5 ms·
How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? Shouldn't the advise be to meet without microphones of any kind, if yo
by tsimionescu 6y ago
How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? Shouldn't the advise be to meet without microphones of any kind, if you're really that paranoid? And of course, I would expect that online conferences are right out - especially useful advice in the times of Covid19.
Unless this is advice for state-level institutions discussing state secrets, this seems like completely useless advice, the kind that gives security people a bad name. It is both too paranoid for regular businesses, and provides too little protection if you truly are being targeted for espionage. Especially in a time where most meetings are happening online.
- raziel2p 6y agoI generally agree with you, but one argument might be that corporate laptops can have strict security policies enforced, but people generally bring their unmanaged personal/private smartphones with them into meeting rooms.
- Aeolun 6y agoMy managed corporate smartphone is not significantly more secure than my personal one.
- galangalalgol 6y agoYou are probably not who they are worried about. My work phone has a corporate curated app store, corporate imessage server, and always on monitoring software. My private phone is full of sideloaded apks and runs as root.
- bitcharmer 6y agoDepends on your field, I guess. Been working for investment banks in front office engineering roles and the only more paranoid organisations I had experience with were exchanges (FX). Even as a power user you will never get admin rights on your machine, neither will you be permitted to download anything lest install it.
- Aeolun 6y agoMakes it a bit hard to work though doesn’t it?
- roenxi 6y agoPhones have a GPS chip and an internet connection that can bypass the corporate network. They are a slightly worse threat than a standard laptop. At least a laptop there is a chance of corporate IT noticing unusual network traffic.
- 082349872349872 6y agoLast century we had low bitrate codecs for full bandwidth speech over dialup modems. I think that little traffic would be shapeable. Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8CRA_yE4D-s&t=35 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8CRA_yE4D-s&t=35 ==== Wow Setara, fit 5. Da Komante Da Bik Im Du Xite Efa. (most Expanse asteroid belters prefer dubs to subs) Leya: Setashang Lando? Solo: Lando na setashang, im mang. ... Leya: To tenye timting mali to. Wamali, ye to tenye imalowda.
- pulse7 6y agoThe best ThinkPads - which are used in many corporations - use Intel's vPro technology. Intel is offering those corporations to "remotely wipe the hard disk - even if laptop is turned off and not connected to the internet - in case the laptop is stolen". This technology requires presence of WLAN and SIM card. So it bypasses the corporate IT completely...
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoThis comparison is absurd. A minority of laptops are thinkpads, a fraction of those have SIM cards, and, finally, attacking that subsystem requires serious skills and the benefits are dubious. Compare that with android/ios phones, which 99% of people have, and have a large underground market of backdoors that anybody can buy and install. Not to mention all the spyware that users and OEM install.
- wolco2 6y agoIt's the difference between finding an expliot for gmail vs finding one for a small discord server. Your attack on gmail has a bigger universe of targets if successful.
- Pick-A-Hill2019 6y agoThe difference is that a smartphone or tablet is an always on device and are also usually personal devices. In addition they are carried round in pockets or bags. Taking over a mobile device remotely and activating the camera and microphone is a real thing (citations available but https://www.wired.com/story/whatsapp-hack-phone-call-voip-buffer-overflow/ https://www.wired.com/story/whatsapp-hack-phone-call-voip-bu... from 2019 provides a solid 'is possible to do' example). I have worked in more than a few sites where all cell-phones needed to be placed in to faraday cage lockers located outside the highly secure areas prior to entering but laptops were ok to take in and use (subject to high contrast stickers over cameras, dummy jacks placed in mic sockets and wi-fi switched off). Given that these were a mixture of national infrastructure, military and embassy type sites and was a thing ten+ years ago I think the various governments are well aware of their own abilities and assume that the opposition have equal capabilities. I take your point regarding “Unless this is advice for state-level institutions discussing state secrets” but knowledge leaks and filters down in to the corporate world. Those same C-Suits that have to attend meetings discussing restricted information projects go away thinking – Huh, I wonder if it could be done to us by a competitor. When you consider the difficulties of verifying the supply chain of a random mobile device (from the chipset through to all installed apps) it leaves so many security holes that it is best to assume that anything a nation state can do so can a well skilled hacker (or group).
