6 ms·
I am okay with qualified medical professionals having a good-faith debate about the broad physical and mental health impacts of lockdowns as it pertains to this
by unethical_ban 6y ago
I am okay with qualified medical professionals having a good-faith debate about the broad physical and mental health impacts of lockdowns as it pertains to this particular virus. It is a fair discussion to have.
I am not okay with unqualified politicians making inaccurate claims about the virus, and prioritizing economic health in the absence of good governance.
I believe there are obvious risks to mental health of adults and children in being isolated from others, unable to socialize with other humans in person. I read recently too, that things like kids in school in person allow teachers and members of the community to be a safe space for children to be seen and essentially monitored for child abuse/poor living conditions. People may go to the doctor less because of fear of the disease, rather than get treatment.
It is certainly a balance - we cannot go full "save every possible life" - thus the term "flatten the curve", where the metric for success was not to have absolute minimum deaths, but to preserve the integrity of the health system to best serve all who need emergency care for any reason.
There was an article in February called "The Hammer and the Dance" that predicted a cycle of shutdowns and reopenings to balance social interaction and jobs with overriding systemic medical concerns. We are in that now.
- calpaterson 6y ago> I am not okay with unqualified politicians making inaccurate claims about the virus, and prioritizing economic health in the absence of good governance. This sounds a bit like you are raising the qualification barrier to participate in the debate, but only if that person disagrees with you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BobbyJo 6y agoI think 'inaccurate' was the key word. I think that's a reasonable barrier.
- young_unixer 6y agoPoliticians, journalists and the general population make inaccurate claims all the time in both pro-lockdown and anti-lockdown stances.
- adamsea 6y agoLuckily as educated adults we are blessed with being able to exercise our judgement to assess what is right, wrong, an honest mistake, a deliberate distortion, a kinda-bad inaccurate claim, or a dangerously-bad inaccurate claim.
- aegis4244 6y agoThe evidence shows that most adults are not all that sharp.
- headmelted 6y agoThis. If we’ve learned anything at all.
- lehi 6y agoBut who is anybody to say what is or isn't accurate.
- yladiz 6y agoFair point, we are in a post-truth society now.
- xienze 6y agoFacebook and Twitter, obviously.
- marshray 6y agoBefore COVID-19, I would have said that we pay for CDC, FDA, Surgeon General, epidemiologists, and virologists to be right about that stuff and they're generally trustworthy. But then they all tried to convince Americans not to wear masks.
- glasss 6y agoI didn't read their comment that way. The article isn't about doctors with years of experience advocating for lockdown, so this conversation is framed around people disagreeing with how deadly the virus is and the lockdown procedures. I'm sure that poster, like me, also doesn't want politicians making inaccurate claims the other way about how the virus is the deadliest thing imaginable, or to prioritize saving every single life possible by orders of house arrest.
- adamsea 6y agoLet's be real. The President of the United States said, several months ago, publicly, that people should try injecting bleach. There's an entire group of politicians in the U.S. irresponsibly discouraging basic use of masks. That is what the parent poster is talking about. What is difficult to understand about this?
- adamsea 6y agoDownvoters: "US President Donald Trump has been lambasted by the medical community after suggesting research into whether coronavirus might be treated by injecting disinfectant into the body." https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52407177 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52407177
- sidibe 6y agoAs someone who disagrees with Trump almost always, I feel like this is not a good point to harp on because most people realize he wasn't really suggesting people inject disinfectants, just musing. When conservatives see this kind of mischaracterization it just solidifies their beliefs that his critics are always wrong about him. I am more upset about the fact he still doesn't seem to believe masks are very useful.
- adamsea 6y agoIt is incredibly irresponsible for the President of the United States (or of any country) to speculate about obviously questionable practices like injecting disinfectant in the midst of a global pandemic and a national emergency. And, the sad fact that we have to remind ourselves of this (you don't "muse" about injecting disinfectant!) is an indicator of just how irresponsible, destructive, and and constant the President's behavior, and it's enabling by politicians, the news media, or others in positions of influence (whose responsibility was to condemn such behavior) has been. This is not complicated. No one who cares about their own well-being would ever want to work under a boss like that, much less let someone like that babysit their kids.
- DuskStar 6y agoYeah, if you're fine with unqualified politicians making inaccurate claims about the virus in order to intensify lockdowns (which, frankly, has been most of the lockdown justifications) then that's pretty unfair. The burden of proof should be on the lockdown proponents, not people trying to return to the status quo.
- eecc 6y agoWe're not used to sharing space with hungry wolves or big felines, in fact humans tend to exterminate them when they move into a new environment. There's a new predator out there, invading our space and we're its lunch. there's precious little status quo to return to until we have the tools to exterminate it. We're not used to not being apex predators. That's fact.
- DuskStar 6y agoA new predator, to go along with all of the others. AIDS, the other things that get lumped into 'colds' or 'flus' (which are different from COVID-19 in degree, but not really in kind), Malaria, and so many more.
- eecc 6y agoExcept HIV isn't airborne, doesn't choke you to death within a couple weeks and the other 'cold' and 'flus' aren't nearly as deadly. Cov2 is both everywhere and lethal, that's quite a difference in kind. And WRT "Malaria, and so many more" we as humans and our collective organizations have been busy trying to exterminate or avoid them as much as possible. Since forever.
