5 ms·
Sure that country can force Apple to comply with local laws. That’s how it works now.
by m3kw9 6y ago
Sure that country can force Apple to comply with local laws. That’s how it works now.
- kodablah 6y agoApple can also choose to challenge it, if not legally there then at least in the court of public opinion as they have done for US government requests. The reason they haven't is either fear of speaking out or that they don't disagree much with the requests. Either way, their silence is a deafening description of their principles.
- zepto 6y agoThey US government requests they have challenged are not credible legal requirements, and there is reliable due process to challenge them. Belarus’s legal system doesn’t afford them this luxury.
- dan-robertson 6y agoIn this case it is telegram which the government ought to need to compel. Or they could make Apple remove the telegram app. But that hasn’t happened
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Or they could make Apple remove the telegram app. Which is effective primarily because there’s no (practical) way to sideload on iOS! This is why I’ve always seen the locked-down nature of the iPhone as a threat to free expression first and foremost. Apple is responsible for setting the system up this way.
- kace91 6y agoI don't fully buy this idea, because I've never seen an app become successfully widespread through side loading. The technical friction is just too high for non technical users. I agree that we need a solution to monopolistic app stores though.
- banachtarski 6y agoThis is somewhat circular reasoning though. Apple and Google have deliberately made it impossible or difficult to sideload to maximize profits.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThere's nothing particularly difficult about side loading on Google. It's off by default because it's an excellent vector for malicious actors to compromise a user's phone. Users, in the average case, haven't gotten smarter since the days of trojans and malware running rampant under the Windows architecture.
- paulgb 6y ago> I've never seen an app become successfully widespread through side loading Isn't Fortnite on Android an example of this? It was in the Play store for a pariod, but IIRC it was not when it was first released and isn't there again after their spat with Google.
- tripzilch 6y ago> I don't fully buy this idea Apple is currently literally being a threat to free expression in a situation where it really matters. You don't need to buy the idea, but they're doing it.
- kace91 6y agoI don't fully buy the idea _that sideloading solves this potential abuse_, not that the abuse exists, I thought that was clear. I'd hate it if the big players got to take decisions against human rights under the excuse that an alternative technically exists.
- supportlocal4h 6y agoWhy does a single app have to be widespread to matter? This is exactly the case where a small group would want a particular app because their life and freedom depend on it. They're not looking to put Facebook out of business or be the next big world fad.
- toyg 6y agoI agree in principle. In practice, this can be achieved today for a handful of apps with AltStore.io.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAltStore is great, but it requires you to run a server on a computer on the same wifi network as your phone, at least once week. I don't consider this a particularly practical way to side-load, even if it is better than the alternatives. Protestors in Belarus shouldn't need to also be IT administrators. Sideloading does have risks, and so it doesn't need to be too easy. As a point of comparison, I really like how disabling SIP works on the Mac—the user needs to reboot the computer into recovery mode and run a short Terminal command. This process feels dangerous, but it's really quite easy, and it only needs to be done once per machine. I could guide even a very technology-illiterate person through the process, if I absolutely needed to.
- dan-robertson 6y agoCan’t telegram be accessed through a website?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoNo push notifications, among other limitations.
- foepys 6y agoSo if an app shows an image of two men kissing, Apple should order the app makers to take it down worldwide because it's illegal in Uganda?
- toxik 6y agoFAANG etc have been kowtowing to oppressive regimes for well over a decade, did you not get the memo? Profit decides, not ethics.
- psychoslave 6y agoProfitability is not absolute: what profits the best to mankind happiness maximization might widely differs from what might optimize profit for a few individuals
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newbie578 6y agoYou state an excellent point and I would love to see the Apple fanboys argue your point.
- oxymoran 6y agoI love how people say Apple fanboys like it’s an insult. Is there a legitimate, better option to apple? No because the smartphone market is dominated by google and apple. At least apple pretends to care about privacy. Yes, apple are obviously hypocrites. Still better than google. If there was another viable choice I would happily go with that.
- tripzilch 6y agoSorry but what's Google done that is worse than this? These are people trying to save their country, from rigged elections and an oppressive regime. That's what they use communication for, and Apple shutting this down, choosing the side of the party that stole the election through cheating and force. I'm not a big fan of Google (nor Apple), but I'm having a hard time thinking of something Google did that is so straight up egregious. But maybe there is, and I forgot about it.
- Zak 6y agoThis illustrates why having large portions of the population using hyper-centralized platforms is a problem[0]. A system based around a single point of failure is inherently brittle. While I don't blame Apple for obeying local laws, or even for having a strict moderation policy for chat apps in its store, I do blame Apple for banning sideloading from a platform that's a general-purpose computing and communication tool for a large fraction of the human population. [0] There is an assumption built in to this that governments censoring their political opponents is bad; I choose not to question it here.