13 ms·
Propaganda, censorship, and surveillance are all attributes of monopoly
- dane-pgp 6y agoThe EU really need to look at the nexus between competition law and data protection regulations. There is already Article 20 of the GDPR[0] which enshrines a "Right to data portability", including a requirement for data to be automatically transmitted from one provider to another, in some cases. It seems to me that mandating federation between social network platforms, using proven open standards, falls within (or very close to) the requirements that such a law already puts onto large data controllers, which should make it an uncontroversial remedy for the EU anti-trust authorities to demand. [0] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-20-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-20-gdpr/
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat you're essentially asking for is the ability of someone to create an account on a service that isn't Facebook, but still be added as a friend by someone on Facebook, view content only available to their friends, share content with Facebook users, send and receive DMs etc. That has the potential to be extremely effective. Anyone using a service solely for the network effect could switch to another one, which could be a large fraction of the users and reintroduce meaningful competition. The biggest problem is protocol complexity. If Facebook adds some kind of timeline feature or anything like that, do they have to add it to the protocol other providers interface with Facebook using? If so, they can stamp out competition by adding so much complexity to the protocol that challengers can't keep up with it. If not, they can add features that challengers can't interface with. And expecting technologically-sideways regulators to arbitrate that sort of thing is a big ask.
- galaxyLogic 6y agoIsn't this what happened with Microsoft network protocols, court ordered them to be made public?
- germinalphrase 6y agoDoes it benefit Facebook in any way to have protocol features that can’t be interface with? Why wouldn’t that result in non-consumption? Sounds like a fun project.
- coldtea 6y ago>Why wouldn’t that result in non-consumption? Because FB consumption happens 99% on their own webpage and mobile client.
- Barrin92 6y agoI think some sort of framework to take your social graph and personal data with you and messaging as a baseline would already be a strong thing. That's really the biggest issue when it comes to switching services, keeping your contacts and primary communication intact.
- bluesign 6y agoWithout interoperability and universal identity, social graph doesn’t help. Universal identity, you can maybe solve with email. But there are problems like requiring using real name, multiple accounts etc Interoperability between messengers will be limited to maybe text and images. Even on this there are huge problems, imagine snapchat vs fb.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoCell service providers had to do it. It wasn't that long ago in the US when you couldn't take your cell phone number to a different provider. Facebook, et al, could provide restricted APIs that let another authorized service gain access to your information via your user identifier. I imagine they provide partial access for favored partners already.
- Karunamon 6y agoCell service is a commodity, though. They effectively act as dumb pipes for sound and data, and although they would like very much to not be that anymore, that is the reason they have customers. Also, there aren't many value-adds to be had at the protocol level. Everything else was already fairly standardized, so adding the number porting stuff on top of that was comparatively easy. What we're talking about here is pure software interop. There is no standard, and any standard that would be devised would become a quickly-outdated albatross around the neck of the developers. Imagine writing code to interface with someone else's crap API, except now you're required to do it by law, and any new feature you come up with has to be either shoehorned into it, or more likely, go through a long and bureaucratic approval process, or even more likely, simply never shipped. Now pretend instead of Facebook, it's your instance of Mastodon that you want to hack on. HN doesn't have the requisite font face options for the magnitude of NO F'ING WAY that is my reaction to getting the government this deep into the nuts and bolts.
- bluesign 6y agoOnly solution is a commodity identity and data provider. But it would never happen. Moderation, cost, legal issues are impossible to handle.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoI am confident that an interface standard could be developed to allow some level of identity portability. Supporting such an interface would be rolled into the myriad other compliance requirements that tech service providers have to deal with these days. (A natural part of being in a maturing consumer facing industry.) Cellphone carriers argued that number portability was too hard or too expensive. "But cell phone companies argue counter that the idea of portability should be scrapped because customers aren’t demanding it. They argue that implementing portability, which involves retooling the software of each carrier’s computerized call-routing system, would be expensive and technically complicated. “The cost to be able to move numbers from one carrier to the other is significant, and it would be significant for the customer too,” said John Scott, deputy general counsel for Verizon Wireless. “Our argument is that it’s not necessary to promote competition.” Carriers Aim to Kill Number Portability - 2002 https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2002-jan-16-fi-cell16-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2002-jan-16-fi-cell1...
