3 ms·
It is deeply frustrating to me that there doesn't even seem to be agreement on basic facts about sars-cov-2/covid19 yet. Death rate? They're still arguing. Risk
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
It is deeply frustrating to me that there doesn't even seem to be agreement on basic facts about sars-cov-2/covid19 yet. Death rate? They're still arguing. Risk of serious complications by age group or complications? Still arguing. Negative impacts of social distancing/lockdown measures? Still arguing.
I think it's great that there is an argument about this, but it still feels disappointing that it will still clearly take a lot longer then 10 months to clarify these points to a level where no serious high level medical professional disagrees.
In the meantime, I'd also appreciate it if we could get back to a lot more talk of "flatten the curve" in our public discourse. Nobody seems to seriously doubt that at some point almost all humans will be exposed to the virus. The question is how rapidly that happens, and the concomittant impact on health care and the economy if it happens too fast.
- dustinmoris 6y agoI agree with your sentiment. It really shows that COVID-19 has been politicised so much that people can't debate on the topic anymore in good faith, because nobody wants to admit that they might have been wrong. Especially people like Donald Trump make a scientific debate extremely difficult, because he has been undermining the virus from the beginning and even if science was to find that the virus was less dangerous than initially thought many scientists, especially those who had public exposure, wouldn't want to support/admit an idea which could play into Trump's favour. The whole thing is just a bloody mess. > Nobody seems to seriously doubt that at some point almost all humans will be exposed to the virus. Unfortunately there are many people who really believe we can eliminate the virus through strict measures. Just read many responses here on Hacker News and you'll find plenty of those people.
- argc 6y agoThis rings true. As soon as it was politicized neither side will budge an inch. And scientific progress requires people being able to admit they were wrong in the face of new evidence. Egos should not be wrapped up in how many feet at which social distancing is effective and how effective masks are and when lockdowns should be enforced or let up. Its really unfortunate and, in my opinion, goes to show the two party system is bad for democracy, science, progress, etc. We need more polictical parties and ranked choice voting, and less blind following of one's parties ideals/agenda/candidates.
- ColanR 6y ago> because he has been undermining the virus from the beginning No, he wasn't. Where did you get that idea? https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/31/business/china-travel-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/31/business/china-travel-cor...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoJanuary 22nd, 2020: Asked if his administration was worried about a coronavirus pandemic, Trump says, “No, we’re not at all. And we have it totally under control. It’s one person coming in from China.” https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/22/trump-on-coronavirus-from-china-we-have-it-totally-under-control.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/22/trump-on-coronavirus-from-ch... January 30th: The World Health Organization declares the coronavirus a “public health emergency of international concern.” • At an event in Michigan, Trump says, “We’re working very strongly with China on the coronavirus—that’s a new thing that a lot of people are talking about….We think it’s going to have a very good ending for it. So that I can assure you.” https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-president-trump-usmca-celebration-american-workers-warren-mi/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-pres... Now, I will grant you that he established the task force on Jan 29th, but against that I will note that the "China travel ban" did not prevent Americans who had been in Wuhan and other affected areas from returning to the US. I would also add the person chosen to head the task force at the start, secretary of HHS, Alex Azar, on August 23rd (after all we know now) explained things this way: > Alex M. Azar II, the secretary of health and human services, defended members of President Trump’s family on Friday for refusing to wear masks at the recent presidential debate despite a requirement that the audience do so. The first family and the president are “in a different situation than the rest of us,” Mr. Azar said, because they are in a protective bubble." https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/10/02/world/covid-19-coronavirus#azar-defends-refusal-of-trump-family-members-to-wear-masks-at-the-debate https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/10/02/world/covid-19-coron... I think it's fair to say that Trump's actions along with his then-private conversations with Woodward, can be reasonably (if incompletely) summarized by saying that he has tried to downplay the virus from the start.
