8 ms·
Do We Live in a Simulation? Chances Are about 50–50
- johndoe42377 6y agoTwo idiotic statement put together. First, probabilities application to a non-discrete systems is undefined bullshit. Second, there is no way in principle to determine a simulation, the way there is no way to determine an actual wiring of a processor from the level of code, or even that there is a processor.
- smallnamespace 6y ago> First, probabilities application to a non-discrete systems is undefined bullshit. ? Quantum mechanics strongly begs to differ—the wave function is continuous, but predictions are probabilistic.
- timkam 6y agoI agree and I really don't understand how mature researchers can engage in this type of guesswork. If we are in a simulation, our observed universe is also a simulation. Even if the real world revealed itself to us Matrix style, this "revelation" could also be a simulation. There is no way to tell. We can not falsify either of the contradicting statements "we live in a simulation" / "we do not live in a simulation". (Edit: Technically, I don't agree with your "application of probabilities to non-discrete systems" statement, but I think we get the intended meaning here.)
- drdeca 6y agoThe revelation would falsify something at least? It would falsify “we have never been in and will never be in a simulation”, yeah? Because even if the revelation was simulated but this now isn’t, it would still involve simulation. That being said, I don’t think it is likely.
- bitcharmer 6y ago> there is no way to determine an actual wiring of a processor from the level of code True, however in a multi-processor die software can use information about heat/voltage/p-/c-states to determine which core it's currently running on. And before you ask - yes, this is used in practice for sophisticated workload distribution across cpu cores in fintech.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> there is no way to determine an actual wiring of a processor from the level of code, or even that there is a processor. Unless someone explicitly leaves a loophole - for debugging or other purposes. There is a nice scene in the recent movie Vivarium about this.
- jl6 6y ago> In 2003 Bostrom imagined a technologically adept civilization that possesses immense computing power and needs a fraction of that power to simulate new realities with conscious beings in them. Given this scenario, his simulation argument showed that at least one proposition in the following trilemma must be true: First, humans almost always go extinct before reaching the simulation-savvy stage. Second, even if humans make it to that stage, they are unlikely to be interested in simulating their own ancestral past. And third, the probability that we are living in a simulation is close to one. The setup to the trilemma always felt like begging the question. That’s a really, really big if.
- titzer 6y agoBostrom's reasoning about the second one is faulty, because simulations cost computational power. In a competitive environment (particularly an economic one), it is more profitable to devote computational resources to predicting the future as opposed to peering into the past (at least to any level of detail that would give rise to consciousness). So by Bostrom's (specious) argument that there are more simulated worlds than real ones, then it's more likely that we'd be living in a simulation of the future than the past. But since in our known past we've never had the computational resources to simulate a world to the level of detail we perceive, then it's a contradiction. There are other, better arguments. Like, it appears that simulating our universe is computationally intractable because of the complexity of quantum mechanics. Instead it would make sense to simulate simpler worlds that don't have quantum mechanics, which of course would look completely different. Another argument from quantum mechanics is that the outcome of most particle reactions is entirely probabilistic, i.e. relies on tons of randomness. It would be dumb to design a simulation based so thoroughly on randomness, because you cannot make conclusions based on the outcome of a single run. Instead, you'd do Monte Carlo simulations, i.e. billions up billions of runs, building a probability distribution, which would make it even more computationally intractable. That'd be completely stupid because you can't even trust your inferences without covering a sufficient amount of the probability space, and that's a problem entirely of your creation. I am extremely skeptical of people who seriously believe that this insane reality is a simulation. They usually don't know much physics, nor computer science. A simulated world would look completely different just from the basic engineering perspective.
- d_silin 6y agoConsidering the amount of pointless suffering in human life, I've inclined to believe that no super-intelligent mind will simulate reality like ours, on ethical grounds alone.
- adrianN 6y agoYou didn't play a lot of Rollercoaster Tycoon did you? Why would the entity controlling the simulation care about simulated suffering?
- d_silin 6y agoMy hypothesis is that ethics has to evolve to match technology development for any advanced civilization, to avoid self-destruction.
- daniel957 6y agoI played a lot of Rollercoaster Tycoon and always cleaned up the vomit. I put out the fires in the Sims and made sure the burglar didn’t burgle.