- nojokes 6y agoI think this measure worked very well for the mobile network customers.
- im3w1l 6y agoFederating my data with 20 different companies sounds like a privacy disaster.
- minerjoe 6y agoDoesn't Facebook sell your data to over 20 different companies and governments already?
- astura 6y agoNo.
- minerjoe 6y agoYea, probably many more.
- astura 6y agoNo.
- minerjoe 6y agoAnd we pass the burden of proof along like a hot-potato... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana... https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-gave-some-companies-preferential-user-data-according-to-uk-parliament/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-gave-some-companies-pr... https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/politics/fact-check/2019/02/15/facebook-business-but-does-sell-your-personal-data/2701066002/ https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/politics/fact-check/201... > But some researchers dispute that ad-targeting is any different than selling data. > "As a data scientist, I am shocked that anyone continues to believe this claim," wrote Michael Kosinski, assistant professor at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business, in a New York Times opinion piece. "Every time you click on a Facebook ad, Facebook sells data on you to that advertiser." > "This is such a basic property of online targeted advertising that it would be impossible to avoid, even if Facebook somehow wanted to."
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoArticle 20 portability is always initiated by the user who owns the data. Federation between social network platforms is very different, because it means swapping personal data not initiated by the user - when a friend loads my profile page, my node sends my personal data to her node. In fact, I'd argue that's simply a GDPR violation unless all of the federated nodes have mutually verified each others' compliance.
- dane-pgp 6y agoIf federated nodes have to mutually verify each others' compliance, then every email server in the EU is breaking the law. Presumably the reason email servers can operate legally is that the sender of each email is deemed to be the data controller or is otherwise giving explicit consent to their private data being sent to each recipient's mail provider. Social networking is roughly equivalent to the sending of emails BCCed to everyone in your address book. In the case of something like Twitter-style microblogging, the GDPR is even less relevant since the user is deliberately trying to make information publicly available.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI think the sender of each email is definitely giving explicit consent. When I type out "To: foo@example.com", I'm directing my email provider to send my email to the example.com server. That's fundamentally different than the Facebook model, where some information is public and anyone at all can request it, even if they're not in my address book. I agree that you could probably make Facebook with no public pages work, or something like Twitter where there's minimal public information in the first place.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAuthor. I'm noodling on notions, and some recent commentary by Cory Doctorow sparked much of this, or rather, gave cause to expand a recent HN comment. This is quite possibly wrong in parts or whole. Critiques welcomed. Though it seems fairly clear that the ills dominating recent discussions of the Internet and media aren't merely incidental to monopoly but integral to it. And that monopoly itself is a control structure. The question's been raised in discussion elsewhere about whether or not smaller / cloistered discussions might also give rise to propaganda. My thinking is "possibly, but likely to a lesser degree'. See, e.g., https://rollenspiel.social/@ArneBab/105027882621910913 https://rollenspiel.social/@ArneBab/105027882621910913 And Rhysy's comment on the linked article, "I think diversity is necessary but not sufficient": https://joindiaspora.com/posts/7bfcf170eefc013863fa002590d8e506#794da060ef5f01388a1d005056264835 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/7bfcf170eefc013863fa002590d8e...
- clairity 6y agoi'd suggest some more fleshing out to be meaty and coherent enough to comment substantially. but a general critique would be that the term "monopoly control" seems constraining, when what you seem to be talking about more generally is centralization (vs. decentralization). the connection to the economic concept of monopoly (which, for that one commenter who will otherwise insist, is not one company crowding out all others in a market, but rather a company having effective control of a market regardless of relative size) seems tenuous at best. how is propaganda, censorship, and surveillance inherent properties of an entity controlling the friend social network market (i.e., facebook) rather than an inherent property of the centralization of social networks (for instance)?