- dahfizz 6y ago> I think the various governments are well aware of their own abilities and assume that the opposition have equal capabilities. Exactly. From most people, "smartphones are spying on us" sounds a little tinfoil hat. Coming from the Director of Military Intelligence, however, gives the message some credence.
- XorNot 6y agoWhich still needs to be read with nuance though: militaries and governments are worried about targeted, specific efforts directed at specific individuals, and the general difficulty of securing random electronic devices which exist outside of high-security environments sometimes (close to impossible). This is probably a reasonable threat for executives to worry about, but it's still ultimately an expression of "we're concerned about a threat where breaking into a home and bugging the device or swapping it with a compromised one is a real concern".
- pulse7 6y ago"...if you're really that paranoid?" No, you can not call me a paranoid anymore. Before Snowden you could call me like that. But today, it is not secret anymore...
- hutzlibu 6y agoOh, you can be paranoid, even though they are after you ..
- ovi256 6y agoThe British capability to monitor webcams (Optic Nerve) was leaked even before Snowden, in 2012 FWIW: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optic_Nerve_(GCHQ) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optic_Nerve_(GCHQ)
- Iv 6y agoSnowden just told us to re-read EU's report on ECHELON or to just check what the Patriot act authorized.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhat Snowden has shown us is that we shouldn't have phones or other internet-connected devices at all if we deeply care about privacy and security. However, if, as most companies, you have already chosen to move the vast majority of internal communications, records and documentation in the cloud, it makes little sense to then be afraid that they'll listen to your meetings through your phone.
- Aeolun 6y agoI think his point is that everyone underestimates the chance they’ll be targeted.
- Foober223 6y ago> too paranoid It's a known risk from the Snowden leaks. So it's not fair to characterize it as paranoia.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIt's a known risk from the Snowden leaks for any internet - connected device.
- throw0101a 6y ago> How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? At least when it comes to smartphones, there is the baseband circuitry that tends to run completely independently of the OS: * https://techcrunch.com/2019/11/08/android-baseband-flaws/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/11/08/android-baseband-flaws/ * https://threatpost.com/baseband-zero-day-exposes-millions-of-mobile-phones-to-attack/124833/ https://threatpost.com/baseband-zero-day-exposes-millions-of... Some people do worry about the Intel Management Engine having similar issues: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#Security_vulnerabilities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#Securi...
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? They are more likely to be attacked because they are better targets. They are more often carried around, have GPS and more cameras. They are MUCH more difficult to manage centrally (e.g. company-managed antivirus/vpn/firewall, locked-down software installation, secure boot...), or inspect or modify. They are more often used to all sort of untrusted networks (cafe', airport, hotel...) Personal phones often have tons of untrusted apps with access to microphones. > Unless this is advice for state-level institutions discussing state secrets, this seems like completely useless advice citation needed, especially after Snowden revelations
- tsimionescu 6y agoIf you take the Snowden revelations seriously enough to worry about snooping on your board meetings, you should take them seriously enough to drastically reduce online communication and record keeping - as I'm sure stae-level institutions do. If you're a company whose financial reports, email and documents all reside in the cloud, having your boardroom meetings snooped on through your phone is the last of your worries.
- everdrive 6y agoMost people have out of date android, and the ecosystem for malware is much larger there than on an old Nokia dumbphone.
- chiefalchemist 6y ago> How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? Tech aside, one scenario: C level exec parent - or any parent - hands phone or tablet to child in backseat as a pacifier. That's much less likely with reg phone or laptop. Also, the fact that he didn't specifically mention laptops might simply be an oversight. That is, pretty much everyone will bring their phones or tablets. An exec with a laptop? In a meeting? Probably a rarity.
- jnxx 6y ago> How are smartphones and tablets different from laptops and regular phones in this regard? Smartphone location tracking data is extremely high-dimensional and sensitive. It is capable of revealing a lot of things which you might not even want to tell to your family. I think for a company such as Google, getting a list of CEOS in e.g. The Netherlands which visit psychotherapists, or occasionally spend the night at the home of their secretary when their wife is on business travel, is little more than an elaborate database query.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhat does this have to do with bringing smartphones to boardroom meetings?