3 ms·
The legend of QWERTY being designed specifically to slow typists down will never die. It has that perfect "folk" quality, it should be true, the problem is simp
by samatman 6y ago
The legend of QWERTY being designed specifically to slow typists down will never die. It has that perfect "folk" quality, it should be true, the problem is simply that there isn't any evidence for it.
What does stick out about QWERTY, is that you can type the word "typewriter" using only the top keys, a trick that made it easier for typewriter salesmen to memorize and demonstrate that little trick when selling their wares. And we do have evidence that this motivated the layout.
- garaetjjte 6y agoIn fact, QWERTY was designed to prevent jamming of early typewriters, allowing to type faster. http://widespacer.blogspot.com/2015/11/the-hidden-secrets-of-qwerty.html http://widespacer.blogspot.com/2015/11/the-hidden-secrets-of...
- taeric 6y agoThis is a patato patahto thing. It would only jam if you went too fast, so the story goes. Get rid of the jamming, or force a max speed that is lower.
- samatman 6y agoIt's actually a critical distinction. If QWERTY was designed to be the worst possible layout, to make typing slow in order to prevent jams, then now, with n-key rollover, we're all stuck with the worst possible layout. If instead it was designed to be the most jam-free possible layout, with a secondary goal of being as fast as possible given that criterion, it's probably not that bad, and we'd live in a world where the fastest QWERTY typists aren't that much slower than the fastest typists, period. And, in fact, we see that, while the world record was at one time held by a Dvorak typist, the prize at present belongs to QWERTY: https://www.typing.com/blog/fastest-typists/ https://www.typing.com/blog/fastest-typists/
- stevage 6y agoI wonder if anyone has ever set out to design the worst possible layout, and if so, what it would look like.
- jeffbee 6y agoCould be a fun game. For starters I'd move the most useless keys to the index finger home row positions, perhaps pipe and backtick. Then I'd invert the sense of shift, so you have to hold it to type anything lowercase. I'd take all the most common two-letter sequences and I'd move those letters under the weakest finger. So T H E O A R S and N replace the punctuation keys on the right side. This should make it a real hassle to type "the", especially considering that you'll be holding down shift, which should itself be somewhere hard to reach, such as where 6 usually goes.
- I_complete_me 6y agoCan't figure out whether you are a sadist or a masochist but I love how you ran with _that_ particular ball. Kudos to you.
- benhurmarcel 6y agohttp://mkweb.bcgsc.ca/carpalx/?worst_layout http://mkweb.bcgsc.ca/carpalx/?worst_layout
- sarbaz 6y agoIt's worth pointing out that the worst possible layout for keyboards might actually be one of the best possible layouts for phones.
- taeric 6y agoI am not claiming to support that it is the worst. Just saying that, if it helps you type faster by keeping the device from jamming because you are typing too fast, then it is by definition helping you type faster by limiting the speed that you can type. Hence, slowing you down so that you don't go so fast that you crash. As per the claim of the fastest typist. I would be shocked it steno doesn't win that, hands down. Edit: Added in "because you are typing too fast", which was part of the original claim. I should have noted I don't know if I believe it, but I did want to raise that something that makes you go as fast as you can by keeping you from going too fast, both slows you down and makes you type faster. At the same time.
- cortesoft 6y agoEven that theory has been questioned: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/fact-of-fiction-the-legend-of-the-qwerty-keyboard-49863249/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/fact-of-fiction-... It seems likely the keyboard layout was the result of working with typists to develop the best layout.
- garaetjjte 6y agoLinked paper [0] correctly states that QWERTY wasn't designed to slow typists down, but authors argue that it was not designed to avoid type-bar jams, but only vaguely suggest some letters were moved around due to Morse operation practice. They base that conclusion on analysis of radial distances of common digrams on typebar basket. But there's no justification why only angle criteria was considered, and they omitted that layout clearly minimizes adjacent typebar digrams, which is shown by [1] and [2]. They also without much evidence reject idea that TYPEWRITER ending up on same row was intentional design, but curiously enough [2] calculated odds of that occurring randomly as about 1 in 2500, so it might have been. [0] https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/139379/1/42_161.pdf https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433... [1] http://widespacer.blogspot.com/2015/11/the-hidden-secrets-of-qwerty.html http://widespacer.blogspot.com/2015/11/the-hidden-secrets-of... [2] https://cyber.sci-hub.se/MTAuMTAxNi9qLnJlc3BvbC4yMDEzLjAzLjAwNw==/kay2013.pdf#view=FitH https://cyber.sci-hub.se/MTAuMTAxNi9qLnJlc3BvbC4yMDEzLjAzLjA...
- stevage 6y agoWell, there's two clear things about the layout of QWERTY: 1. TYPEWRITER on the top row. 2. DFGHJKL on the middle row, in perfect alphabetical order except for the two vowels that got moved to the top. (The French version has the M after the L). It looks very much like they started with alphabetical order, then moved a couple of things.
- gdx 6y agoAnecdotically, QWERTY also seems to be sort of arranged in alphabetical order but with certain keys moved here and there — for exemple, the middle row is: A .. D . F G H . J K L (dots indicating the missing letters.) Then it goes down for the M N from right to left, up for O P, then the top row is: Q R . T U And the bottom row is, from right to left: V . X . Z And then the rest.
- bclnr 6y agoA while ago I did a little analysis to compare ergonomics of existing keyboard layouts [1]. The criteria are obviously subjective, but the results clearly show that Qwerty comes out significantly inferior to all alternatives designed later. [1] https://github.com/bclnr/kb-layout-evaluation https://github.com/bclnr/kb-layout-evaluation