6 ms·
> What I’ve come to appreciate in the years since is that the stories portrayed were not exactly value neutral. Television, like all forms of fiction, contains
by crazygringo 6y ago
> What I’ve come to appreciate in the years since is that the stories portrayed were not exactly value neutral. Television, like all forms of fiction, contains implicit messages about how to be a good person and what sort of aims are worth pursuing.
This is very, very, very true. A screenwriting teacher of mine once explained to me that the vast majority of us no longer get our "sermons" from church. We get them from sitcoms.
Sitcoms aren't just joke-delivery vehicles or advertising conduits (though they're those, too). They're actually the primary place the majority of Americans learn about how to be a good person.
It may sound like a bizarre claim at first, but pretty much every sitcom follows a plot something along the lines of: character has bad idea, character debates whether to do it, character does bad idea, idea seems to succeed at first, idea ultimately fails miserably, character is in trouble, character gets bailed out by someone who loves them, character learns their lesson. Virtually every sitcom episode demonstrates a moral lesson in their A-plot. (B plots and C plots are more often just gags though.)
Given the amount of TV most Americans watch, we learn far more "lessons" in any given week or month than we have the opportunity to do so in real life or through friends.
Sitcom writers actually hold a tremendous place of responsibility in American society that they can use (and have used) for good. As the article notes, Will & Grace was a big factor in changing Americans' attitudes towards gay people. Just like the Cosby show was for attitudes towards Black families. So you might think sitcoms are dumb... but they're a huge part of people's moral education, most of all when watching them as kids and teenagers.
- rmrfstar 6y agoPeople use the phrase "TV programming" without a hint of irony.
- discordance 6y ago... and here we are playing out Idiocracy
- 082349872349872 6y agocompare the 1952 take: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24739131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24739131
- ashtonkem 6y agoThis is something the right has been complaining about for a long time, the shift of this moral authority from its traditional stewards (usually the churches) to the television writer. It’s unclear to me how much of the complaint has to do with disliking the results, especially around the acceptance of homosexuality, and how much of it is a complaint about the shift in power itself. As you said, a lot of the moral lessons in sitcoms are fairly benign, as they usually center around the idea that bad actions have consequences but forgiveness and salvation is available if you ask for it. THe core message isn’t that different than what you’d see in some sermons, only the jokes are new.
- jackfoxy 6y agoEvery time a pastor has a personal scandal or other personal problem, especially the mega-church pastors, it becomes fodder for media exploitation. Do television writers, producers, and actors get the same public proctology exam? Rarely. But it does happen. The college admissions scandal and Harvey Weinstein come to mind. But in general the moral authority is now an industry that self monitors its moral rectitude.
- crazygringo 6y agoWell, TV writers are paid peanuts next to mega-church pastors, so there's less scope for charges of hypocrisy. Also scripts are generally developed by a room of writers, not any single one. But the reality is that it is monitored, but certainly not self-monitored -- it's monitored by advertisers. If an pilot or episode isn't acceptable, advertisers will yank their money in a heartbeat. This is why mostly all sitcoms preach a "conventional" middle-class morality, because that's specifically what advertisers find palatable. It's also why the first dark/shocking drama on TV -- The Sopranos -- was only possible on a network that was subscriber-supported instead of advertiser-supported, namely HBO.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Well, TV writers are paid peanuts next to mega-church pastors, so there's less scope for charges of hypocrisy. Well, how many "mega"-churches are there though? How many people congregate to them versus the local micro-/mini-church? Also, just because a pastor is a hypocrite doesn't necessarily make them wrong: * https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/tu-quoque https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/tu-quoque * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque A doctor who smokes, but tells you smoking is bad for your health, is a hypocrite but still medically correct. :) > Also scripts are generally developed by a room of writers, not any single one. Usually in the US: in the (e.g.) the UK each series/season is often done by an individual (or 2-3).
- Firebrand 6y agoIt doesn’t bode well for society if kids and teenagers are spending more and more time watching YouTube videos and Twitch streamers compared to scripted shows, then.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoTo that end “Unboxing” and “review” videos seem to have already had their impact. It probably will make me an old man in the eyes of some portion of the following generation but there’s only so much that I can take of watching a person celebrate opening yet more free shit and yelling and swearing through an inanimate box at people they don’t know. It’s not all bad, but by I swear there are more “product review” channels than ever and they’re spreading like dandelions.
- ryandrake 6y agoWhy would you watch it if you don't like it?
- 52-6F-62 6y agoMost of the time I don’t. Since many shops are closed to anything but appointments in the music world I’ve relied on hearing some shared equipment demos and experiences which the recommendation algorithm promptly sees fit to take as suggestion that I love just watching product videos and unboxings so they regularly show up next in my queue and begin to play before I can get to preventing it. I’m also of a curious persuasion so I’ll stick it out for a while wondering what people find so fascinating—maybe that I was missing something. But I wasn’t, not so far as I’ve been able to tell yet. If a majority of what children take in from something as powerful as the immense capacity for information sharing as the internet is watching someone open a material item they covet over and over again I don’t think that it can possibly be healthy for them in the long term—especially with a lack of other contextual framing.
