4 ms·
Everything you say is subjective (at best) or tautological (at worst) until you put a number to what you are calling a "megadose" or "excessive." "Megadose" is
by hammock 6y ago
Everything you say is subjective (at best) or tautological (at worst) until you put a number to what you are calling a "megadose" or "excessive." "Megadose" is relative and needs to be couched with the emerging (not really, it's a decade old at least I believe) that the current official RDA of vit D is about 4-5x TOO LOW and was based on bad data (or a misinterpretation of the data).
- jrumbut 6y agoWhether or not that's true, the article isn't talking about 4-5x the RDA. It's talking about massive doses beyond even the most aggressive supplementation, much less a normal days intake.
- nostromo 6y agoAccording to the paper she was indeed taking 325 times the recommended daily dose of Vitamin D for 20 months. The paper is indeed pretty silly. "How much is too much? Somewhere between 1x and 325x RDA apparently."
- jhardy54 6y agoThank you for posting the actual number instead of just saying "excessive" or "megadose". (It's true, I didn't read the article.)
- sbierwagen 6y agoFortunately, there is a link at the top of the page, which leads to the very article that OP is talking about.
- dec0dedab0de 6y ago...the current official RDA of vit D is about 4-5x TOO LOW... The person in the study was taking 162.5x the largest recommended daily allowance.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Everything you say is subjective (at best) or tautological (at worst) until you put a number to what you are calling a "megadose" or "excessive." The Vitamin D blood level range is clearly indicated on the blood test results. That’s why I suggested that people get the blood test. Blood test shows too little Vitamin D? Supplement more. Blood test shows you’re approaching or exceeding the upper limit? Supplement less. There’s nothing subjective about it. > the current official RDA of vit D is about 4-5x TOO LOW and was based on bad data (or a misinterpretation of the data). This claim, however, is unbounded. We can’t just go around telling people “more is better” and that the official recommendations are vaguely “too low” and expect people to just guess at the real range.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> This claim, however, is unbounded. We can’t just go around telling people “more is better” and that the official recommendations are vaguely “too low” and expect people to just guess at the real range. I don't understand this sentence at all. 4-5x is an extremely specific amount, with no guessing.