- dredmorbius 6y agoCan you think of an example of monopoly which does not entail centralisation? For regulatory purposes in the US, "monopoly" does not match either your definition nor the one I was taught in my intermediate microeconomics coursework. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625775 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625775 Courts do not require a literal monopoly before applying rules for single firm conduct; that term is used as shorthand for a firm with significant and durable market power — that is, the long term ability to raise price or exclude competitors. That is how that term is used here: a "monopolist" is a firm with significant and durable market power. https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/monopolization-defined https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a... Propaganda, censorsship, and surveillance are not the only concerns regarding monopoly. But within the media and communications domain, it seems that the problems and market-power structure are inherently linked. If there are any other points needing addressing I'd be happy to hear them.
- mellosouls 6y agoI clicked on the link assuming it was about the board game :) Maybe the title (which I assume was clipped for HN length) might be more of a draw for some here using the plural ("Monopolies") or "Monopoly Control" as used in the article a few times? Maybe not, just flagging it fwiw.
- dredmorbius 6y agoMonopoly as concept rather than monopolies as instances. Though yes, titling is hard.
- choward 6y agoOr even "a Monopoly". Using it like they did leaves no other interpretation really than it being the name of something.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- acituan 6y agoIt seems like the way author uses them, propaganda, censorship and surveillance are just versions of propagation, filtering and signal acquistion with a corrupt intent attributed. They are just basic elements of any information processing system. > Speakers and Audiences — a public — divided across independent networks, with access to different editorial selection, from different distribution networks, with access to different input message streams, are far less subject to propaganda, censorship, or surveillance. Epistemic diversity resists control. One downside is if factions can’t reconcile their views we get into heavy information warfare between little echo chambers like we do today, and we haven’t seem the downstream consequences of this in full effect. The AIs of the “non-mainstream” information channels we use, twitter, youtube, facebook, reddit, instagram etc, are very good at diverisfying their information streams to micro-target individuals, but with absolutely the wrong objective function; to increase engagement, not to increase sensemaking. The result is more stratified cultural factions with little hope of reconciliation and conversation in between. And for certain things, the reality has the monopoly we strive to converge to. Scientific process doesn’t necessarily reward diversity, but it reliably rewards relevance and approaching to reality. For matters like how covid spread, whether masks worked etc, we would have loved to subjected ourselves to the monopoly of what it really was in itself, but instead we made another information warfare out of it, heavily politicized every bit of data, causing tons of unnecessary human death suffering in between. Therefore the problem is not the topology of the information network, but the incentive scheme driving the network. Today we all answer to the normativity of markets, not patriotism, not religion, not intellectual honesty, merely markets, so changing the shape of the network would achieve so little to change the downstream consequences.
- john_moscow 6y agoI am pretty certain, if our society manages to survive the current times, our attitude to centralization and globalization will change. On the surface, it increases efficiency through central management and automation, lowering the prices and making products more affordable. One layer deeper, it commoditizes people's time, making them more replaceable and lowering what one's salary can buy even longer. If you look even deeper, you see that when people are not spending their passion trading, making deals, and creating things others would want to buy, they instead turn on each other. If your work doesn't keep your mind busy, it finds a different outlet, that seems to be driven by some primal tribal instincts. Team up with the ones of your kind and go against the neighboring tribe. Call me paranoid, but we might see another Fall of Rome in our lifetimes.