- bennysonething 6y agoI'll never understand unboxing. It's just depressing to think that anyone could waste their life watching someone else open boxes.
- hvs 6y agoI got a significant number of my morality lessons from Saved By The Bell and Blossom.
- 0xfaded 6y agoIs there a list of common story lines somewhere? I used to watch sitcoms as a kid, so my memory needs to stretch back a bit, but that seems to sum up almost any episode that I can think of. I've heard something along the lines of "there are only 6 types of plots and every movie is just a rehash of one of them", but I've never actually found the list.
- severine 6y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2016/jul/13/three-six-or-36-how-many-basic-plots-are-there-in-all-stories-ever-written https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2016/jul/13/thre...
- severine 6y agoAnd of course https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Plots https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Plots But be aware of the rabbit hole!
- lqet 6y ago> Virtually every sitcom episode demonstrates a moral lesson in their A-plot. Seinfeld may be a major exception to this rule.
- humanrebar 6y agoI don't think so. It's just the lessons were through bad examples. George wouldn't let something go. Jerry would be an overly critical boyfriend. Kramer would reject good advice. All of them lied, gossiped, and snarked about their social circles constantly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slg 6y agoYeah, the show literally ends with the four of them in jail due to their moral failings. They are anti-heros that serve as a counterexample to acceptable behavior.
- paganel 6y agoWas thinking of Seinfeld, too. I’d add “Curb Your Enthusiasm” (of course), “Arrested Development” and even “The Office”.
- lqet 6y agoI wouldn't add either the British or the American "The Office" to that list. Just think of the relationship between Jim and Pam in the American version, there are clear moral lessons there.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Given the amount of TV most Americans watch, we learn far more "lessons" in any given week or month than we have the opportunity to do so in real life or through friends. Some of the things learned may not be entirely accurate: > Copaganda, a portmanteau of cop and propaganda, is the phenomenon in which news media and other social institutions promote celebratory portrayals of police officers with the intent of swaying public opinion for the benefit of police departments and law enforcement.[1] Copaganda has been defined by cultural critics in the United States as "media efforts to flatter police officers and spare them from skeptical coverage,"[2] "pieces of media that are so scarily disconnected from the reality of cops that they end up serving as offbeat recruitment ads,"[3] and "videos, photos, and news clips of police officers dancing, praying, or handing out free food" used to boost public relations.[1] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copaganda https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copaganda * https://boingboing.net/2020/10/07/what-is-copanganda-and-how-did-these-shows-emerge.html https://boingboing.net/2020/10/07/what-is-copanganda-and-how... * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udhDawfCLHo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udhDawfCLHo
- humanrebar 6y ago> Some of the things learned may not be entirely accurate... Yeah, but that's also very true of sermons at places of worship. That's speaking as someone who thinks an accurate sermon is possible.
- throw0101a 6y agoIn the modern era there are quite a few sermon podcasts, which is handy if the local pastor(s) aren't skilled in that particular area. Just have to be careful about entering an echo chamber of too-like minded voices.
- crazygringo 6y agoYes, but even with that, shows are responding. Shows grow together with society. After Black Lives Matter protests this summer, Brooklyn Nine-Nine cancelled already-written scripts when they realized, essentially, that they were unwittingly part of this "copaganda", and that they need to start over [1]: > “We’re all in touch and kind of discussing how you make a comedy show about police right now, and if we can find a way of doing that so we all feel morally okay about.” Because the show being "morally okay" is a responsibility they actually take quite seriously. (Remember, co-creator Mike Schur also created The Good Place, a hit sitcom about morality itself.) [1] https://hypebeast.com/2020/7/brooklyn-nine-nine-andy-samberg-black-lives-matter-news https://hypebeast.com/2020/7/brooklyn-nine-nine-andy-samberg...
- teddyh 6y agoIt can also be used for very dubious purposes: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheComplainerIsA...
- dbspin 6y agoThere is something subtler and more important concealed in sitcoms and dramas. Narrative has its own logic. By that I mean that there are kinds of things that are easy to describe in certain media and difficult or impossible to describe in others. And also that the systematic requirements of storytelling satisfaction act to prioritise certain kinds of understandings of the world. One simple but ill understood way in which this is true is in the numbers of people interacting within a group or institution. In drama the audience can keep in mind only a set number of major actors - even in a relatively complex political procedural, at most a dozen characters will recur. In reality, the humblest institution may have dozens or hundreds of regularly interacting people who take active part in decision making. So the implicit and unintended myth created by all films and television diminishes the importance of the collective - with its web of loyalties and contrasting intentions - and replaces it with a tiny number of easily tracked isolates. Character motivations always need to be personalised in drama, with 'complex' motivation existing to humanise rather than explicate action. There are countless other examples of the ways drama systematically distorts our understanding of life and politics. From the disavowal of the motivating force ideology and (even in the United States) religion, to the systematic concealment of poverty. None of these necessarily require censorship or explicit manipulation. They're not simply expressions of a particular societies blindness to its own flaws. But exemplars of what can easily be transmitted in drama.
