6 ms·
Note the red message about how to run the installer on Windows despite the SmartScreen popup. Microsoft really needs to do something about the whole SmartScree
by flohofwoe 6y ago
Note the red message about how to run the installer on Windows despite the SmartScreen popup.
Microsoft really needs to do something about the whole SmartScreen mess if even properly signed, popular and trusted open source tools like Krita require such a "how to get around the SmartScreen popup" note in their installation instructions.
- kuschku 6y agoYou can actually install Krita from the Windows Store, it's the same version
- selfhoster11 6y agoNot everyone wants to use the Windows Store, for multiple reasons. There's no reason to scare users away from independent software distribution.
- vinceguidry 6y agoOf course there is. $$$$
- wtetzner 6y agoHow does Microsoft make money from free apps being in the Windows Store?
- laszlokorte 6y agoBy conditioning users to only use the store and then later for paid apps as well.
- vinceguidry 6y ago'Zactly. Every tech company has a strong interest in platform lock-in, not only do they collect a cut on whatever gets sold through the platform, but their data collection is better, so they can sell it to marketers.
- Complexicate 6y agoThere absolutely is a reason. Microsoft's reason. Scaring users away from independent software distribution means more people will use the Windows Store.
- wtetzner 6y agoOr it means more people will stop using Windows.
- Miraste 6y agoUnfortunately, Android, iOS, and MacOS are the alternatives non-technical people look at, and they're all much worse about installing software than Windows.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoCode signing existed for a long time before the store arrived.
- hashkb 6y agoI think it's about money, not security.
- IshKebab 6y agoOf course! If they made independent software distribution impossible at the same time as introducing the store there would be an enormous backlash. The strategy is to introduce the store and slowly make independent distribution more and more onerous, using security as justification. When people complain you can say "just put your app in the store and you won't need to worry about signin/notarisation/etc." Apple are doing exactly the same thing.
- gambler 6y agoCode signing the way it's implemented in Windows was always a garbage feature that made everyone less secure and more confused. Stop gaslighting on behalf of Microsoft. They clearly are manipulating users to get them to use Windows Store. The thing is shoved in your face whenever you use Windows 10.
- qayxc 6y ago> There's no reason to scare users away from independent software distribution. Can you please for the love of Zeus make up your mind already? "Installing random software from the Internet - bad! Linux good because package manager!" Microsoft offering a "store" (most software on it is free anyway) and allowing signed installers that won't trigger warnings - also bad! So which is it? And more importantly, how is this any way worse than the common practise in Linux to install 3rd party software via some variation of "wget -O https://some.totally.trustworthy.website/install https://some.totally.trustworthy.website/install | sudo bash" that won't show any warning whatsoever? TL;DR There totally IS a reason to scare users away from installing random crap from the internet. And that reason is independent from operating systems or companies!
- Shared404 6y ago> "Installing random software from the Internet - bad! Linux good because package manager!" Yes. > Microsoft offering a "store" (most software on it is free anyway) and allowing signed installers that won't trigger warnings - also bad! Yes, but ONLY because they require you to create a Microsoft account. If you could use it without the account, then it would be fine. Edit: I also tend to trust package maintainers for established distro's more than I trust Microsoft's QA. This is just me though so only partially relevant. > So which is it? And more importantly, how is this any way worse than the common practise in Linux to install 3rd party software via some variation of "wget -O https://some.totally.trustworthy.website/install https://some.totally.trustworthy.website/install | sudo bash" that won't show any warning whatsoever? (Windows Store) is worse than (random.exe)||(wget -O some.stupid.site/something.sh | sudo bash) is worse than (Proper package manager)
- qayxc 6y ago> (Windows Store) is worse than (random.exe)||(wget -O some.stupid.site/something.sh | sudo bash) is worse than (Proper package manager) Why? Name a technical reason and not ideological BS, please. I've yet to hear a proper argument that isn't just "because Microsoft".
- 6y ago
- thordenmark 6y agoHave you never had a relative (usually your mom) install malware because they didn't know any better? Most people are not so tech savvy as those of us who frequent Hacker News.
- flohofwoe 6y agoThere's nothing wrong about a malware scan on download (Chrome does this automatically too), but this scan should be smarter about detecting actual malware (it's called SmartScreen after all).
- _flux 6y agoBut it's basically an impossible problem to solve while not preventing running useful applications. You can only do that well until it becomes too difficult to do better.
- eitland 6y agoJust because it is impossible to solve completely doesn't mean they should get off the hook for conveniently "forgetting" innocent open source packages.
- gambler 6y ago>But it's basically an impossible problem to solve This is not just possible, but relatively easy to solve. Applications can be sandboxed by default. Signing the application or user granting it extra rights can remove some restrictions from the sandbox.
- wtetzner 6y agoBut the message specifically says MS will only trust applications signed by a Digitcert certificate. The problem isn't that they're doing the check, it's that the check is poor. There's no reason it needs to prevent people from installing software that has been signed.
- qayxc 6y agoWhere do you see that? I can find it anywhere in the release notes or the Downloads-page.
- webmobdev 6y agoThey are just imitating Apple's macOS - their GateKeeper also irritates you similarly when you install stuff not available in the app store (which I specifically avoid). Nobody wants their mac to turn into an iPad / iPhone.
- zepto 6y agoThat’s not accurate. Gatekeeper only warns about unsigned software. It has nothing to do with whether it is in the App Store or not.
- kps 6y agoThat's not accurate. The options in System Preferences are: Allow apps downloaded from: ○ App Store ○ App Store and identified developers There used to be a third option, ○ Anywhere but the frog is warmer now.
- zepto 6y agoYour options list supports my assertion: Identified developers = signed FYI: frogs actually do jump out of water as it gets hotter. You may be right that this changes in the future, but for now I am correct.
- Miraste 6y agoApple's next move is to disallow unsigned software entirely, Gatekeeper popup or no. They already announced it for ARM Macs [0]. It currently allows adhoc signatures, but I'd be shocked if that didn't go away in the next couple of versions unless they were built locally. [0] https://developer.apple.com/documentation/macos-release-notes/macos-big-sur-11-universal-apps-beta-release-notes https://developer.apple.com/documentation/macos-release-note...
- zepto 6y agoThat document doesn’t appear to say what you are claiming. Disallowing unsigned software altogether would contradict other statements they have made. That said, I wouldn’t be surprised if it becomes something you can only enable from the command line. They have clearly stated that Apple Silicon Macs will be open to whatever software you want, but they may well choose to make that more difficult for inexperienced users.