- fabianhjr 6y ago> commoditizes people's time, making them more replaceable and lowering what one's salary can buy even longer Commodification of people is treated extensibly in anticapitalist writings. ( https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Commodification https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Commodification ) > Call me paranoid, but we might see another Fall of Rome in our lifetimes. There is a more moderate stance of American Decline ( https://www.wikiwand.com/en/American_decline https://www.wikiwand.com/en/American_decline ) that has been a source of sourness to many US nationalists
- netcan 6y agoThe word "capitalism," in our lifetime has two fairly distinct meanings. One meaning is marxist. Marx popularised the term and he implicitly defined it as an economic-political system and "that which we are fighting against." Most of his writing and communist contemporaries was about corruption and cruelty of this newly described system. In marxist capitalism, when a monopolist bribes a government official this is capitalism par excellence. The premise of the term is that "capital rules," so regulatory capture is assumed The other meaning is pro-capitalist. These mostly riff on Adam Smith. David Ricardo responded directly to marx and provides some technical ammo. By Ayn Rand, "capitalism" it has a full blown utopian definition like communism. Regulatory capture is seen as a corruption of "true" capitalism. Anyway... the two frames are highly related to eachother.
- jeisc 6y agohuman life will persist as long as the environment permits it but what future form it will take remains unknown and perhaps would not please our common current cultural tastes
- jeisc 6y agothe ancient base of Greek and Roman civilization persists to this day in the West even if the major empires have changed hands many times! The West is still studying Plato and Aristotle...
- gerland 6y ago"Industrial Society and its Future", "Ride the Tiger". Good night.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe first is Ted. Who is the second? Evola? Any specific elements?
- gerland 6y agoYes, Evola. The first few chapters about nihilism are probably the most relevant. Keep in mind that if you want to strawman this on, it's very easy. Filter out the Kali Yuga, etc. stuff if this is not to your liking and the rest is still pretty informative.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThanks.
- Der_Einzige 6y agoGood old "actually I'm not a fascist, I'm a super fascist" evola...
- gerland 6y agoThere is nothing more than one can say about Evola that wasn't said before. You can pretty much go to his page on Wikipedia and the first few paragraphs sound like a hit piece. I will say that everything is true, even the things that I know for sure are not. It does not matter, in the end there he is, popular as never before. "The truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is." inb4 > Churchill was a fascist, let's tear down his statues.
- 082349872349872 6y agoTIL that's at least a paraphrase, possibly even a direct quote. To be charitable, even to someone who loved hierarchy and hated raves, I'm guessing he probably meant "superfascist" not as in "supercomputer" but as in "supersonic."
- narag 6y agoI suspect that desire for decentralization is motivated by wanting Facebook without Facebook. I've never have an account, I don't tweet, I don't care about centralization. So I guess there could be a connection. About propaganda, there are some kinds of person that never miss the opportunity to tell you what they think about their pet topic. Any community that doesn't allow to ignore them is bad for mental health. It used to work for thematic forums, with rules about off-topic. If the topic is more open, politics creep in.
- znpy 6y agoIn a way, yes. I dropped my Facebook account, only interact with Twitter and mastodon from time to time and can see your point. But the thing is, once you are in Facebook you get to see that most of the world propaganda is there and the whole platform is conditioned (and monetized, but not on your interest). So you get to see the benefits of a platform like Facebook and the evil of facebook (the platform) being Facebook (the company).
- cryptica 6y agoIt's terrible that a lot of investors are now being told to diversify their portfolio. Diversification is the root of all evil and creates hidden oligopolies. If the same investors own shares of all major corporations, then it creates a strong incentive for those corporations to collaborate with each other instead of competing. This is probably why we ended up with companies like Google and Apple making employee non-poaching agreements with each other - There is enough shareholder overlap between the two companies that these illegal agreements benefit the majority shareholders of both companies.
- dredmorbius 6y agoHow does this relate to the article?
- cryptica 6y agoIsn't it obvious? Diversification leads to monopolization which leads to surveillance, which leads to propaganda and censorship and loss of civil liberties. Until we understand the root causes, we are headed towards either mass censorship or revolution. My comment could not be more useful or relevant. If most people think like this and don't see the obvious link, then we are surely headed for disaster.