- dougmwne 6y agoThis is a great insight. I think it's also worth mentioning that TV is an imperfect representation of our moral reality. TV shows are primarily meant to entertain and keep us watching. Their budgets, production and writing are often slapdash. The shows are absolutely packed with value judgements, though often the creators are not fully in control of the message and the lessons are either contradictory or downright fantastical. We are the TV people. As I get older I realize more and more that TV raised everybody. I watch us act out the screen dramas in our real lives. I learned professional etiquette from office dramas and sitcoms, and so did everyone else. I re-watched TNG recently and realized it's not a show about aliens on military spaceships, it's a show about people from the late 80's and early 90's aspiring to a better and more inclusive office culture filled with universally competent co-workers who do not harass each other. It is a vision of a world that will never exist. The author of the article maybe has it all a bit confused. He is not binging on prestige TV to learn more about his upper class peers. His upper class peers learned to be themselves by binging on prestige TV. He had gone right to the source. Jean Baudrillard would agree. Life imitates art imitating art and so on.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThis mimetic dynamic is exactly why I believe Brave New World and 1984 both have more to say about the large changes in anglophone society between 1910 and 1930 than an orthodox facile dismissal as science fiction dystopias would lead one to believe. (my hobby: guessing not when costume dramas are set, but when they were shot.) Bonus branding: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Droste_effect#/media/File:Droste_cacao_100gr_blikje,_foto_02.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Droste_effect#/media/File:Dros... Edit: as to whether "his upper class peers" are upper or not I will leave to those of you who are nearer to them to discuss.
- dougmwne 6y agoI'm no authority, but as far as it goes the author probably encountered plenty of actual upper class americans at ivy league schools. I was inspired to watch a few episodes of the West Wing to see if I could sus out what he was talking about. I could pretty easily tell that Aaron Sorkin wrote it from a middle class perspective that fetishized and idealized wealth, education and power that he did not himself possess. I can see why ivy leaguers would like it, since it flatters them at every chance.
- alexpetralia 6y agoI'm going to leave here the one of the best essays I've read on narratives: https://www.moviemaker.com/hollywoods-four-classic-narrative-types-part-i-when-the-bad-guys-win/ https://www.moviemaker.com/hollywoods-four-classic-narrative...
- 082349872349872 6y agocompare https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23637670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23637670
- alexpetralia 6y agoVery interesting! Thanks for sharing.
- mstade 6y agoMy English education as a Swedish kid mostly consisted of watching shows on Cartoon Network. People always think it's a joke when I offer Hanna-Barbera cartoons as the explanation for why I speak English with a North American accent. They just assume I studied in the US or Canada, or grew up there. Not gonna lie – most things I know I probably learned from watching TV shows, movies, and more recently YouTube videos.
- 082349872349872 6y agoHow well do North Americans you interact with (online or off) match up with your media education? Any clear disconnects?
- mstade 6y agoAmericans typically assume I'm from somewhere in the Midwest but can't quite place where, and when I say I'm not American they assume I'm Canadian. It's usually a bit of back and forth before they believe that I'm actually Swedish, and sometimes I have to bust out the börk börk as proof – it's a lot of fun! :o)
- 082349872349872 6y agoMange tak. I was more interested in the other direction: were there any situations where you'd been surprised by americans behaving other than how you'd been led to believe by their media? (I'd been told the literal börk börk is a false attribution, and that he sounds more like a norwegian chef. Or at least a danish chef trying to sing with a mouth full of potato?)
- lqet 6y agoThanks for this comment. I just realized that I was morally raised by the first 10 seasons of The Simpsons.
- mncharity 6y ago> character has bad idea [...] learns their lesson [...] Sitcom writers actually hold a tremendous place of responsibility in American society Seemingly not widely known, is that sitcom scripts were for years often submitted to the office of the White House Drug Czar, for approval and negotiated revision. IIRC, the carrot was the show counting towards a station's public service broadcast time requirements? So a "90210" script containing drug use for instance, might be revised to reflect a list of requests, intended to present it more clearly as bad idea. As we now collectively design a censorship regime for more recent social tech, it might be interesting to see insightful non-narrow analysis of past regimes.
- gmadsen 6y agowith this in mind, do you think there is a concerted effort by corporate media to sway public opinion in ways that might not be ethical?
- Simulacra 6y agoThis is why I miss all of the old Nick at Nite shows from the 50s-70s. They seemed to have a more overt “do the right thing” plot line.