- unethical_ban 6y agoI am commenting on a combination of the motives and the qualifications of speaking as an authority - not on the position of the speaker.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoFWIW, I didn't read the the comment this way, and it doesn't seem like "the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says". From the HN guidelines: Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
- pessimizer 6y agoOnly if you intentionally ignore the very first sentence, which is obviously supportive.
- jtbayly 6y ago> in the absence of good governance. This is begging the question, though.
- throw9872349872 6y agoPoliticians should be the ones making policy based on the data available.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI just struggle to get on board with the premise of medicalizing all of society. Can the harms from social isolation, poor quality education, economic damage, etc. really be reduced to medical factors for doctors to weigh against disease risk? I think these are inherently political decisions; or rather, politics is the process by which a society decides how to make such challenging tradeoffs.
- morpheuskafka 6y agoI think a clear distinction needs to be made between normative and descriptive claims: the former, everyone has the right to make and hold their own opinion to, including both politicians and scientists; the latter, should only be entertained by policy-makers when supported by evidence-based scientific research. For example, a politician has every right to say "I think schools should re-open immediately under X procedures," if that is what he truly feels reflects the best outcome for his constituents. Of course, it would be wrong to say this only for political posturing, corrupt influences, etc. On the other hand, it is completely unacceptable for a politician (or anyone) to say, "Children are immune to the virus," "COVID is not a serious illness," (okay, technically that is normative but only insofar as the definition of seriousness is normative), "same as the flu," "masks cause oxygen lack," etc. Likewise, asserting these claims in an argument, "Children are immune -> we should open schools," is not right. But, making a philosophical/policy and/or medical argument based off true, evidence-backed descriptive claims--even if the scientific community does not tend to share that normative opinion, is completely fine. So there is nothing wrong with arguing against a given measure that the majority of doctors support, so long as you aren't distorting the underlying facts. As a practical matter, of course, this shuts down many arguments. Ex. admitting that masks pose no health risk to the wearer, cost very little, do not substantially limit any right or activity, and have at least a fair probability of public health benefit, it would be hard to argue against requiring them. But if you feel otherwise, make your case by all means. The only thing that is morally wrong is corrupting intellectual discourse by adding FUD and confusing people as to the underlying evidence and data.
- briefcomment 6y agoThis might make sense if medical experts consistently made accurate predictions, but they often seem to be wrong, and have to change their positions after the fact. One could go as far to say that it is irresponsible to give their peripatetic claims more credence than they seem to historically deserve, especially when it's clear that there are legitimate trade-offs.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> I am not okay with unqualified politicians making inaccurate claims about the virus, and prioritizing economic health in the absence of good governance. Who else is supposed to make these types of decisions? Doctors don't have governing experience, and they weren't elected. They can and should serve an important advisory role, but the final call should be up to our elected leaders. If we have elected unqualified politicians, that's a separate problem. This is still a decision that's within their domain.
- basch 6y ago>prioritizing economic health I sense that everyone fairly well off sort of ignores how quickly poor economic health translates into poor social and biological health. We like to act like the economy is this nice to have extra that can shut down, and everything will go on as normal, except our luxuries. But then you realize, you cant shut down ports, railroads, roads, trucking, Wal-Mart, Amazon, Target, every grocery store. And suddenly all the interconnected everything requires all the software companies to stay running. All the power companies. They all need their supplies. >we cannot go full "save every possible life" Where is the calculation of life lost or years lost of lifespan, because the economy wasn't there to support life. >thus the term "flatten the curve" I understood the context of flatten the curve to be in that we needed to buy time to prepare hospitals, manufacturing, and as a tool to prevent ICU overflow. It's now been co-opted to be used in a "until the vaccine" sort of way, which is not how it was used initially. You can see how people might have agreed with it before, but not now, and still have a consistent unchanging view (its the usage around their view that changed.) It's also very frustrating to hear rate statistics used out of context, as if the instantaneous rate is what matters, without the understanding that their denominator, time, extends into the future, and with part of the denominator in the future, the numerator is not very useful.
- unethical_ban 6y agoIt's odd that you're attacking what I said when I'm kind of supporting what you're saying. That we can't sustainably lock down indefinitely until a vaccine, that we need to balance the desire to protect lives with the need to live and work. Your statement about flatten the curve is exactly what I said. I will say, though, I bet we disagree on this: The federal government should have minted off a few more trillion dollars to keep people home as needed without them losing their jobs or insurance. Our American political/economic system is not built to keep people healthy or economically secure, and the government should take a more active role in fixing that.
- basch 6y agoIm not sure if I agree or disagree that blindly throwing more money is the right approach, but I can say I think we did a poor job of using the information we had early on (age, weight being major factors) and using that to selectively protect the most vulnerable. Locking down elderly care to an extreme level and having the social support and food to do so, might have saved more lives-years than keeping everyone at home. All in all, it just wasnt feasible to tell the elderly to stay home while the rest of the world continued humming. This was one way to get everybody to care. I wasn't disagreeing with what you said about flattening the curve, I'm saying its meaning has changed in some usages, from what you described to something else.