3 ms·
What will ultimately hurt the establishment (by which I mean mainstream scientists and public health leaders) is this attitude: """“Whose grandmother and grandf
by dekhn 6y ago
What will ultimately hurt the establishment (by which I mean mainstream scientists and public health leaders) is this attitude: """“Whose grandmother and grandfather and family members are you willing to sacrifice for this stupid idea?” asked Santa Clara County Executive Jeff Smith, """
That's not an acceptable way to engage with good-faith scientists at major institutions. It's an appeal to emotion as well as an implication of stupidity on your opponent.
I've noticed this behavior among a wide range of mainstream scientists and public health leaders too- literally mocking people who disagree with their policies. This will hurt the credibility of these scientists, especially if, in retrospect (when we have the time and luxury to study the public health response to COVID in detail), we find out that decisions led to suboptimal outcomes.
It's far better to project humility, stand by your decision, but be willing to admit when you're wrong, and adapt.
- wonnage 6y agoThey're not good-faith scientists. Bhattacharya is a co-author of the widely debunked Stanford seroprevalence study. Kulldorff doesn't believe in child-to-adult transmission. I think this is an appropriate response.
- dekhn 6y agoI do agree their scientific positions are tenuous, but having worked in a few scientific fields where the mainstream ultimately was proved completely and totally wrong (RNA can be an enzyme, the ribosome is an RNA machine) I've learned that even scientists who appear to be "not good faith" may be as ethical and as intelligent as the people they were disagreeing with. I wouldn't classify Bhattacharya in the same bin as Peter Deusberg (well known virologist who insisteted that HIV transmission did not cause AIDS).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]