- cryptica 6y agoThe great irony of this is that even people who think that they're on the winning side of this trend and who are benefiting from monopolization right now are going to be in for a big shock when they realize that they no longer have the freedom to sell their own company shares or use their own money as they please. The employee and the passive shareholder will always get screwed over in the end. Always. Surveillance and control will extend to absolutely everyone. Even the top 1%. Freedom and control will be in the hands of a tiny number of people. You can already see signs of this today. Now they manipulate people through thought leadership and the media, but once people have given up their basic freedoms, corporations will be able to coerce people at will. It will not be your shares or your money anymore because what you will be able to do with them will be severely restricted. It will all be done in the name of financial stability and safety.
- netcan 6y agoA depressing aspect of this is that our toolbag is mostly empty. The few rusty old tools we have are not very good. On the antitrust side... Courts and antitrust law are completely ill equipped to deal with modern monopoly. Everything must be funneled through a 19th century lens. On the regulatory side... it might be even worse. We need to keep in mind that regulators are usually monopoly enforcing. Look at banks, traditional media, etc. The difference between a regulated fb and an unregulated one may be that fb can blame the regulator for censorship. This is how it works in a bank. Whatever mindless bureaucracy exists, everyone can just claim it's mandated. Meanwhile, it makes competition less likely. A "privacy preferences" popup approach will not help us with our monopoly problem. Courts: The recent EU adwords case is a great example. They found unequivocally that adwords monopolises search ads, and use this monopoly to suppress competing search engines who have to sell ads on the adwords network. Google got a $1.5bn fine. Similar cases against amazon marketplace. To Google, it's a cost of doing business, and google would have undoubtedly paid that much just to get the narrow benefits proven in court. Monopolies are not a narrow phenomenon though. Whatever can be proved in court is the tip of an iceberg, almost by definition. If courts focus on the narrow (they are), then maneuvering around court decisions is trivial. Meanwhile, consider this: If Toyota (workers, machines.. everything) fell of the disc tomorrow, the world would have less auto manufacturing capacity. It would take time and resources to rebuild. If facebook fell off the disc, the social media vacuum would be filled near instantly. There would be no social media supply issues. This is where modern monopolies depart from 19th century monopolies. Courts may have wanted to liberalize (eg) the market for steel, but they didn't want to crash it. We still needed their steel. We don't really need facebook's "steel." Whether fb makes $100bn on ads or 1% of that, we will have plenty of social media. There is no (public interest) reason to step (on fb) lightly, but courts can't really make these distinctions. IMO, the only answer is to act against size itself, and make decisions on a case-by-case basis. Also IP. Say Tesla does get to self driving years ahead of everyone because data... do they now get a monopoly forever? The poverty of our public domain is going to become increasingly relevant. Given, for example, that AMZN "are the market" in a meaningful sense, why not make their sales data disclosable. That data is being proven in court to be a monopolistically potent. Give other market participants access. Advertising even moreso. This data is of major public interest
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI'll copy parts of my response to the dear Doctor when (initial draft of?) it was posted on Mastodon: 1: Propaganda is not (no longer?) limited to centralized control. Advertising is an example of fully decentralized propaganda, where the actors don't have any kind of real central control, but if their goals align, they'll amplify a single message to the level much larger than a monopoly ever could. Perhaps we could call it mob-style propaganda. Mobaganda? 2: The way I feel it, propaganda is about making a large group of people believe things that aren't true, but benefit some other group of people. Said beneficiaries of the propaganda may be the original source of the message - but even historically, propaganda only works if some of the audience believes it and starts convincing/socially pressuring others into believing it too. So the core operational element here is just a meme that spreads. Centralization is orthogonal. -- Basically, I feel that old school propaganda was just a way to forcefully spread a selected meme. It happened in an era where most media was unidirectional - from a small group of people operating newspapers, radio and television, to a large group of people who could only view it and perhaps comment between each other, but their response wasn't broadcast to a wide audience. These days, with our hyperconnected social media where everyone is a publisher of thoughts, memes can spread without much effort. You don't need force of a central power anymore for an idea to travel; memes amplify themselves now, as they spread through our bidirectional media. And this means not only that propaganda isn't restricted to a central power, but also that it doesn't have to have any intent behind it. All it takes is for someone to accidentally craft a meme that resonates with people, and it'll get amplified. If it incidentally benefits a group of people, that group will ensure it gets amplified further. The problem is, said meme doesn't have to be in any way correct, reasonable, or corresponding to observable reality.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Advertising is an example of fully decentralized propaganda Not at all. Centralization is absolutely crucial to deliver advertising. Getting a bigger audience to attract larger advertisers is what pushed newspapers, radios, television channels and finally web services to become behemoths.
