3 ms·
This part: > The bricking shows that all these “smart” cars with remote software control are liable to hacking No remote control or wireless communication was
by nomel 6y ago
This part:
> The bricking shows that all these “smart” cars with remote software control are liable to hacking
No remote control or wireless communication was used here, so this can't provide evidence that it is liable to hacking.
- Dylan16807 6y agoThe bricking shows how deeply integrated the remote control system is, and that it can brick the car. And since it's remote control, it can be hacked (or Ferrari themselves can be hacked). Therefore we can conclude that the bricking shows how badly the car can be affected by remote hacking. It doesn't matter that wireless remote communication didn't happen here. The wireless remote control system was demonstrated. And the comment is making claims about the wireless remote control system. The only way the difference would matter is if you think they're lying about the ability to send signals to the system.
- nomel 6y agoWe don't know if it can be enabled remotely from this story. There is no evidence for that beyond your speculation. There is only evidence that it cannot be enabled remotely. This is why I said your claim is false. Looking at other instances, or the documentation, will probably show that it can be enabled remotely, but that evidence is not here. But, it appears your perspective is that if remote control operation exists, so it can be hacked. This is proof that remote control operation exists, so it can be hacked. Framed in that perspective, sure I guess.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> There is only evidence that it cannot be enabled remotely. Wait, by "enabled" do you mean making the car stop working, or making the car work again? Either way, that's wrong. For making the car work remotely, the fact that they tried and say it would have worked if it had a cell signal is strong evidence that they can in fact do it. Why would they lie about it? It's evidence they can, not evidence they cannot. For making the car stop working remotely, this situation doesn't give any direct evidence either way. It's not evidence they can, but it's also not evidence they cannot. And considering how these devices are usually designed, if they can flip the car one way they can probably flip the car the other way. So it very likely can remotely make the car stop working. > But, it appears your perspective is that if remote control operation exists, so it can be hacked. Is that wrong? Even if the system itself is magically perfect, surely Ferrari itself can be hacked. I can't imagine someone credibly claiming otherwise. So I take it as a fact that a hacker can send commands to your car. Whether those commands can shut it down... I'll just say that if it even resembles competitor systems then it's a strong yes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]