5 ms·
Warren Buffett is now betting against the US dollar
- ra 16y agoI can't see one single indicator to suggest that the USD isn't in a long term decline. The only reason this isn't yet glaringly obvious to everyone, is that the Euro and GBP are also stuck on a downward trend. Speculatively, I believe the Euro and GBP will 'save' themselves out of trouble within the next 5-7 years, whereas the US will practically have to reinvent the earnings foundation of it's entire economy before it can break out of this current downward spiral of excessive debt.
- ck2 16y agoTime to start hording mid-1900's coins eh? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junk_silver#Common_U.S._coins http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junk_silver#Common_U.S._coins
- presidentender 16y agoThe time to start that was years ago. When I started.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoWhy does the US have to reinvent its earnings foundation and the EU and the UK don't? I believe the US dollar is in a long term downward trend because it is slowly slowly losing its reserve currency status as the US is losing its economic predominance. That's not a bad thing. It's just a reflection of Asia becoming less bad economically, which is neither difficult nor surprising considering how bad they used to be.
- anonymous246 16y agoMy uneducated two cents: 1) The USA's economy is "financialized" to a much greater extent than Europe's. 2) Lots of "phantom" GDP in USA which makes US "productivity" and per-capita GDP look higher than corresponding Europe figures (it's not an "apples to apples comparison"), thereby hiding US economy's weaknesses (e.g., high college tuition costs, health insurance costs, high healthcare costs (paid out by insurance companies to hospitals), doctor liability insurance etc all inflate the GDP but the corresponding figures for Europe are smaller).
- lupatus 16y agoThe USA is not going to lose its reserve currency status because it will continue being the world's sole superpower for the for the next 30 - 100 years, at least. For an in-depth analysis, see: http://www.singularity2050.com/2008/06/why-the-us-will-still-be-the-only-superpower-in-2030-v20.html http://www.singularity2050.com/2008/06/why-the-us-will-still...
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoI don't doubt the strength of the US economy or its military power, but in relative terms the US is slowly getting less important. The article doesn't dispute that. It just says that it will take a long time until anyone will surpass the US. Also, the article works on the assumption of linear development, which is kind of questionable, but that's a different story. The US used to be the biggest user of commodities, so it was pretty logical that the dollar should be the currency in which commodities are priced. Today China is the biggest user of commodities and it is only logical that countries like Brazil are going to take a little more RMB in exchange for their iron ore than they used to. And considering they import a lot of stuff from China as well, why should they sell their RMB for USD immediately? They won't. Exchange rates are not based on absolutes but on relative strength. So the question is not wether the USD will or will not lose its reserve currency status. The question is how fast. My totally scientific characterization of that pace was "slowly slowly".
- lupatus 16y agoThe USA, however, isn't exactly "declining". As the article I linked to above noted, the USA is continuing to grow across a broad spectrum of measures. Yes, China and the EU may be growing at a faster rate in some of those categories, but the USA has such a great initial advantage that it will be a long, long time until another country catches or surpases the USA in even one of those categories. So, let us take your simplified example and expand it a little to see a broader macroeconomic picture that illustrates why Brazil and China would want to do that trade in dollars. Let's say that Brazil wants to use the cash from that commodity sale to improve the living conditions of their citizens and purchase some Catepillar brand forest-clearing bulldozers and some crude oil to refine into gasoline for those bulldozers because their local sugar-cane ethanol would wear-out the engines too quickly. Well, Catepillar is a American company so it makes sense for them to bill Brazil in USD instead RMB. The middle east oil exporter also charges Brazil in USD because the US Navy protects their shipping lanes and the CIA and State Dept maintains (or doesn't) the internal stability of that country. Last, China has USD coming out of its ears and is more than happy to trade pieces of paper for real assets like Brazillian ore. Now, why would the Chinese want Brazil to pay them in USD for some Chinese goods? The Chinese are smart and recognize that if the USD sank too far in value that the manufacturing jobs in China would return to the USA. This is a problem for the Communists because they do not have a sufficient internal economy to continue employing hundreds of millions of peasants. And, that would be a dangerous political problem for the Communist leadership in China. Now, I will agree that this assumes linear development, but it would take a situation like WWII to knock the USA out of reserve currency status, and I don't think that is very likely. In conclusion, welcome to Pax Americana; you should learn to love it.
- espeed 16y agoFor a different perspective, see... 1. "Credit Suisse: America Is Not Broke" (http://pragcap.com/credit-suisse-america-is-not-broke http://pragcap.com/credit-suisse-america-is-not-broke) 2. "Understanding The Modern Monetary System" (http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-system http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-s...).