- Nasrudith 6y ago
- aasasd 6y agoIt feels like the entire current deal about monopolies is instead about massive centralization even if it's not technically monopolies. Specifically: - the post really talks about cohesive platforms of all sizes: a topical forum can easily have the same aspects even though members may migrate at any time. - countries might come out of the current ruckus with an understanding that massive centralization and platforms is something to worry about, in a lawmaking and enforcing way, even if it's not monopolies. Because it's a centralization of power, albeit indirect power so far. Of course, this problem is just what cyberpunk prophesized, so it's interesting to see how countries deal with expanding rule of corporations: namely if the US rethinks or confirms its position that corporations are just fine.
- golergka 6y agoFirst and foremost, it's about the only organisation with monopoly on violence: the government. No commercial monopoly could maintain it's position without regulation. Solving the problem by giving even more power to the government is a completely backwards solution that will only bring even more of all this in the long run.
- meekmind 6y agoI think ancaps have very compelling arguments and I tend to agree with them. Corporations privatize their profits (to themselves) and socialize their risk (to government). Eliminate the ability to socialize their risk and it's incumbent upon corporations to respond to market forces, creating competition, reducing barriers of entry, etc. This all makes sense to me from a free-market perspective. From my experience the ancap positions are the most philosophically consistent, taking into account the large majority of economic and ethical variables. The only problem I have with ancaps is that they usually fail to acknowledge the third rail of politics and as such fall into the same trap as the libertarians. It's one thing to envision a system which minimizes authoritarianism and maximizes personal liberty. It's another thing to actually implement that system from where we are, not where we would like to be. For example, if we minimize (or abolish) government too early, we create a vacuum which invariably will be filled by existing corporate combines. I'll add this argument has been made before by ancaps against libertarianism, so the problem isn't exactly foreign to them. In contrast, break up the corporate combines without also reducing the power and authority of the state and we temporarily fix the monopoly problem while leaving the door wide open for the exact same thing to repeat (as we are seeing today). There are undoubtedly smarter people than me working on this problem but in my estimation it's absolutely critical for ancaps to outline incremental steps (in the correct order) towards the solution and not fall on their swords because those incremental steps may not represent the most philosophically pure end result from the outset (like what's happened with libertarians).
- dredmorbius 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24779491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24779491
- tannhaeuser 6y agoI don't know why we need to attribute these properties to monopolies when a monopoly is in itself a bad thing. Also, I don't see concrete measures to end monopolies being mentioned. Maybe it's time to realize that our industry has left the innovation phase, and is into consolidation. In this environment, legislation is well advised to look into mechanisms for a regulated market given the extreme importance of digital platforms and markets (which are the only ones having growth). And perhaps states should also play a much stronger role in setting standards rather than leaving that in a mixture of naivite and corruption to failed initiatives of market participants (such as the wannabe standard bodies W3C and WHATWG with disastrous results). After all, if "national security" (of the US, that is) is an argument to block market participants, and the web being monopolized, there's no point in pretending international trade or other fair trading rules apply.
- mjburgess 6y agoWhy is a monopoly in itself a bad thing? A monopoly on violence is an extremely good thing: its absence is called a "civil war".
- kazagistar 6y agoThere is no monopoly on violence because the state is non monolithic, and because much of the violence is outsourced to subcontractors with limited oversight. More importantly, monopoly on violence by the state is only good if the control of the state is distributed democratically to all affected by it, ie, if the control over violence is redistributed to all people equally. If violence is held in a monopoly by a small group of individuals for their personal benefit... then civil war is a better option. And corporations are structurrd exactly like that sort of despotism.