- owenshen24 6y agoSSC has an interesting take on theodicy that addresses this claim: https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/03/15/answer-to-job/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/03/15/answer-to-job/
- mark254 6y ago
- adrianN 6y agoDoes it matter? What does it even mean to live in a simulation?
- daniel957 6y agoA person’s a person, no matter how small.
- formerly_proven 6y agoIf we do, we can pull of a sandbox escape so brazen it'd make taviso blush.
- sheepdestroyer 6y agoExactly. This is the topic of this entertaining talk by geohot (of iPhone and PlayStation jailbreak fame) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ESXOAJRdcwQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ESXOAJRdcwQ That's why this subject is not just theoretical/philosophical, but has potentially actionable ramifications with universe level consequences.
- lethoso 6y agoWell we either do or we don't, that's 50:50 right?
- notRobot 6y agoThat'd not how probability works. Just because there are two possible outcomes, doesn't mean that they're equally likely.
- fiblye 6y agoWith things like quantum tunneling where particles cross barriers that they probably shouldn't, and distant objects in space moving faster away from us the farther they get, one idea I've had is that naively implementing the universe's simulation in floating point numbers could explain those anomalies pretty easily. You get a lack of precision when your scale gets too tiny or too large.
- mat_olev 6y agoI'am from Belarus. We've got a real simulation out there. :)
- snicker7 6y agoThe question of whether or not we live in a simulation is more of a theological question than a scientific one.
- ryanjshaw 6y agoI propose we put 1,000 of the best vulnerability researchers in a room with an unlimited budget and ask them to break us out of the VM to turn it into a practical question.
- scoutt 6y agoI guess the problem is that they can involuntarily crash the system, but we would never know.
- draugadrotten 6y ago....and perhaps that was done already, in the moment of big bang.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoSo - put them into Scrooge McDuck's vault?
- WClayFerguson 6y agoThere is a possibility our "creator" (simulator) is indeed living in the same Spacetime as us, and is yet at a higher level up, where he isn't made of atoms like us but something else that's nonetheless inside the common spacetime. This could explain why Gravity hasn't been unified with Standard Model. Could be that our simulation is just the standard model itself, and is the thing God created. So if this is true the Simulation theory would still not answer the "Theological God" question unless our simulator knows the answer to where both of our common spacetime came from.
- sheepdestroyer 6y agoNot if we can jailbreak from it. See the geohot talk I posted in reply to another comment
- 60secz 6y agoYes and the transistors are baryonic matter 1:1 with the actual universe. The map has become the territory. Seriously, the simulation argument has to be one of the absolute stupidest. Even from a probability standpoint, it's not P(A) vs P(B), it's P(A and B) that we're in a simulation. The amount of energy required to run a universe scale simulation is beyond our ability to even begin to calculate. It's an interesting and useful thought experiment, but a terrible argument. I suspect people like Musk popularize it because they want to highlight the real and terrifying risk that humanity will destroy itself. As Occam stated: "Entities are not to be multiplied beyond necessity."
- daniel957 6y agoThe dinosaurs thought the same thing about computers.... or not...
- kiwicopple 6y ago> The amount of energy required to run a universe scale simulation is beyond our ability to even begin to calculate. Wouldn’t the simulation only have to run whatever is being perceived? No need to simulate things that are completely unattended.
- titzer 6y agoExcept that you need to ultimately compute the backwards light cone of every possible event that is part of a causal chain. I.e. this caused that, so we have to compute why this caused that, and what caused those things. Sure, if an event is never observed, i.e. it never influences any event which a consciousness perceives, either directly or indirectly, then you can leave it out. Problem is, we keep coming up with new ways of observing phenomena. We keep doing particle experiments and building telescopes, so the load on the computation of the universe is getting pretty big!
