4 ms·
>And we do not guess, we know, that we can derive from the laws for the constituents what the whole object does. If you make a claim to the contrary, you are co
by Barrin92 6y ago
>And we do not guess, we know, that we can derive from the laws for the constituents what the whole object does. If you make a claim to the contrary, you are contradicting well-established science. I can’t prevent you from denying scientific evidence, but I can tell you that this way you will never understand how the universe really works."
I mean this is just flat out wrong and actually terrible science. Everyone who has taken a class on complex systems is aware of the phenomenon of emergence. You cannot understand the dynamics of a bird flock by breaking it down to the individual birds, and you cannot understand the dynamics of a hurricane by looking at each individual particle. A steering wheel cannot drive, an exhaust pipe cannot drive and a tire cannot drive, but a car can drive. The human mind is of course another important example. You can pry someone's head open and break the brain down to its constituent parts, but you will not find a mind anywhere in there.
Systems can have properties that are not found in any of its parts, because it's the interaction of the parts, not the parts themselves, that produce those properties. That is why reductionism has never been a successful enterprise, and why we indeed do not have a "unified science" (as some of the logical positivists imagined) which explains the totality of all things in one formal language. (i.e. physics).
- Supermancho 6y ago> Everyone who has taken a class on complex systems is aware of the phenomenon of emergence. Interactions (any observed results) are side effects of deterministic properties. Not knowing all initial states or the complexity of the intetactions being incomprehensible in aggregate (by humans) is not relevant. Emergence is not incommensurate with determinism. Full stop. Once you figure out that time is an illusion of local shared human memory (if you travel to nonlocal spacetime you will have a divergent memory), the situation becomes clearer. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-6rWqJhDv7M https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-6rWqJhDv7M Wake me up when there's something new to talk about.
- elevenoh 6y ago>Interactions (any observed results) are side effects of deterministic properties That's my understanding as well. I'm trying find utility in the 1st comment, but I don't see the direction of causality - e.g. emergence of culture from physics (bottom up) - is relevant in determining whether something non-deterministic.
- Barrin92 6y ago>I'm trying find utility in the 1st comment, but I don't see the direction of causality - e.g. emergence of culture from physics (bottom up) - is relevant in determining whether something non-deterministic. physical determinism isn't relevant for the concept of free will, that is the point of the comment. Emergent properties of the system by definition do not exist at the reductionist level of physics, but that does not render them "not real". It's simply a category error to say that free will does not exist because constituent parts of a system are deterministic, in the same sense as saying that consciousness does not exist because you cannot find it at the level of a neuron, or that the car cannot drive because none of its parts can. Also on the issue of causality which is important, complex systems don't just exhibit bottom-up causality, but the reverse, the system can only made sense of if one takes into account the downward causality from the macro to the micro level which explains why the system functions the way it does and that is what 'will' is in the context of a human to begin with. It's because the system cannot be reduced to bottom-up processes that it is complex, and it is for that reason that concepts such as 'freedom', autonomy', 'intentionality' and so on make sense.
- maest 6y ago> deterministic properties. Thing is, I don't see this addressing quantum mechanics. The randomness in QM is _truly_ random, it's not just a deterministic system where we can't learn the initial state. I'm not saying that means there is free will, but it does counter the argument that everything is _deterministic_. The other wrinkle is that you can have a deterministic system in an infinite space - I'm not sure if that setup still precludes free will.
- withinboredom 6y agoYou’re making the assumption that nondeterministic QM is the right one. There are other interpretations that are deterministic[1]. Even if it is not deterministic, it’s not determined by free will so it’s a nonissue. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave_theory
- ykevinator 6y agoThat's not what she's saying she is saying systems do not have magic, their aggregate behavior is exclusively a function of the singletons. That can include their interactions.
- jffhn 6y ago>Everyone who has taken a class on complex systems is aware of the phenomenon of emergence. Reminds me of some conference (lost the URL) of Robert Laughlin, where he said (if I recall correctly) that rigidity (e.g. of a steel bar) was an emergent property, to which someone in the audience objected that sure enough it should be deducible from quantum mechanics, which he dismissed. That would mean that emergence can occur even in simple systems (regularly packed atoms), and for quite basic properties.
- hackinthebochs 6y agoThere are no uncontroversial examples of non-reductive emergence. Of course you could understand the dynamics of a hurricane by analyzing each individual particle. There are practical limits in doing so, but there are no theoretical limits to predicting the behavior of the whole from the parts.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Of course you could understand the dynamics of a hurricane by analyzing each individual particle that's actually an article of faith because scientifically speaking we can't. And that's important because it's where reductionism subtly goes from being treated as a scientific method to a sort of belief system. It's not actually obvious at all that say, complex mind states or intentionality can be reduced to physics. It even seems extremely unlikely, because there's no conceivable way to me how the 'aboutness' of intentional mind states are supposed to be reduced to particles. Another good example is maybe life itself. Schrödinger in his book What is Life? categorised life as local 'negative entropy', ordering matter at a local level and exporting excess entropy to the outside, in a sense locally 'breaking' the second law of thermodynamics. When our civilisation warms the planet up and produces heat what it really does is exporting disorder, I think it's quite a good description actually. Aside from the fact that we scientifically haven't proven it, it's hard to imagine how this sort of top-down causal behaviour and complexity is supposed to be reduced to mostly linear particle interactions.
- hackinthebochs 6y agoIt's certainly unproven whether complex systems are reducible, but this doesn't mean the alternative is on equal footing. Science since its inception has been one long process of reducing that which was previously thought irreducible. Standard physical processes, like hurricanes, can easily be though of as reducible by inference to the best explanation, as they present no apparent difficulties with reduction aside from access to information and sufficient computation. There are other phenomena from which one can make a case for non-reduction, but I don't think even the best case to be made is all that strong. In my opinion, the only phenomena to present a real challenge for reduction is phenomenal consciousness. I don't personally consider intentionality and life to be insurmountable problems for reduction. The 'negative entropy' of life is really just a computational problem: find the configuration that has the property of being self-sustaining in the face of disordering forces. But some natural processes have a natural computational description, e.g. systematically producing variations of states, and preserving 'successful' states to seed the next generation of state space search. In other words, evolutionary processes are natural computational processes. I don't see the need for an extra ingredient. Intentionality is about meaning, i.e. how can some process have some intrinsic meaning. The answer is probably similar in spirit to the answer of negative entropy. Meaning has an external relation in the sense of being substantiated by context (e.g. a binary digit means heads/tails vs day/night depending on its context). But if you have enough of these meaning units in relation to one another, the system as a whole bootstraps the meaning of itself. E.g., some neuron in a brain means Jennifer Aniston because of the context it sits in the milleu of neurons that collectively create a disposition to respond appropriately to Jennifer Aniston.