- Lost_BiomedE 16y agoPeople saying America is broke are looking at future obligations. Doing this, the 12T figure presented by the Credit Suisse link is a joke. The obligations that become current will rise so fast that GDP and household wealth have no chance in catching up and alleviating them. Add in our current run rate, and it is the straw that broke the camels back.
- espeed 16y agoThere is more to it than that -- read the article it links to about "Understanding the Modern Monetary System" (http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-s... http://pragcap.com/resources/understanding-modern-monetary-s...). "Government deficit spending and tax collection should be maintained at a rate that does not impose financial hardship on the private sector. Because the Federal government is not a state or household it should not manage its balance sheet for its own benefit. Rather, taxes and government spending should be managed in a way that most benefits the private sector and encourages private sector prosperity." "The key takeaway here is that the government balance sheet is not like a household or a state. It does not finance spending via revenues or debt issuance. The US government, as a monopoly supplier of currency in a floating exchange rate system never really has nor doesn’t have money."
- Lost_BiomedE 16y agoYes, it is a, broke relative to what. If human costs are not taken into account, it is a much easier equation.
- espeed 16y agoTo understand what's going on, make sure you read the last sentence on the first page, continue on to the second page, and then watch this Charlie Rose interview with Gordon Brown (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Brown http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Brown) where he also talks about the US/China "currency wars" and the "race to the bottom" (http://www.charlierose.com/view/interview/11343 http://www.charlierose.com/view/interview/11343). China artificially lowers its currency so its goods are relatively cheaper ("it's pegged to the dollar"), which keeps its foreign trade prices down and therefore boosts its exports. So how does the US "compete" with an artificially-lowered foreign currency to discount its debt and keep its exports up? Or, in other words, how does the US devalue its own currency in a "race to the bottom"...?
- fingerprinter 16y agoSo, are you saying that this is a good thing? I don't quite follow. Care to give a TL;DR explanation for those of us with more programming sense than fiscal sense?
- espeed 16y agoI'm saying it's the reality of an emerging "economic war" between China and the US. In the article, Kenneth Rogoff (http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/rogoff/ http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/rogoff/), a Harvard economics professor and former chief economist at the International Monetary Fund, says "A weak dollar isn’t necessarily a bad thing -- it can make the United States more competitive, bolster exports and help domestic companies that are vying against imported goods here in the United States." The article goes on to say, "[Devaluing the dollar] effectively would be playing the China card against China in a battle for manufacturing jobs...Many fund managers say the only way out of that box is a weaker dollar, reducing the value of the massive amount of U.S. debt held by foreigners and increasing the value of American investments abroad, such as Buffett’s. "'Countries like the United States do race to the bottom,' said Gross (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Gross http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Gross), though he added that Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner would never say so. A weaker currency 'makes them more competitive and reduces the burden of debt,' Gross added. Americans own about half of the outstanding federal debt, but Gross said the rest is owed 'as Tennessee Williams would say, to strangers, outside the U.S. If the United States can devalue the value of those dollars that they owe, then all the better.'"
- Symmetry 16y agoAn entire article about the dollar losing value, but not a word about how this relates to US monetary policy? The article was singularly uninformative and misleading.
- adestefan 16y agoIt has very little to do with monetary policy. Instead it's the threat of Congress not raising the debt ceiling.
- crikli 16y agoCan you explain how Congress refusing to raise the debt ceiling contributes to devaluation of the dollar? (Serious question, no snark intended at all.)
- ck2 16y agoI think it has to do with a reduced credit rating if they don't raise the limit (because they could then default on existing loans) which makes the interest on the debt higher, which makes US currency worth less?
- JonnieCache 16y agoAs I understand it, the US dollar's status as the human race's reserve currency is based on the fact that the US is perceived as always paying it's debts. If they default, countries and banks around the world will suddenly change their reserves into euros, plunging the value of the dollar. Take all that with a handful of salt though.
- rgraham 16y agoIt's not quite that simple. If you're holding dollar denominated assets and you want to 'suddenly' switch to Euros you'd better be happy to sell/exchange those assets for pennies on the dollar. Flight from an asset causes prices to crater. Sudden flight and causes crises and panic.
- daed 16y agoAny investment ideas stem from this? Where's a safe place for one's money? It seems as though the price of gold has more or less adjusted for this already. Right now I've got a bunch stashed in Inflation Protected T-Bills...
- cageface 16y agoI don't know about safe, but investing in some kind of Asian development fund doesn't sound too crazy right now. Things are definitely booming over here.
- espeed 16y agoIt's a great time to do a startup because it looks like investors are encouraging another dotcom bubble (see above).
