3 ms·
If the field were contaminated to that extent, he could have presented evidence that that happened, and used that to defend himself. But that's not how this co
by pfdietz 6y ago
If the field were contaminated to that extent, he could have presented evidence that that happened, and used that to defend himself. But that's not how this contamination worked. He amplified traces far beyond what mere contamination would cause.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBut apparently he was allowed to amplify those seeds in an even mixture with other seeds. The distinction is that he wasn't allowed to amplify only those seeds, while removing the normal seeds. And that's... a weird way to interpret the idea of a patent.
- pfdietz 6y agoWhat he did only made sense as a an attempt to obtain seeds with the patented genes, and the courts properly interpreted it that way.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBut he already had those. He just wanted to remove the other seeds.
- pfdietz 6y agoIntentionally propagating patented genes without a license violates the patent. It doesn't matter that he was in possession of the seeds.
- Dylan16807 6y agoExcept that he apparently would have been fine if he was just replanting everything and not applying any herbicides, with only some percent of the plants having the patented gene. Even though that would also be intentionally propagating patented genes.
- pfdietz 6y agoRight. If he had not intentionally tried to concentrate the patented gene, he'd have been ok. He could have used the defense that he didn't cause the contamination, so Monsanto was to blame. But by deliberately trying to get just the altered seeds (or descendants containing the patented gene) he lost the ability to use that defense.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhich I find strange. "Oh go ahead and replicate the patented gene as much as you want, just don't concentrate it."
- pfdietz 6y agoThe difference is that if mere propagation were problematic, then Monsanto directly harmed him by the contamination. He could use the "unclean hands" defense if Monsanto sued. But if he took deliberate action to concentrate the genes, over and above what would normally be done just growing crops, that defense would no longer be available. Monsanto's statements that it would not sue for just contamination can be viewed as immunizing them against being sued for that contamination.