9 ms·
Sure you can do anything with the hardware which you actually ha e bought! The problem is in the software (the driver) which you never can buy, only license un
by nine_k 6y ago
Sure you can do anything with the hardware which you actually ha e bought!
The problem is in the software (the driver) which you never can buy, only license under a long list of conditions which prohibit specific uses.
If e.g. Noveau could implement interfaces needed for CUDA, you could probably try to use a 3050 in a datacenter. I bet NVidia has provisions against this turn of events, too.
- amelius 6y ago> The problem is in the software (the driver) which you never can buy, only license under a long list of conditions which prohibit specific uses. Ok, so who gave software a special status over hardware? Is this desirable? Can we reverse it?
- jiggawatts 6y agoYes, maybe, but step #1 is to sue Oracle. See if you can convince them to "let you" publish a benchmark of their database management system. Start there.
- Retric 6y agoAmusingly, Oracle is known as the slowest major DB despite their heavy handed tactics. So, actual benchmarks might actually help their sales rather than people simply assuming it’s unacceptably slow.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mcny 6y agoDid this change recently? I remember my database professor in college was adamant that when they talk about databases, I am to assume some things as a given (going by memory, am probably not completely accurate): that the data set is large enough that cannot fit in memory that storage is orders of magnitude slower than memory and memory is orders of magnitude slower than processor cache Oracle has the “best implementation” given these constraints. Is that not the case?
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoThat's precisely the point, Oracle forbids benchmarking and comparisons in its licensing. So how would anyone (legally) know?
- anticensor 6y agoWell, you cannot legally publish a benchmark, but you can set up your own for your private uses. It is not like Oracle DB detects it is being benchmarked and shuts off itself.
- PeterisP 6y agoIt's worth noting that in current conditions the assumptions may be unwarranted. First, while storage used to be orders of magnitude slower than memory, not SSD storage is just a single order of magnitude slower; Second, in many domains now it's often practical to ensure that your data set can fit in memory. For example, if your system is for storing financial transactions (which is a prime market for Oracle), then your enterprise has to be quite large to get a terabyte of transactions and you can put a terabyte (or much more) of RAM in a database system if you choose to.
- nexuist 6y agoIt's not a special status, anyone has the right to deny you a hardware product as well. I don't have to sell cars to anyone if I don't want to. If I do want to sell someone a car, I can specify a contract or license that they must follow if they buy my car. Ferrari famously only sells exclusive models to customers who have been pre-approved, i.e. they have a certain amount of income and own 5+ Ferraris already. I also cannot walk into a Lockheed Martin dealership and tell them to sell me a F-22, even if I can afford it, even if my country has permissive laws regarding the ownership of fighter aircraft. As for software, well, EA has the right to ban me from their servers if I hack their games, even if I did pay for the product, and this makes sense because it ruins everyone else's experience. I don't pay for HN but if I did they still would have a right to ban my account if I start posting slurs or other abusive content. Is it desirable? Of course it's desirable; imagine having no control over your own creations and having to deal with the consequences of other people abusing it.
- rowanG077 6y agoThe examples of software you list aren't close to equivalent. They are all services and you can get banned from a service if you misbehave. But a piece of software such as a driver is not a service.
- nexuist 6y agoSoftware updates aren't a service? Doesn't Nvidia provide updates to its drivers over time? They can choose to cut anyone off from those, including the very first initial driver download. Sure, you can own and do whatever you want with the hardware - but good luck getting it to do anything useful if you can't access Nvidia's driver download service.
- rowanG077 6y agoYes software updates can be a service. Nvidia however doesn't provide a working version of their driver with a card. Just like buying a game is not a service but recievig updates can be.
- 6y ago
- ImprobableTruth 6y agoThere's nothing stopping nvidia from theoretically offering a gpu that is only rented out rather than sold. It's just not really considered acceptable for hardware (at the moment).
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThat's only because the hardware is a useless dongle without the software. Sure in theory you could run an open source driver, and in practice sometimes the river won't crash, but there's no point because you could get an equally good open source driver video card for the same price, since you can't get the fancy card's peak performance from the open source driver
- andromeduck 6y agoIsn't that what IAAS is in essence?
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Ok, so who gave software a special status over hardware? Some american politician extended copyright protection towards software. The rest of the world eventually did the same. > Is this desirable? No. > Can we reverse it? Sure. We just need to have billions of dollars just like the copyright industry. That money can buy a lot of influence.
- hiram112 6y ago> Some american politician extended copyright protection towards software. The rest of the world eventually did the same. >> Is this desirable? > No. So I'm sure you'd be happy if I just took the software for whatever great startup idea you'd been slaving away on for the last two years, slapped better marketing on it, and undercut you by 50% since I didn't have to employ all those pesky overpaid engineers.
