4 ms·
The good school / good neighborhood thing is a self-reinforcing cycle. Wealthy families move to neighborhoods with better schools, increasing local tax revenue,
by ryandrake 6y ago
The good school / good neighborhood thing is a self-reinforcing cycle. Wealthy families move to neighborhoods with better schools, increasing local tax revenue, which gets invested into better and better schools, which attracts even more wealthy families. On the other hand, middle class flight leaves poor families in shitty districts, reducing tax revenue, which means worse and worse schools, which means more middle class flight. The incentives guarantee this will happen.
We need to separate school funding/quality from neighborhood affluence but that's a tall order politically.
- seibelj 6y agoIf we let the money follow the student (aka vouchers) then good schools would sprout up and attract more students and more dollars in a self perpetuating cycle regardless of location. It is immoral that the only students who have the choice of which school they go to are those with rich parents that can select the private school they prefer. For the poor, it’s a derelict monopoly school full of lifers.
- throw9872349872 6y agoBut muh unions!!!1!
- dang 6y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. Could you please stop creating accounts to do that with? We'd appreciate it, because we're trying for something different here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dsd 6y agoI see your argument as avocating for a flavor of wealth redistribution. Is be interested in hearing more, but would prefer to explore the idea in a less polarizing, more academic way. Any sources?
- seibelj 6y agoSchool choice movement, charters, voucher program. If you search for these you will see a lot. A list of relevant articles https://reason.org/author/corey-deangelis/ https://reason.org/author/corey-deangelis/
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoI think school quality is more a factor of the the families economic status than than of how much funding a school gets. I bet if you took took the Cupertino school district families, and transplanted them into a much worse school district, and kept the same teachers, same staff, same buildings, same funding level of school, you would see the school district improve, even without the funding. The issue is the families in poverty don't have the time and energy to care about school. Wealthy families, care about school. So even if the school is crappy, they will make sure their kids learn what they need to. In impoverished school districts, teachers can't concentrate on teaching, because they have to act as both teachers and social workers and advocates for their students. So even if you increased the funding of schools, if you did not address the poverty in the surrounding community, it will mostly be a waste of money and political capital.
- weehoo 6y agoMissouri spent $1.6B in 1980s dollars on the inner city schools in Kansas City. It didn’t do any good. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-03-27-me-51685-story.htmL https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-03-27-me-51685-...
- nradov 6y agoIn California, tax revenue is already redistributed by the state to mostly equalize funding across school districts. Most of that funding comes from state income taxes, not local taxes. https://ed100.org/lessons/whopays https://ed100.org/lessons/whopays In affluent areas the local PTA often gathers donations from parents to fund extra programs for things like sports, music, and technology.