- ALittleLight 6y agoThe simulator would just need to simulate your mind such that it believed that stuff existed. For example, if you looked in a telescope at a distant star the simulation wouldn't need to simulate the distant star and all the photons and wave length shifting and gravitational lensing and whatever, it would just need to draw a little picture for you.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoThe thing that always makes me think I'm in a simulation is when somebody tries to explain to me quantum physics. From a simulator's perspective quantum physics may be the tool that efficiency possible. What I mean is that, like in a computer game, quantum physics may be responsible for only calculating the n-dimensional space that is currently in use. In a game we also try to only load into memory those parts that are currently required for gameplay in order to be efficient. Just a thought.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoI think the reason Physics (call it God, or Simulator, or whatever) uses Quantum Mechanical uncertainty (Probability Wave Functions) is because the number PI would take infinite time and storage space to compute. Not even God can compute the number because it is not 'representable' even with infinite memory. And every calculation involving particle trajectory involves PI. So what "nature" does instead of computing it is to create a function that represents it, and then solves the function later on 'on demand' with whatever accuracy there is, which is definitely finite.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoSounds plausible.
- nathias 6y agoPlato's cave for the modern age (that doesn't read or even recognize philosophy).
- seventhtiger 6y agoIs the universe compressible? Based on what we know, are there efficiencies to be found in storage or computation of the universe? Because the smallest simulation of something incompressible is itself. Assuming the universe is incompressible, it's impossible to simulate the universe in the universe. The smallest computer to simulate the universe would be have the size and energy requirement of the entire universe itself.
- newsbinator 6y ago> The smallest computer to simulate the universe would be have the size and energy requirement of the entire universe itself. There's no reason to think those computers don't exist.
- seventhtiger 6y agoThey definitely don't exist within our universe.
- newsbinator 6y agoIf our universe were a simulation, the computers simulating it would be outside the simulation. We have no idea what constraints those machines would or wouldn't have, since we have no idea what physics they'd be operating under.
- seventhtiger 6y agoThat's true. I'm only arguing against partial simulation within our own universe (eg. The Matrix). Any simulation that has a night sky and telescopes must simulate the full big bang and evolution of galaxies just for the people on Earth.
- scoutt 6y agoWhy the simulated universe should be the same as the universe outside the simulation? If it's the same, perhaps it's shown to us as a fraction of what's real.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WClayFerguson 6y agoIf there's a 'God Computer' that's running our universe, it's much more likely that all it's programmed for is Quantum Mechanics and Gravity, and everything else is purely emergent. I mean we know how everything in chemistry, biology, etc. definitely DOES simply 'emerge' with no 'programming'. People just hear "Sim" and hey think of the "Sims" game. It's not like that. Our 'creator' (Sim programmer) likely didn't even know what any of the life forms would even look like on any specific habitable planet, nor how many planets would even form, etc. prior to 'running it'. And it's even [dare I say] likely, that if we are in a simulated universe it may be the N-trillionth one, and the programmer just finally stumbled across the correct values for the fundamental Standard Model charges, masses, spins, that can result in a stable universe. We do know it's fine tuned, but we don't know if the tuning is purely Anthropic Principle or from many iterations.
- Thorrez 6y ago> All of these factors have led Davoudi to speculate about the simulation hypothesis. If our reality is a simulation, then the simulator is likely also discretizing spacetime to save on computing resources (assuming, of course, that it is using the same mechanisms as our physicists for that simulation). Hmm, crazy idea: What if the EmDrive[1] is powered by simulation error? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24461005 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24461005
- uladzislau 6y agoIt’s interesting how quickly this submission disappeared from the front page, hm. I think the only way to find an answer is to somewhat base it on faith not just pure science. What if the future has already happened (at least some version of it) but the past has never existed like we know it? That’s why the simulation has been used. If the “base” universe/Earth that we live in just appeared a few dozens years ago “as is” out of nowhere then the only way to make it “real” is to actually simulate the past. Mandela effect and predictive programming are actually anomalies in favour of multiple iterations on the simulated past. Now the question is who benefits from this and why? The technologies from the future (which are not distinguished from magic) and antagonist - Devil/Lucifer that is not interested that we see God as the creator or maybe even furthermore to undermine God’s role or maybe even trap him in this reality. This actually also answers the question why we don’t have a proof that God exists because someone put real huge effort to disprove it i.e. here’s a given reality, now how we came here but without God? Apparently all efforts on this failed otherwise we would never even heard about concept of God or simulation. And it also proves that we’re indeed in “base” reality. And because God does exist in this reality the future is not predetermined despite whatever means antagonist is using to prove otherwise.
- scotty79 6y agoI quite like the moral argument against hypothesis that we are living inside a simulation. I read it in Iain M Banks novel. It goes as follows. Any entity technologically advanced enough to simulate our reality wouldn't be immoral enough to create something so morally horrible.