- nerfhammer 16y agoBond prices should always contain the market's inflation expectations. If you think markets can usually anticipate inflation correctly then investing in bonds should be an effective inflation-neutral store of value.
- bootload 16y ago"... He also pronounced post-earthquake Japan “a buying opportunity, ..." There was a block of trades in Tokyo Electric reported by the NYT, 18th April: "Mysterious Trades in a Big Block of Tokyo Electric Shares Draw Regulators’ Interest" ~ http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/19/business/global/19tepco.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/19/business/global/19tepco.ht... The Times noted the following: "... Japanese regulators and executives of the Tokyo Electric Power Company are asking questions about a seemingly coordinated series of stock purchases two weeks ago that led to an undisclosed buyer or buyers acquiring a large block of the utility, which owns Japan’s dangerously damaged nuclear power plant. ..." Wonder if this was a Buffett (or inspired) move? This is after the first loss in 28 year, April 30th, Bloomberg, "Tokyo Electric Has First Loss in 28 Years on Shutdown" ~ http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=a7TSwanL7qHg&refer=asia http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=a...
- csomar 16y agoReading through the comments, I found that some HNers suggest that a weaker currency will boost exports. But I have a question that is looping in my mind: If currency weakness is due to inflation, won't the product price inflates? If I have a product that is worth $100 and tomorrow there is a USD inflation of 10%, won't the product be worth $110?
- j2d2j2d2 16y agoI think you're conflating two ideas. First, inflation internal to the US manifests itself, often enough, as higher prices. Second, the reason this is good for exports is because it usually also takes less of the foreign currency to purchase our goods.
- nerfhammer 16y agoinflation is defined as higher prices
- j2d2j2d2 16y agoThat is correct. However, the purchasing power of non monetary items is not effected by inflation.
- mkr-hn 16y agoFrom my vague memories of an intro economics class I took two years ago, inflation devalues the inflated currency relative to others. It would cost someone in the US more, but a yen or a euro would buy more.
- dstein 16y agoIf currencies were perfectly elastic then yes, the price of the exports would increase exactly to match the inflation. But they're not, if a currency falls it takes years for that change to be reflected in the prices. For example the Canadian dollar has been hovering near par for years and is now 5% higher but the prices of US imports are still higher than they should be.
- 16y ago
- mmaunder 16y agoA weaker dollar is marketed as a bad thing in the USA. But many don't realize that a strong dollar benefits the rich and a weak dollar benefits entrepreneurs and companies who don't yet have large dollar reserves they need to protect, but are exporting services and competing in a global market place.
- larrykubin 16y agoThe majority of the population aren't the rich people with tons of money in the bank or entrepreneurs starting companies. The price of gas and basic food items increasing rapidly is devastating to many people.
- nika 16y agoOne could, in fact, call it a regressive form of taxation.
- mmaunder 16y agoThen you have to consider what is more devastating: Being unemployed because your job was shipped to a country with a weaker currency, or being employed but paying more for imported goods because our currency is weakened. A weak dollar will create more jobs in the USA as it becomes more expensive for companies to outsource to other countries. In the short term, imported goods will increase in price, but longer term they will readjust to levels that reflect their real value as production moves back on-shore.
- richcollins 16y agoWorked like a charm in Zimbabwe
- jellicle 16y agoYou say that as if it was possible to move 25% of the world's oil production to the United States.
- orijing 16y agoExactly, and the weakening dollar is making food, gas, etc more expensive to the poor in the US. The strong dollar is especially beneficial to the consumers.
- jscore 16y agoAdvice for someone with a sizable IRA denominated in dollars who wants to move it into other currencies?
- GoodIntentions 16y agoI get foreign exposure with a combination of ADRs and ETFs. Approx 55% of my portfolio is non North American at the moment. About 2/3 of the foreign portion is in ADRs, but I am fairly risk tolerant. They aren't for everyone.
- simpsond 16y agoI should start charging N ounces of gold per hour.
- fexl 16y agoYou should indeed. A couple of possibilities are http://www.gsfsystem.ch/ http://www.gsfsystem.ch/ and http://goldnowbanc.com/ http://goldnowbanc.com/ . Or just delivery in person for local business. Go ahead and quote a rate in silver while you're at it.
- bgray 16y agoMy question is, how can we (normal people, inside the US and outside) take advantage of the situation?
- triviatise 16y agoget as much fixed rate debt as possible you can keep bank accounts in foreign currencies at a bank like everbank.
- fexl 16y agoWithin a few years I expect to see legislation which mandates a minimum level of participation in U.S. government debt for all retirement accounts and pension funds.