8 ms·
Apple is nothing else but the digital equivalent of a landlord extracting economic rents from everyone in the ecosystem. It's time to put an end to it, and whil
by Barrin92 6y ago
Apple is nothing else but the digital equivalent of a landlord extracting economic rents from everyone in the ecosystem. It's time to put an end to it, and while we're at it the same goes for all the other platform owners.
We (in this case the EU) should give it the same treatment we gave credit card companies. Cap their rates at 1% or whatever so they can cover the operational costs of their stores, stop them from banning apps from their stores that aren't breaking any laws, and that's that. If they want to make more money for their shareholders they should actually build things rather than abuse their gatekeeper position.
Just imagine if Microsoft had taken a 30% cut from every developer who ever compiled software for windows, or told them what software stack to use to develop their software. We'd have gone on the barricades immediately. Microsoft had to face scrutiny for bundling a browser, compared to what smartphone companies have done to their devices that was a joke
- d1zzy 6y agoWhen you will build your own piece of land from scratch then you also get to decide what laws govern it. The iPhone, iOS and the Apple Store exist because someone had the idea, will and spent tons of money building it. They aren't natural resources that Apple acquired and imposed on people so now everyone else has no choice but to pay the Apple tax. So I don't see how that analogy applies here.
- zo1 6y agoWhat about the products of my labor that I create from scratch? Can I decide what laws govern that too? You know, like taxes? That idea went out the window a long time ago. Now we are all beholden to each-other and society on some level, so best we deal with it and solve these anti-competative issues and predatory platforms, otherwise let's agree that it's completely immoral and stop cherry-picking "moral rules" based on what we find useful at the time.
- Barrin92 6y ago>When you will build your own piece of land from scratch then you also get to decide what laws govern it. I don't know where you live but where I do the government determines laws, on my property or otherwise. i can't just do what i want on my property just because it's my property. Neither my actual land or the digital land of the app store are some sort of extraterritorial space, we're not living in the Shadowrun universe
- rfw300 6y ago> Just imagine if Microsoft had taken a 30% cut from every developer who ever compiled software for windows Microsoft has the whole code-signing racket going on for Windows, but that's at least a flat fee in fairness.
- donmcronald 6y agoYeah. That’s another good example of abusing a market position to limit options to incumbents. I’d love to have LE style domain validate code signing certificates.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Apple is nothing else but the digital equivalent of a landlord extracting economic rents from everyone in the ecosystem. It's time to put an end to it, and while we're at it the same goes for all the other platform owners. And while we're at it, implement a Georgist tax scheme on landlords.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y ago"stop them from banning apps from their stores that aren't breaking any laws" It's unlikely to happen in the US because one primary weapon of Cancel Culture is going for the financial jugular, by getting people they dislike banned from payment processing platforms, who all hide behind "we are a private entity" BS.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI'm not comfortable having the US government tell Apple what entities they are obligated to do business with.
- iamdbtoo 6y agoHow is it BS for a private company to say they don't want to take money from a group like Stormfront?
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoWell, then don't ask for the EU to legislate that payment processors can't drop customers. You can't have it both ways...
- dpiers 6y agoWhat about video game consoles? Early in a generation, they are sold at razor-thin (or negative) margins, with the expectation that the manufacturer will recoup losses from licensing fees over the life of the console and that costs will come down in later revisions. If manufacturers lose their substantial licensing fees, they would be forced to charge more upfront for the consoles which is objectively worse for consumers.
- manfredo 6y agoConsoles are much, much narrower in use than smartphones. Most consoles have a few thousand titles, if that. By comparison the App Store had millions of applications. And as you point out, manufacturers are building these consoles at a loss. Apple builds it's phones at a profit. Getting a game approved for sale on a console is much more involved than releasing an App on the App Store, and involves significant manual review not just of the quality of the game but also the content.
- itake 6y agoApple does a manual review of the quality of their apps as well as their content (e.g. if you own a social app that allows users to publish images, they will verify there are no adult images being published and there are systems in place for banning these images.)
- ecshafer 6y agoThat doesn't sound like a good thing to me. Why must we be held to some extra moral laws for the ability to allow ios users to use our software?
- GloriousKoji 6y agoEveryone here seems to be obsessed with the fact that a console is a "computer" in the turing machine sense but the fact is that people buy consoles with the strong primary purpose of entertainment. Smart phones and tablets have gotten to the point where they are expected to be able to do hundreds of different things, with some peoples livelihood dependent on it.
- jqpabc123 6y agoIf you're an end user --- don't buy Apple. If you're a developer --- don't build for Apple. Problem solved.
- esarbe 6y agoIn theory; yes. In practice; not quite enough. Apple is doing everything it can to stop the customer from being informed. As a developer, you are not allowed to tell your customers how much of a cut Apple gets. This has to change.
- nichos 6y agoThis is the solution. I'm sorry, but an iPhone is not a human right. If you don't like it or the company practice, don't support it Legislation is not the answer here.
- ncr100 6y ago> Just imagine if Microsoft had taken a 30% cut from every developer who ever compiled software for windows How does this relate to this discussion? Just inserting "30%" into ANY financial transaction and drawing a comparison is a false equivalency. If I could, I would downvote this.
- draw_down 6y ago> digital equivalent of a landlord extracting economic rents from everyone in the ecosystem. Ok, well, it’s not illegal to be a landlord, nor immoral (as most people see it at least). So I’m not sure this is a very good argument. You could even say “they’re as evil as Ticketmaster” and it’s like... yeah well Ticketmaster continues to operate. You don’t have to like them, basically no one does, but they’re playing according to the rules of the game.
- missedthecue 6y agoThere is a benefit. The prevention of side loading limits malware. Windows is ridden with malware.
- segmondy 6y agoI agree with you, the say I have framed is. I say Cisco should charge for every packet that goes through their router that is involved in a Financial transaction. If you don't pay, they add you to a blacklist. It's feasible, router has a blacklist, Cisco checks if you make money, if you do, they shake you down, if you don't pay, they add you to the blacklist and router downloads and refuses to route your IP addresses. Sounds ridiculous, but it's doable. After all they are facilitating the transaction.
- markawesome 6y agoPlease don't give Cisco any ideas as they'll surely be doing this soon enough