4 ms·
I've just requested my data. When I get it I'll take a look and see if it contains playlist information and either edit this comment or post a reply to myself i
by tzs 6y ago
I've just requested my data. When I get it I'll take a look and see if it contains playlist information and either edit this comment or post a reply to myself if the edit window has closed with the results. They say it can take up to 30 days to process.
- morsch 6y agoHere's a previous discussion of someone getting the full dataset: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17681289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17681289 Tried the GDPR data export from Spotify. By default, you get like 6 JSON files with almost nothing. After many emails and complaining and a month of waiting, I got a 250MB archive with basically EVERY INTERACTION I ever did with any Spotify client, all my searches. Everything.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y ago> They say it can take up to 30 days to process. What the heck... My current day-job is a multi-tenant SaaS system - every single entity in any of our heterogenous databases is tagged with a tenant identifier (it's also used in composite PKs/FKs in RDBMS databases to prevent incorrect inter-tenant references). Every database system we use (MSSQL, MySQL, Cassandra, etc) has some way to query itself (INFORMATION_SCHEMA, system_schema, etc) which allows for query-generation to generate queries that will reliably dump all data we have associated with any tenant (and by extension, any user) within seconds, even if there's been some ad-hoc or unplanned database design changes (this is the only time I use "SELECT *" in production code!) - this is from a weekend project where I wrote a simple web-application that generates and runs those queries and dumps data to CSV files for tables and JSON for document-stores, shoves them into a zip and uploads them to Azure Blob storage. I didn't build it for GDPR compliance but actually to allow me to undo any unintentional data-deletion without needing to do a full database restore. My operation's scale is nothing compared to Spotify - but if a tool I built in a couple of days can reliably dump all data about a subject across multiple independent cloud databases within seconds - what's Spotify's excuse?
- draaglom 6y agoThe 30 day figure is likely derived from the legal limit under GDPR for a Subject Access Request (one calendar month). Why commit to a tighter SLA than you legally have to?
- ViViDboarder 6y agoExactly. I’d be surprised if it actually takes 30 days, but there’s no point to them quoting something faster.
- toast0 6y agoAs someone else mentioned, there's a legal maximum, and I think a company is also held to their quoted timeframe (and they may be required to quote a timeframe as well). Additionally, having a delay can be useful to make it harder for someone to take over your account, and grab all your data; especially if there's sensitive data that might not be otherwise accessible or enumeratable through the UI or API.
- tpmx 6y agoIt's obviously not a technical problem. The 30 days comes from the GDPR legislation. Spotify is just behaving like an obnoxious child that needs a good smackdown from the EU. Howevever the GDPR also stipulates that this needs to happen without "undue delay". I'm not a lawyer specializing in EU law, but I think this wording was put there for the precise reason of being able to punish companies that behave like that. They'll get to them eventually.
- jrockway 6y agoI don't think that's fair. If the law sets the limit at 30 days, there is no reason to do it sooner than 30 days. It is obviously a money-losing proposition to do it quickly, and the only reason it's an option at all is because of the law. I guess that makes it a reasonable compromise -- everyone is equally unhappy, but the world is a slightly better place. The reality is that "30 days" translates to "someone will run a script manually once a month" whereas something like "100 milliseconds" would force you to have automation. It's a reasonable tradeoff for rare events. There is a lot less engineering effort required, and that makes it cheaper.
- tzs 6y agoI got the results. It contains playlists.