- dkarl 6y agoAnd that's the problem with... let's say politics generally, but Trump especially. Two of Trump's biggest winning issues have been travel bans and China. Taking the opportunity to combine them was such a political no-brainer that he didn't need to believe in the virus to do it. Over and over again, when Trump has succeeded politically by saying things that are transparently untrue, we have been told that we'll never understand him politically if we are hung up on facts, because we need to "take him seriously, but not literally." I think that advice applies very neatly to this case. His travel ban was seriously meant as a gesture of resistance against a serious threat of disease from China, but the threat was not literally the coronavirus, as his subsequent rhetoric showed. Having a travel ban against foreigners arriving from China felt good and safe for his supporters regardless of the literal medical danger posed by a literal virus. "Seriously, but not literally" means that Trump could support a covid travel ban without believing that covid was a real threat. As usual, his target audience understood instantly, while the rest of us once again took months to figure out that Trump might not even have a literal opinion.
- asdff 6y agoThe people who are arguing are the people who are politicizing the normal scientific process of drawing conclusions from available evidence.
- jhpriestley 6y agoI've been reading about this virus daily since February and my impression has been the opposite. It's a very boring virus which has offered very few surprises. We knew since February that it is a flu-like respiratory disease with high rates of hospitalization and death, especially among the old. The initial estimates for fatality rate were about 4% and that has now been narrowed to 1% based on better testing and treatment. Social distancing and masks are effective at controlling the spread. All of this has been known since February/March, most of it is spelled out here: https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-china-joint-mission-on-covid-19-final-report.pdf?sfvrsn=fce87f4e_2 https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-chi... At the same time, there has been an endless parade of contrarians trying to make the whole thing into a big mystery and muddy the waters for some reason. There was the theory that the virus was spreading much earlier than expected. There was the theory that most cases were asymptomatic and that immunity had already been reached. The theory that lockdowns are not effective. The theory that there were different strains with highly different behavior. Some vague theory about t-cell immunity. None of these contrarian theories have been supported by any real evidence, but there is a large appetite for them and people will seize on any puzzling number to try to rethink the whole picture of the virus.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThis doesn't align with my tracking of virus facts. 1) the death rate is still unclear because very few localities have done sufficient and/or the right kind of testing to answer this in a definitive way. 2) initial estimates about hospitalization across age cohorts seem to have turned out to be fairly far off. Tracking the stats for my own state (New Mexico; admittedly a fairly small population), we sometimes have almost flat hospitalization rates across age cohorts. That report was dated 16-24 February 2020. It was authoritative at the time of writing (hard not to be given the limited breakouts outside of Wuhan at that time), and the reporting on the physical structure and mechanisms of the virus have remained largely unchanged AFAIK. But the epidemiological aspects of covid19 have, I think, changed quite a bit since that report. The report doesn't in fact coe down strongly in favor of masks: "The relative importance of non-pharmaceutical control measures including masks, hand hygiene, and social distancing require further research to quantify their impact." and in the section titled "Knowledge Gaps" includes "Effectiveness of the public health control measures and their socio-economic impact ... * Wearing mask in general public", along with most "lockdown" type policies.
- wonnage 6y agoI think the death rate in particular has been the victim of politics. Each side has in interest in presenting it as higher or lower, particularly relative to the flu. The true value is unknowable as it requires perfect test data. And the available data (case fatality rate) is rejected by the "it's just the flu" camp, because they say the true denominator is much higher. But honestly, who cares about the actual number? The flu death rate is subject to the same problems. Nobody gets tested for asymptomatic flu. We're should be comparing the CFR for flu to the CFR for COVID, and this shouldn't be an argument.... But it is.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIndeed, which is why I consider excess mortality numbers to be the most useful numbers on death rate that we have, although I have still not found an excellent breakdown on what they show (notably by age cohort).
- edanm 6y agoBut excess mortality can be changed by behavior. That's part of the point of lockdowns. You can't know the hypothetical death rate given no lockdown measures.
- tim333 6y ago>Death rate? They're still arguing. Trouble is it isn't a fixed number. It depends who the people are, what treatment is available and so on. It's come down over time for various reasons. These things aren't as simple as they might be.