- me_me_me 6y agoHere is an argument for why we are not/ we shouldn't try to run simulation. I haven't seen this argument so maybe its flawed. If we have non-zero chance to live in simulation, then running our own simulation will eventually have a chance for cascading simulation effect (each simulation runs one or more subsimulations). This puts ever growing strain on amount of power needed to run the whole system at the top level. At the top layer it might mean that simulation might be slowed down - time resolution slow downed (un-perceivable to us in simulation) to level where simulation becomes unusable/no value running it. At this point the simulation might be killed/rebooted. So if we have non-zero chance to live in simulation, creating our simulation might mean we are dooming ourselves.
- scotty79 6y agoWhy anyone treats seriously argument "I don't know therefore 50-50"? If there are actually two possibilities and they are mutually exclusive one has exactly 100% chance of being true and the other has exactly 0%. Knowing nothing doesn't let you just take the average. Even if you picked one, you wouldn't have 50% probability of being right. You'd have 0% probability if you picked the wrong one. Only if you picked one at random you'd have 50% probability of being right. You can see that the 50% comes from the process you used to pick the answer not from how the answer relates to reality. Imagine you are tossing a coin to choose what you are going to believe in about whether we live in a simulation or not. Before you toss a coin you have 50% of holding the correct belief. But after you tossed it you have either 100% probability that you hold correct belief or 0% depending on how coin toss aligned with reality.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThe Bayesian view of probability is that the 50% comes from the information you have. If the only thing you know is that there are two mutually-exclusive possibilities, then you'll give both a 50% estimate of being true. The more you learn about the world, the more refined your estimate becomes. But it's important to remember that the "I don't know therefore 50-50" describes your state of mind, not reality.
- hirundo 6y agoWhen I started college there was an orientation lecture by a special guest -- Carl Sagan. He asked us what we thought the probability is that there is life on other planets. The guy sitting next to me mumbled "50-50". Dr. Sagan said "50-50". He said there was no data on either side, and without it, 50-50 was the only probability he could assign to a binary question.
- tim333 6y agoOne thing that makes me think the chances are less than 50:50 is the bit in the book QED by Feynman where he talks about calculating the magnetic moment of a proton. He says at time of printing the experimental value is 2.97275 but the best theoretical value they had was 2.7 plus or minus 0.3 as the calculations were so complicated. The things are full of quarks and gluons going all over the place. If doing one proton is so hard a whole universe is going to be tricky.
- hprotagonist 6y agoOntological Arguments are fun: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ontological-arguments/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ontological-arguments/ Why are we all Gnostics now, though? Moot the arguments themselves for a second, and I’m interested in what their priors reveal about ourselves. The simulation hypotheses seem to assume that we’re likely to be in a situation like the nesting car battery universes from Rick and Morty, and it’s interesting to think a bit about what that valuation of ourselves says about how we see ourselves these days.
- Protostome 6y agoIf we indeed live in a simulation, the creators can just make it impossible for us to detect it. Nothing in this hypotheses make sense to me.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIf you accept someone's totally unverifiable philosophical presuppositions, and believe their assignment of probability numbers to various things in their totally unverified framework, then...
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoAs the prime solipsist I think YOU live in MY imagination. Though I think I need to work on my Zen somewhat, because you tend to mess that up :)(:
- Simulacra 6y agoI have not seen the idea of rules and limitations discussed. Is it possible we could we be falling to a wilderness of mirrors? Take for example observations about our universe. Are they our observations, or the computers presentation of data that we receive as observations? To put it a little more succinctly: What if the only barrier to determining reality from base reality, is that the software will not allow us to view and comprehend that barrier? If we are a simulation, would not the goal be for us to become sentient? Wound the simulation even allow that? Do we even understand the true concept of simulation as it pertains to base reality?
- stevenalowe 6y agoI’d say the odds of this being nonsense is at least five nines. :) If not, what’s to prevent the simulated sentients from developing sufficient simulated technology to simulate their own sentient simulations? The rate of technological advance in the base reality would have to keep pace with the accumulated capacity demands of all nested simulated realities. Compute is not infinite, and sentience is not static. The premise is unsupported
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]