4 ms·
There has been something very strange going on at Stanford since this began. Tons of really really bad stats, stuff that should destroy a person's career, even
by epistasis 6y ago
There has been something very strange going on at Stanford since this began. Tons of really really bad stats, stuff that should destroy a person's career, even if it wasn't during a global pandemic and the bad stats resulted in the death of people.
Politics have overtaken some people's scientific sensibilities. Fortunately there are still lots of great people at Stanford, but they aren't the ones who are going on mass media.
- aphextron 6y ago>Politics have overtaken some people's scientific sensibilities. Fortunately there are still lots of great people at Stanford, but they aren't the ones who are going on mass media. They've always leaned far more conservative than almost any other academic institution I can think of. Probably it's to do with the pervading influence of big business there. The Hoover Institution is one of the oldest conservative think tanks in the US.
- epistasis 6y agoIt's weird because I had never heard that Jay Bhattacharya was super political. But early on he designed a study with unethical participant recruitment, juked and terrible stats, to push a bad pre-print for a contrarian number on the death rate that has proven to be very very very wrong. And he went out into media and pushed his bad study, at a crucial time. That the Mercury News is publishing his words is a huge black eye both for Stanford and for the Mercury News. It's clear that his COVID work is not driven by science, but rather strange political beliefs that can not be justified by data. Shameful.
- bhk 6y ago> ... a contrarian number on the death rate that has proven to be very very very wrong. What was that "very very wrong" number? I found [1] from April in which Bhattacharya estimates that the IFR is probably one tenth of the CFR of 3-4%, which would mean an IFR of 0.3-0.4%. That doesn't seem very contrarian or wrong. The CDC in May estimated 0.26% IFR [2]. The WHO just the other day [3] said that 10% of the world's population may have been infected with the virus. They also estimate ~1,000,000 deaths globally. That would imply an IFR much lower than 0.3%. [1] https://padailypost.com/2020/04/06/stanford-experts-say-covid-19-death-estimates-may-be-too-high/ https://padailypost.com/2020/04/06/stanford-experts-say-covi... [2] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/06/05/fact-check-cdc-estimates-covid-19-death-rate-0-26/5269331002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/06/05/fac... [3] https://apnews.com/article/virus-outbreak-archive-united-nations-54a3a5869c9ae4ee623497691e796083 https://apnews.com/article/virus-outbreak-archive-united-nat... [4] https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situation-reports/20201005-weekly-epi-update-8.pdf https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situati...
- jhpriestley 6y agoThe CDC estimate was from before we had any good studies using antibody prevalence. It was too low. The WHO estimates a fatality rate of 0.6%. If you are simply dividing deaths by (an estimate of) current cases then you will get an inaccurate number because many of the current cases will eventually die of the disease.
- bhk 6y agoIf CDC's mis-estimate from May can be forgiven by virtue of there not being enough good studies at the time, then why is Bhattacharya's even earlier (and more accurate) estimate being characterized as unconscionable? > The WHO estimates a fatality rate of 0.6%. I don't see how that makes an estimate 0.3% to 0.4% "very very very wrong", especially considering that we haven't heard the final word on this. > If you are simply dividing deaths by (an estimate of) current cases then you will get an inaccurate number because many of the current cases will eventually die of the disease. I didn't do that, but if you look at the numbers you'll see that it wouldn't make a meaningful difference anyway. WHO numbers show over a million deaths since the start of the epidemic, and around 5000 deaths per day over the past month. Whether you use 0.13% or 0.14% for the implied IFR, the WHO's comments the other day are out of whack with the 0.6% fatality rate estimate.
- jhpriestley 6y agoI don't quite know what to make of the WHO estimate. I can't find further details about it. I don't think it makes sense to take this estimate and try to extract an IFR from it. They could be suggesting that the IFR of the virus is much lower than expected, but they could also be suggesting that deaths have been badly undercounted (e.g. in areas with poor health infrastructure), or that it has spread more widely among younger populations in places like Africa, where IFR would be expected to be much lower. Bhattacharya's estimate is being criticized because, even though he was taking a contrarian view on the virus and getting results that were out of wack with other lines of evidence, he rushed out a highly flawed study (the Santa Clara seroprevalence study). This came out when we had little data about antibody prevalence, his study was one of the first ones, and it had the big name of Stanford behind it, so it was reported very widely and misled an awful lot of people about how dangerous this virus is. In his position he should have been bending over backwards to make sure he was on sure footing and not misleading the public, and instead he let this paper full of basic mistakes go to press.
- wdevanny 6y agoCould you clarify your statements and provide references to the bad stats? I'm not sure if you are accusing the Stanford doctors in the article of bad stats or those arguing against the doctors in the article.
- epistasis 6y agoI'm talking about the Stanford doctor in this article. Here's a summary of what he's been doing since the start of this, and he's been very wrong: https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/experts-demolish-studies-suggesting-covid-19-is-no-worse-than-flu/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/experts-demolish-stu...
- k4l3 6y ago> In fact, criticism of the two studies has woven a damning tapestry of Twitter threads and blog posts pointing out flaws of the studies—everything from basic math errors to alleged statistical sloppiness and sample bias Unless I'm missing something, it's Twitter and blogs against published studies. Sounds like he's been proven wrong all right...
- gotoeleven 6y agoLike what are you talking about specifically?
- jhpriestley 6y agoDamn, these are the same people who came up with that ridiculous antibody study which fueled the crackpot "widespread immunity" theory? They must have no shame to keep pushing their contrarian covid takes.
- cozzyd 6y agoIt's not all of Stanford, just one group (Jay Bhattarcharya's) that published a paper that betrayed extreme ignorance of binomial confidence intervals and modeling in general and is now the subject of this article. Why anybody would listen to this group despite after that is a good question (although, since poor understanding of statistics is rampant in the Medical field, let alone among the general population, perhaps not too surprising). (disclaimer: Stanford '09)
- epistasis 6y agoIt's Battarcharya and a few others, including Ioannidis. However Stanford is completely complicit, and when I search for these people I get results like this that promote bad information and reasoning: https://fsi.stanford.edu/news/coronavirus-deadly-they-say https://fsi.stanford.edu/news/coronavirus-deadly-they-say Rather than anything from the university that promotes the more accurate statements from the rest of the faculty. So I would say that Stanford carries a lot of blame for letting their name be used for disinformation, and is not pushing back at all, which is a huge disgrace. If you are an alum, make some noise and refuse to make contributions until they start at least giving equal PR time to the scientifically based viewpoint. Edit: and how could I forget Michael Levitt, who is now following in Kary Mullis' footsteps as a Nobel winning biochemist that promotes for crazy viral theories that damage public health https://www.stanforddaily.com/2020/05/04/qa-nobel-laureate-says-covid-19-curve-could-be-naturally-self-flattening/ https://www.stanforddaily.com/2020/05/04/qa-nobel-laureate-s...
- cozzyd 6y agoWell the Daily is the independent student newspaper and has little to do with official University policy. I don't know what FSI is, perhaps some department that Bhattarcharya is part of. I agree, if it was being pushed by official Stanford news sources (a search for Bhattarcharya on https://news.stanford.edu/ https://news.stanford.edu/ reveals nothing, although plenty of other COVID-related research), that that might be problematic. I agree it's not a good look for Stanford, but but if people conflate researchers from a university with a university, then that's on them.
- sureshv 6y agoHow much of this is coming from https://www.hoover.org/ https://www.hoover.org/?