4 ms·
For those unaware, the new wave of apple varieties (juice, not space gray) are also IP-encumbered [0]. The Honeycrisp's patent seems to have expired, but varie
by ethbr0 6y ago
For those unaware, the new wave of apple varieties (juice, not space gray) are also IP-encumbered [0].
The Honeycrisp's patent seems to have expired, but varieties that you will need permission to grow: Ambrosia, Cosmic Crisp, Envy, Jazz, Kanzi, SweeTango.
[0] https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/11/10/358530280/want-to-grow-these-apples-youll-have-to-join-the-club https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/11/10/358530280/wa...
- thotsBgone 6y agoThis whole thing seems perfectly reasonable to me. The analogy between DNA code and computer code seems pretty direct. They made the code, they should get the rights to the software/fruit. Don't like it? Write/selectively breed your own fruit.
- itisit 6y agoYou wouldn’t download an apple pie, would you?
- pixl97 6y agoHow about no. I would rather have companies not make new breeds because of fear of theft than deal with lawsuits/enforcement of growing food.
- kbenson 6y agoTo take this to the obvious parallel of software patents, patents get a lot of (deserved) criticism these days, but they exist for a reason, ans serve a purpose which I think is arguably still valid. Excessive patent length and patenting trivial things is bad. So is people stealing the hard work of others. There is a sane middle ground we should be shooting for, not wiping patents out entirely to the detriment of most (arguably all, in the long run).
- nixonpjoshua1 6y agoIncidentally these types of plant patents AND software patents are the two categories that are patentable in the USA but not in most of the rest of the world, so they definitely straddle the line of patentability.
- swimfar 6y agoDo you have a source for that? It looks like there are plant patents in the EU. https://www.mewburn.com/law-practice-library/plant-variety-rights-and-patents-for-plant-related-inventions https://www.mewburn.com/law-practice-library/plant-variety-r... https://www.no-patents-on-seeds.org/en/node/285 https://www.no-patents-on-seeds.org/en/node/285
- gruez 6y ago> than deal with lawsuits/enforcement of growing food. Is there a reason why food should be treated differently than any other manufacturing process, which is also patentable? Or are you against patents in general?
- monadic2 6y agoI mean there's a lot of problems with patenting manufacturing processes. How do you argue this is a solid model for growing fruit?
- thotsBgone 6y ago*selling food Big difference
- pixl97 6y agoThe only way to grow any apple is to take a cutting off the tree. Apple seeds don't grow what you expect.
- lisper 6y ago> Apple seeds don't grow what you expect. Would you mind elaborating on that a bit?
- grawprog 6y agoWild apples tend to be small and rather tart or bitter. Commercial varieties are not grown from seed but rather from cuttings from a mother tree somewhere. Planting Apple seeds results in apples resembling wild apples and not the cultivated variety the seeds come from. This is because https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple >Many apples grow readily from seeds. However, more than with most perennial fruits, apples must be propagated asexually to obtain the sweetness and other desirable characteristics of the parent. This is because seedling apples are an example of "extreme heterozygotes", in that rather than inheriting genes from their parents to create a new apple with parental characteristics, they are instead significantly different from their parents, perhaps to compete with the many pests.[51] Triploid cultivars have an additional reproductive barrier in that 3 sets of chromosomes cannot be divided evenly during meiosis, yielding unequal segregation of the chromosomes (aneuploids). Even in the case when a triploid plant can produce a seed (apples are an example), it occurs infrequently, and seedlings rarely survive.[52] >Apples do not breed true when planted as seeds, although cuttings can take root and breed true, and may live for a century, grafting is usually used. The rootstock used for the bottom of the graft can be selected to produce trees of a large variety of sizes, as well as changing the winter hardiness, insect and disease resistance, and soil preference of the resulting tree.
- vikramkr 6y agoTo clarify, the reason you are likely ending up with a wild apple phenotype is not because that is intrinsic to the nature of apples. Otherwise, new varieties could never be developed. Crabapples are used as pollinators for farmed apples since apples aren't self fertile, and you'll end up with a hybrid. If you've got the space and the time (in this case a lot of time), breeding is a great hobby for anyone. Another factor is that apples from seed take a lot longer to fruit, and as you mentioned, you can really control the growth characteristics of the tree with the rootstock. Unlike mangoes, the rootstock can result in the same scion variety of apple growing into a 50 foot tree or a 5 foot shrub- thats a huge amount of control!
- wincy 6y agoOh interesting, apparently Honeycrisp could have been a trademark, which would have allowed them to sell them indefinitely under that name excluding others from doing so, but apparently that got messed up because the name Honeycrisp was included in the patent name. https://www.duetsblog.com/2018/09/articles/articles/if-only-honeycrisp-were-a-trademark-for-apples/ https://www.duetsblog.com/2018/09/articles/articles/if-only-...
- maxerickson 6y agoA bummer with apples is that climate seems to matter. Wisconsin Honeycrisp are lame. There's something they do to ruin varieties. I think it's either that or picking them green and gassing them for sale.
- eps 6y agoSweeTango is really quite there on the edge of a freaky mutant fruit. They often have oddly shaped and deformed seed cavities, opening up into the flesh in some weird ways. Many would have parts of flesh that look transparent and saturated in juice. They are tasty, but it's in-your-face obvious they aren't naturally evolved.