- mjburgess 6y agoLikewise for any monopoly. A monopoly is not all-consuming monolith (ie., a totalitarian state). Either way, my point was precisely that there are conditions on monopolies that make them beneficial. And hence the "in itself" condition fails.
- crazypython 6y agoHow is diaspora compared to a federating solution like Mastodon or Plemora? Both are powered by ActivityPub, a W3C standard. I've used Mastodon and it works well.
- diegoholiveira 6y ago> All three problems have the same effective solution: Break up the monopolies. One thing here it's not clear to me: this include the monopoly of force holds by governments?
- dredmorbius 6y agoKeep in mind all of Weber's definition. Government has a monopoly on the claim to legitimate use of force. All elements of this statement are crucial. The Libertarian objection neglects to consider "claim", "legitimate", and most aspects of "monopoly". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16953184 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16953184
- diegoholiveira 6y ago> Government has a monopoly on the claim to legitimate use of force. All elements of this statement are crucial. I do agree and understand that, and I'm not a libertarian. My main issue here is that big governments has the same issues than big companies. We must break then all, not only big companies. My provocation was about that, not the use of force per si, so I may use the wrong words in the previous post.
- qwerty456127 6y agoHow can a [assumingly benevolent] state survive without using propaganda, censorship, and surveillance today, when all the other states, as well as malicious parties within itself would inevitably deploy propaganda, censorship, and surveillance against it? This is a genuine question. I would love propaganda, censorship, and surveillance to be non-existent but I can't really see a viable alternative. That would be cool if we could make the people immune to propaganda by means of education but I'm sure there will always be plenty of people who would remain easy to manipulate.
- frankish 6y agoI think setting an example and keeping to your principles is the right approach. Naivety won't go away, but things will continue to improve in the long run.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'd suggest that this is a separate though related question. My essay concerns the fact that propaganda (and other activities, often but not at all exclusively the domain of state actors) rely on and exploit monopoly structures. One fairly obvious corollary is that "if you build it", where "it" os a communications or information network exhibiting monopoly control points, "they will come", they being propagandists, censors, and surveillors. Which is pretty much what Shoshana Zuboff was writing in the 1980s, see her eponymous laws. That states and other large organisations (see: Congregatio de Propaganda Fide, the IBM songbook, etc.) rely on propaganda, censorship, and surveillance (James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State), means that yes, they effectively operate in a competitive and selective landscaape in which if they don't develop such capabilities, or countermeasures against them, their adversaries will. This will happen through the most monopolistic communications structures available, whhich is my point.
- 082349872349872 6y agoHaving recently read a translation of the Rule of Benedict, I'll note that when Benedict disparages people coming together with like-minded others to form faith communities (Sarabaites, Ch. 1), he says "They live ... without a shepherd, in their own sheepfolds and not in the Lord’s," which I believe may be interpreted as a complaint about the lack of propaganda, censorship, and surveillance in their living arrangements. Samples, by no means exhaustive: propaganda https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#chapter-38-nl-on-the-weekly-reader https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#c... censorship https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#chapter-54-nl-whether-a-monk-should-receive-letters-or-anything-else https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#c... surveillance https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#chapter-22-nl-how-the-monks-are-to-sleep https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50040/50040-h/50040-h.html#c...
- boxed 6y agoConspiracy theory, anti-vaxx, cults, ignorance are all attributes of a lack of a monopoly. Like always there is a balance to be made.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThese can form without a monopoly. They're generally promoted and amplified by systems optimising for something other than epistemic validity: advertising, engagement, political interest, interest marketing, etc., etc.