- stale2002 6y agoIf someone purchased a product from me, and then used it however they want, that's fine. It is their product at that point, because they purchased it. You should not have the rights to control someone else's product, such a a graphics card, or whatever, after they have purchased it. It's theirs now.
- analognoise 6y agoYou're free to write your own graphics driver for the hardware you own, just as Nvidia is free to not help you.
- stale2002 6y ago> your own graphics driver My whole point is that there needs to be more efforts to hack and modify these things, and that this would be "more desireable". And that orgs should be using their power to cause this to happen more. For example, if open source orgs can weaponize licensing agreements against nvidia, in order to force them to do this, then they should and this would be desireable.
- jonas21 6y agoKeep in mind it's the same special status that allows the GPL to have the condition that you must release your source code if you distribute something that includes GPL code. So, "reversing" it would also reverse the GPL.
- Majromax 6y agoNot exactly. The GPL's special status generally comes from the fundamentals of copyright law: it attaches conditions to the duplication, modification, and distribution of a work. If not for the GPL, you'd have no right to distribute something containing the copyrighted code. The datacenter-versus-personal conditions of NVidia drivers attach instead to the use of the copyrighted work. These restrictions are based on the idea of an end user license agreement as an enforceable contract, either agreed-upon when the driver is downloaded or through a theory that copyright attaches to the temporary (in-memory) copy of the driver necessary to run it.
- mr_toad 6y ago> Ok, so who gave software a special status over hardware? Software is rarely sold (outside of bespoke development). All the off the shelf software is essentially rented. Software itself has no legal value - the copyright is what is considered to be property. That property can be leased or sold. This is why copyright infringement is called infringement and not theft. When you “buy” software, you are actually entering into a lease contract to use the software (sometimes perpetual, but increasingly only temporary) which can have various terms and conditions (that you really should read, but never do). But that lease doesn’t grant you the copyright.
- amelius 6y agoI think that's misleading then, because when I buy a GPU, they make me believe I own it, when, apparently, in reality I don't. I don't think this way of selling (or as you say renting) stuff should be considered legal.
- jopsen 6y agoYou own it, and can talk to it the same way you can talk to a brick, lol :D (I avoid nvidia whenever possible)
- daxfohl 6y agoWhat's the point of that? We do the same thing in software all the time. You get basic functionality for one price, and pay for a key to unlock extra features. Why should hardware be any different? So the law would somehow require any feature on a hardware product to have some physical difference and not be purely a software limitation? What is the advantage of that? Just increases cost to the manufacturer (which will get passed down), then also precludes any possibility of upgrades by purchasing a software patch.
- amelius 6y agoIt should be clearly communicated and never be misleading.
- rodgerd 6y agorms, amongst others, long maintained that firmware is different to software.
- ta76893547 6y agoThe difference between hardware and software is that copying is free for software. You can own the hardware and do whatever you want with it because for you to reproduce it would require you to effective be Nvidia. For software you can't give a user ownership of exactly 1 copy of software. If the purchaser has all of the rights of ownership they would have the right to distribute copies for free, which obviously make selling the same software impossible. Software is copied and hardware is moved, they're fundamentally different so the have to be treated differently
- toyg 6y agoIf the hardware is effectively useless without the software driver, it could be argued the whole thing is a bit of a fraud / misrepresentation. But I guess nobody wants to sue somebody with pockets as deep as nVidia to change the status quo.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIt's not fraud; you can return the purchase if you don't like the software license.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoGTX/RTX cards are sold as gaming cards so its not misrepresentation. If it was then every bit of hardware with locked down software would be fraud.
- toyg 6y ago“Locking down” is not the problem - the problem is that you are told you’re buying goods when you are actually buying goods which require access to rented software in order to function at all. It’s like buying a blender and then finding out that you’re not allowed to blend anything unless someone in the manufacturers’ operation approves of it.
- newdude 6y ago"The problem is in the software (the driver) which you never can buy, only license under a long list of conditions which prohibit specific uses." Well, buying and licensing are not so different in Europe (first sale doctrine). The company can not forbid you to resell a license (Exhaustion of intellectual property rights) in Europe.
- bdowling 6y agoThe US respects first sale doctrine as well. See Vernor v. Autodesk, Inc. 555 F. Supp. 2d 1164. [0] However, the ability to resell a license doesn’t remove other conditions, e.g., restrictions on data center usage. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vernor_v._Autodesk,_Inc https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vernor_v._Autodesk,_Inc.