3 ms·
Consumer inflation actually is inflation, by definition. This isn't being confused, this is understanding how inflation is defined and using terms correctly. I
by skybrian 6y ago
Consumer inflation actually is inflation, by definition. This isn't being confused, this is understanding how inflation is defined and using terms correctly.
Inflation is about the prices people actually pay, on average. Your neighbor's house getting sold for a lot of money isn't a real cost to you like rent. Someone paid that price, but they are not necessarily typical.
Inflation does include rent (or "imputed rent") to the extent that people actually pay those prices on average. Some people really do pay higher rents, but many others have lower housing costs locked in via home ownership or rent control, and they count too, so this is going to drag down the average. That's just the nature of averages.
BTW, stock market indexes are an average too, and it's heavily weighted towards tech firms due to market capitalization. Only about half of the stocks in the S&P 500 are up for the year.
- pedro_hab 6y agoThis is the new definition, in old dictionaries inflation was defined as increase in money supply. Using products to measure inflation, is a terrible mistake in my estimation, because cost has been falling, so stable prices don't mean no inflation. It just means the governments got wise to just take what they can get without being noticed.
- pjc50 6y ago.. how old a dictionary are we talking here? It's not a recent change.
- pedro_hab 6y agoProbably 100 years old, I don't remember exactly, but it is not recent at all.
- RobertoG 6y agoYou can't define inflation as you want. Inflation is an government official indicator with a very clear meaning.
- dnautics 6y agodo you always trust the government's definitions of things? Suppose the government defined "eastern time zone" to be a geographical area. And you live in western indiana, and commute to work in chicago. Suppose the government defined "torture" to not include "waterboarding".
- RobertoG 6y agoThat's not my point. My point is that if we don't agree in a definition of inflation, how can we have a rational discussion? And there is a clear textbook definition of inflation.
- dnautics 6y agoRight but that definition has drifted. That's not necessarily a problem in and of itself but in the process of drifting in this case it has obscured the original definition, which now is orphaned without a label. The problem therein is that it's left the discourse; since the subject of the old definition is more likely to precede and be a cause of the subject of the new definition, it seriously muddies the discourse and arguably the modes of thinking about the solution.
- pedro_hab 6y agoI didn't define as I want to, I pointed to the fact that the meaning in old dictionaries used to be increase in money supply. My point doesn't depend on this tho, measuring inflation by rising prices isn't ideal, because you will be measuring multiple things at once, and only the people lose in that case. Prices can rise and fall for multiple reasons, and knowing why helps to fix it. If the price goes up because of a shortage, the increase in price helps stimulate more production. Governments get the advantage of being able to inflate the money supply to the point were it prevents prices from falling, ensuring easier reelection at the price of the people paying more for things and effectively taxing savers.
- RobertoG 6y ago
- skybrian 6y agoIt was once thought that the money supply was directly related to inflation, but they were never the same thing. The classic equation was MV = PY, and M (the money supply) and P (the price level) are different. They are only proportional (according to this equation) if everything else remains the same. In any case, the "money supply" is an abstract macroeconomic variable with multiple possible definitions. Why do we care about it? Because it might have a real-world effect on us via price changes. Gathering data about prices directly is a better way of understanding price levels (and inflation) than mucking around with less measurable quantities. To the extent that the money supply matters, it's because it might result in higher prices in the future. But this doesn't seem to happen in any mechanical way. Just because people have money doesn't mean they want to spend it. In the classic equation, V (the velocity of money) can slow down. This is particularly true when we are talking about institutions and rich people who already have savings. Higher numbers in their bank accounts doesn't automatically result in more spending, either by them, by the banks, or by companies whose stock prices get bid up. It would matter more if the money went to people who actually need to spend it.
- pedro_hab 6y agoI think we agree on the point, but disagree in the definitions. Money supply inflation might not directly influence price inflation, though we see price inflation in asset prices, such as stocks and properties. My point is more on the government saying it needs inflation, when even without price increases inflation might be happening. We have increasing productivity, cost has been falling, so if prices stay fixed, therefore no price inflation, the people are still paying more than they should. The value of things have been falling, but prices haven't.
- skybrian 6y agoWhen the Federal Reserve said that a little more inflation is acceptable, they were talking about the Consumer Price Index. It’s not that price increases are good in themselves, but that it would be good if people spent more, and if it results in prices being a little higher, this is okay.
- 6y ago
- UncleEntity 6y ago> Consumer inflation actually is inflation, by definition. This isn't being confused, this is understanding how inflation is defined and using terms correctly. They fail to make a distinction between monetary inflation and price inflation which is the reason for the (intended) confusion around the term 'inflation'.