5 ms·
You can frame it as regulatory capture, but to a large extent, it's more about environmental and consumer protections that the auto industry has spent decades f
by klyrs 6y ago
You can frame it as regulatory capture, but to a large extent, it's more about environmental and consumer protections that the auto industry has spent decades fighting.
As somebody who drives an ancient car, I'm keenly aware of its lack of safety features. The "american steel" argument falls flat; my car was made before the concept of crumple zones, much less airbags -- driving this boat, I'd be seriously injured or die in a head-on collison with a Yaris, where the other driver and passengers would probably walk away. Unless my gas tank explodes and engulfs us all, that is.
If everybody was driving pre-1984 vehicles, the emissions would result in horrible smog, bringing most cities on par with Beijing.
The world must bring carbon emissions down to prevent severe climate change. Maybe lax safety standards could contribute to that; but environmental regulations must not go.
Follow up: the "free" market that you propose is not actually free, but ignorant of externalities that the modern market has limited facilities to account for.
- asdff 6y agoIs throttle and steering by wire a safety feature? No. Its objectively worse than having the physical linkage, and manufacturers turn to it out of ease of design.
- klyrs 6y agoSorry, but I'm not sure what part of my comment that you're responding to. Maybe you're rebutting my parent? Because I've never heard of a regulation towards drive-by-wire, so I suspect this particular aspect of automotive design is a result of a free market.
- Scoundreller 6y agoWhile I could see steer-by-wire driven by lowered production costs (easier to share parts between LHD and RHD models), I could also see it indirectly driven by weight savings to meet fuel economy regulations. No pinion shaft required. No pinion shaft cutout through the firewall means the body can be made with less steel. Belt-driven pumps are moving to electric-drive for efficiency, but when you're switching from hydraulic assist to motor-assist, making the whole thing 'by-wire' and motor driven reduces complexity.
- klyrs 6y agoSure, I can agree with the weight savings. Having hit a pothole recently, I've been driving with a bit of a lean... this could be extremely easy to fix in software, and I suspect that automatic recalibration would be pretty simple to implement. As it stands, I'm waiting for nice weather on a weekend in the Fall, and I'll probably end up at the mechanic. And economy of scale doesn't just apply to LHD/RHD, but the parts necessary to implement drive-by-wire can be shared between makes and models -- a Fiat won't need as much torque to steer as a Peterbilt, but in theory a huge amount of that system could be shared. That can significantly reduce engineering costs as well.
- Scoundreller 6y agoMeanwhile, I'm thinking about how lazy cars are making us and tinkering with disabling the power-steering pump. But with drive-by-wire, we could simulate all kinds of scenarios in software and switch between them.
- asdff 6y agoIf your car is leaning bad from a pothole the last thing you'd want to do is artificially correct yourself out of thinking you need to get your wheels aligned.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- netsharc 6y agoThrottle-by-wire helps with emissions and fuel consumption, technically making cars safer for all of us pollution-breathing humans: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_throttle_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_throttle_control
- asdff 6y agoNot seeing where in the article it states this explicitly. How does it work to help emissions? Compensation for drivers who have a lead foot?
- flyingfences 6y agoWith a traditional, mechanical throttle linkage, there's a momentary spike in emissions caused by a too-rich or too-lean combustion condition when you suddenly lift off or step on the throttle because the engine computer and fuel injection system can't compensate quickly enough. Throttle-by-wire allows the manufacturers to smooth the throttle position changes. Even when you snap your foot off the pedal, the throttle valve is now made to close over some significant fraction of a second, slowly and gradually enough for the fuel mixture control to keep pace.
- hetspookjee 6y agoWell for small quantity production there are exceptions. Like Pagani and Koenigsegg have a ridiculous high Co2/km brand average because of low quantity. So it's possible.
- fomine3 6y agoAlso miss ABS/TRC/ESC that's done by computer.