7 ms·
Prefab is the wrong optimization. It targets a minor improvement in a small part of the overall budget. Most of the time and money of construction in America is
by jeffbee 6y ago
Prefab is the wrong optimization. It targets a minor improvement in a small part of the overall budget. Most of the time and money of construction in America is tied up in land prices, permitting, and regulation. Prefab solves zero of these issues.
There is a building going up in Oakland right now where Factory_OS put out a press release that they had built it in ten days. But they spent 7 years getting approvals, 18 months in site prep, and they've been detailing and finishing the building for more than a year since the press release, so it doesn't seem like the method of construction was a very important factor.
- modeless 6y agoThe advantage to me seems like it should be in quality and consistency, not cost and speed. Building houses is fast enough, and as you say the cost of the land often dominates, but the quality of houses is appallingly bad compared to consumer items mass produced in factories.
- xnx 6y agoThis. I want homes as well designed, engineered and built as iPhones, or at least automobiles.
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoFWIW, I have a hunch that in 10 years TSLA will start building homes and AAPL will likely start building condo buildings.
- stephencanon 6y agoThe quality issues that you encounter in houses aren't the framing either, though. It's the roof sealing, ventilation, trim, plumbing, ... all things that prefab framing also doesn't address.
- modeless 6y agoTrue, I don't see a point to prefab unless it involves a lot more than the framing. But it seems totally possible to do prefab installation of most of the ventilation, plumbing, electrical, etc.
- jolux 6y agoYou say it’s the wrong optimization but your argument seems to be that there are bigger problems. I tend to agree, particularly with pernicious stuff like single-unit zoning and such, but that doesn’t mean that prefab is “wrong” overall. I don’t see it as a cost optimization, I see it as a speed and consistency optimization. Do we know if long-term maintenance costs of prefab construction are lower?
- jeffbee 6y agoSeems like it would be hard to reason about. Consistency is great but it means if you order assembled wall panels from a factory, your foundation has to be exact in dimensions and dead level, or it's not going to come together. On-site framers aren't really bothered by this. I think it trades one kind of complexity for another.
- sjg007 6y agoHuh? There's a shortage of carpenters so if you can go prefab it is a win. In fact the article shows that if you can build a house faster with prefab at the same cost as a traditional house that's a win.
- arbitrage 6y agoIt's about scale, as the person you are responding to clearly said. Technically, it might be a win. It's not enough of a win, however, to bring many new converts. It simply doesn't scale to enough large savings to make much of a difference in the construction budgets OP actually was writing about.
- bluGill 6y agoThere isn't a shortage of carpenters. There is a shortage willing to work for the wages offered. I've done carpentry work in the past, offer enough money and I'll leave my tech job. I'm not the only one who could do carpentry for the right price.
- amelius 6y agoOk, so prefab can still be a win if it's cheaper?
- rbanffy 6y agoPermits and regulations should be solved too. Prefab houses can be identical or use a finite set of components that could be pre-approved easily.
- fblp 6y agoI know of at least one prefab option where permitting and inspections are streamlined at the factory.
- Schiendelman 6y agoThat is likely not the same permitting and inspections the commenter refers to.
- mcguire 6y agoSee also "manufactured housing".
- jessaustin 6y agoNo one is writing articles asking why mobile homes haven't taken over. In many communities, they have.
- jeffbee 6y agoLocally? Because nationally manufactured home deliveries are a small fraction of what they once were in the 1970s. Adjusted for population they are down to 10% of their peak. https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/mhs/tables/time-series/shiphist.xlsx https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/mhs/tables/time-ser...
- mcguire 6y agoLikely due to the easy availability of mortgages during the 1990s and 2000s.
- vannevar 6y agoDoes prefab go much beyond framing? The NAHB estimates that framing is only 17% of the cost of a house(1), so even cutting that cost in half doesn't save much on the whole project. (1)https://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?sectionID=734&genericContentID=271883&channelID=311#:~:text=Of%20the%20major%20stages%20of,the%20cost%20of%20hiring%20subcontractors https://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?sectionID=734&gener....
- dejv 6y agoI am currently in the process of buying prefab house and after visiting couple of local factories it seems like most of them is doing just framing and competing on price only. We are going with company that actually assemble full house inside and bring it to site fully equipped: electrical, plumbing etc.
- robocat 6y ago> so even cutting that cost in half doesn't save much on the whole project. Houses are usually a leveraged investment. If you put down 5%, and prefab saves you 5%, you have massively reduced your risk of default during a downturn. And if you expect it to take 20 years to pay off your mortgage, and framing saves 5%, that’s one year saved, which is massive IMHO. Obviously a lot of assumptions to the above e.g. everyone else doesn’t get the 5% savings, and everyone doesn’t just bid up new house prices by 5% (because they are bounded by their mortgage which is related to their earnings, not costs).
- 6y ago
- mcguire 6y agoThe San Francisco Bay area is not all of "America".
- hansvm 6y agoThat depends heavily on where you're building. There are plenty of places you can pick up a few acres for $10-$20k (with electric/water access) and have a minimal permitting process that's over in at most on the order of weeks.
- yeetman21 6y agoEngineers can only fix so much, they can not really do permitting and regulation
- rektide 6y ago> Most of the time and money of construction in America is tied up in land prices, permitting, and regulation. Prefab solves zero of these issues. I'd hypothesize that access to affordable, reproducible, medium-scale home production would allow a lot of new places to try to develop. Land prices, permitting, & regulation are very different in different places. The places where these are not the major factors could have a better chance, if home construction could be more economical & effective & appealing, which pre-fabs might be able to help with.
- danans 6y ago> There is a building going up in Oakland right now where Factory_OS put out a press release that they had built it in ten days. But they spent 7 years getting approvals, 18 months in site prep, I'm currently gut remodeling a small house in Oakland. Permitting and regulations are a whopping 3% of the cost. The land (the existing property) is 50%, and 40% is building costs. Land costs (addressed via incremental upzoning) and build costs (addressed with more efficient building technology) are the 2 biggest things to address to make housing affordable, not the cost of permits.
- epa 6y agoI don't fully agree given that housing and materials prices rise every year. 7 year delay adds how much $ to a project in inflation?
- danans 6y agoWell delays can vary. My delay was 3 months, but that was due to COVID.
- jeffbee 6y agoRemodeling an existing structure won't really expose you to the regulatory burden, which is good for you but isn't the full picture. If you wanted to buy a SFH and build a duplex or, God forbid, a triplex, then you'd be paying serious money, mostly in the carrying costs of your debts while the government dithers over your application. This is why in California one of the most important recent state law changes was 2017's SB35, which mandates that local authorities must approve certain types of projects in 90 days or less. But the types of projects which benefit from this are fairly few. On top of the carrying costs there are impact fees. These vary by city but you can see how crazy they are. In Fremont you will pay $160k per dwelling, that's just cash out of your pocket. Totally crazy. https://www.spur.org/news/2018-05-09/it-all-adds-growing-costs-prevent-new-housing-california https://www.spur.org/news/2018-05-09/it-all-adds-growing-cos...
- swader999 6y agoWrong optimization. I think this is key. My house has prefab trusses, doors, windows, and many other already built components.