience. I think the target audience largely follows your "can I nod along to it" heuristic, but underspecified hypotheses are the easiest to nod along with, because they'll continue to make sense no matter what data you see. If a second wave hadn't manifested in Europe, nobody would see that as a contradiction; they'd just say "well, ok, Europe must have done the right things then".
- lhorie 6y agoI'm sure there's a matter of article length if every claim requires writing extensively about a country's policy. You can look up articles on your own to corroborate these claims. For example, Brazil's Bolsonaro's stance was pretty much a mirror of the US response (down to the president downplaying the seriousness of the problem and subsequently getting infected and all) Canada provides another interesting data point. They have very strict quarantine policies for incoming travelers, but now that domestic flights are at full capacity again, schools are reopening and the general public is getting more lax, they're seeing an uptick in cases again.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThere are certainly examples of countries that both had a lot of deaths and didn't have very strict responses. But the list also includes Spain and the UK, which had long and strict lockdowns - Spain kept kids locked indoors for 6 weeks!
- lhorie 6y agoSure, but that doesn't refute the claim that not taking the necessary precautions leads to worse outcomes. What the Spain/UK cases suggest is that lack of lockdown policies aren't the only leading factors to the spread of the disease. This is why I think the Canada case is interesting: yes the government tells travelers to quarantine under the risk of a million dollar fine, but go to a park now and 80% of people aren't wearing masks despite reports of people breaking quarantine. So clearly, a dissonance between policy and what's going on on the ground can have a non-negligible effect.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAgain, my concern is that this claim is so underspecified that no data could refute it. No matter which countries achieve better or worse outcomes, you can (and people do) define whatever the countries with better outcomes did to be the necessary precautions. Maybe a concrete example would help express what I'm getting at here. If Brazil saw a rapid improvement over the next month, would you consider that a refutation of the claim, or would you conclude that they must have started taking the necessary precautions?