- 75dvtwin 6y agoI agree with this. And would like to extend it a bit further. In the instances where each of these 3 attributes (Propaganda, censorship & surveillance) -- are also essential part of a business model -- I would call those specific large businesses as Super-Monopolies. If we look at any large and successful business that has the above, plus is in the business of end-user Advertisement (that is in the business of promoting one thing over another .. that's advertisement for end consumers). It fits into a 'super-monopoly' bucket. It must surveil (to understand the target audience), and it must do it covertly. It must censor (remove, downplay, gray-out content that does not fit the business model, or, as we see lately, the political bias of the org's leadership) It has to monopolize the market place, so that every end-user 'walks through a single door'. It will use propaganda to pacify critical thinkers, and to mislead folks with less developed 'critical thinking' -- that they are 'not a monopoly by any stretch', that they are just and fair, and hard working... As that's a necessary function to survive in a system with anti-trust laws. - - - What is, of course, very notable about these 3 attributes -- that they are also a must for Dictatorships and Monarchy style of government. - - - If the above is an accepted analogy. There are 2 positions about it ( a) -- that's good, continue on (b) no, that's bad, we need to have constitutional checks that this cannot happen, even if most powerful people try to do it. - - - So what could constitution (assuming that it cannot be changed) could look like to prevent a 'country-wide' analogy of a monopoly - a Dictatorship? - - - Well, the first thing, is to agree, that no matter how fair-minded, or 'saint' a person is -- given enough power, he/she will get corrupt. That applies for groups of people as well as for individual. - - - Therefore, the first solution -- is power distribution. Under no circumstances political, economic and military power can be concentrated within the power of the same group of people. That means 'de-centralization', and more practically 'de-urbanization'. Meaning that having small geographical areas and their elected representative wielding most power is good for Dictatorship. So a Constitution must prevent that. The nuance there is what is 'economic power'. Well that's mostly means, control of tax revenue, and control of within country trade. Therefore, a good constitution, to avoid corruption would: - Prohibit same group of people to control tax revenue, to control laws of intra-country trades - Prohibit same group of people (as above) from having control of military force. And prevent military from interfering within the border. - Prohibit same group of from forcing a 'single choice' of any article of commerce, education, health. - Prohibit same group from enforcing any emigration choices (meaning if the person wants to leave the country, they can). -- Other thing that a good Constitution would do, is to enable the voting citizens to be the 'final backstop', the final judge to decide if actions of elected officials are constitutional or not,.. the final police police, acting as a threat with force, speaking allegorically. With regard to comment > I am pretty certain, if our society manages to survive the current times, our attitude to centralization and globalization will change I think it may be more nuance. Or at least, I am trying to come up with the framework that will let me understand if the country will change and how... I am speculating, that has to do with 'critical thinking' abilities of voting public... I have came to read somewhere, that critical thinking is more like an 'immune system'. We are not born with it, instead ,it develops over time, by experience. When meeting with bad, malignant information, manipulation and lies. Just like immune system that gets stronger when surviving infections deceases. Critical thinking does not directly correlate to our cognitive gifts, just like immune system may not be a reflection of visible physiological gifts. With that analogy, we can say there always be a portion of voting population (due to age, particular environment that they were brought up, fear, etc.) -- that will have somewhat reduced critical thinking (or have in decline) compared to others. That is, those folks have reduced cognitive immunity to being manipulated. And that deficiency can change (improve or get worse) over time... (it is not static). Depending on how string & aggressive the malignant manipulation of people is in a particular period -- and depending on the percentage of folks with delayed development of critical thinking at that same period -- we will have different outcomes. It is that ratio of how virulent manipulative malignancy is, divided by percent of voting population with underdeveloped critical thinking, that will decide the outcome for a country in a particular time period. - - - Without claiming an affinity to a particular side in the current US politics, I would say that it appears (at least to me ), that percentage of voting public with underdeveloped critical thinking, is higher now than was say 35 years ago or so. If we can agree on the percentage of underdeveloped critical thinkers in the current voting population. Then if we can agree on the measure of malignant manipulation (that, underneath reflects stakes) Then if we agree and find these ratios in other consequential historical periods. We will be able to 'predict' what will happen, with, hopefully, better certainty. I know this may easily fall into confirmation bias, as we start picking and choosing the percentages, etc. But nevertheless, I hope the above represents a 'framework' to apply.