4 ms·
IMHO companies need to either embrace WFH fully or not at all. This current "we're kinda mostly WFH but not really sometimes" is the worst, as you have archaic
by ChuckNorris89 6y ago
IMHO companies need to either embrace WFH fully or not at all.
This current "we're kinda mostly WFH but not really sometimes" is the worst, as you have archaic processes still in place from pre WFH days that are still enforced, and most importantly, if management is in the office and you're not, over time, the colleagues who will be in the office will seem to get really lucky in regards to promotions and opportunities for some reason and you'll be left out because you'll miss the coffee/water cooler/cigarette chit-chat where future projects/directions are discussed casually and off the record without you.
Example: I once ran into my boss talking to a colleague at a coffee break about a potential project with a new customer and volunteered to work on it as I liked the tech. Months later, I got it. If I would have been remote that day I would have never heard about it as stuff like new projects and new customers is pretty hush-hush until the ink dries on the contract so they're never written about in public slack channels until then, but then it's usually too late to call dibs as the pieces are already in motion.
Not to mention, you can't really move far away from the office either since you could at any time be expected to show up in the office for $IMPORTANT_MEETING.
- st1x7 6y agoYes - for someone living in a big city half office, half WFH is the worst of everything. It means that I have to maintain an expensive home office, don't get all the benefits of working in an office with other people (which I prefer) and I can't move out of the big city.
- lnsru 6y agoYou’re describing my situation. I have no dedicated room for my home office, just table with my own decent monitor and company’s decent workstation plus some hardware from the office. My place looks ugly with all that equipment, but it’s still better than punching a card daily in the office. Moving to a cheaper area is too good to be true.
- ghaff 6y agoOr you get a coworking space (in normal circumstances) and it's just a cost like commuting is for a lot of people.
- st1x7 6y agoThat sounds like all the downsides of an office with none of the benefits. Plus additional expenses.
- ghaff 6y agoBut you can get a coworking space in a cheaper location if that's where you want to live. (Or get a bigger place with room for an office.) Some people prefer working in a different location than they're living.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThere are winners and losers every time there's large change. Those people slogging out 1.5hr commutes from the outer suburbs are the winners because remote work even with a "you must be in the office 1 day a week" policy makes their land more attractive. The people who mortgaged themselves up to their eyeballs to get in on those good inner suburb commutes and schools are the losers because suddenly outer suburb housing is a more viable alternative to what they own. The people living in illegal 300sf studio departments in people's basements are neither since they weren't all in on any particular side. They can rent somewhere further out and cheaper with space for an office without too much friction. Back in the early 90s a lot of cities were dumps compared to today. The people who bought there and held on for 20-30yr won because a lot of cities gentrified.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI completely disagree, and I am in that situation. I feel like working from home 3-4 days a week, and then in the office 1-2 days a week is the best of everything: 1. I have much more freedom to choose where I live because my commute is much less of an issue if I'm only doing it once or twice a week. 2. I feel like I get the best of all worlds: I get great "focus time" when I'm working from home, but I am still able to have more personal relationships from meeting people in person at the office. 3. Our company I think has done a great job segregating heads-down work time from specific days where we have more meetings or more collaboration.
- dudul 6y agoThe practices/processes need to embrace a "fully remote" model. That doesn't mean you can't have a physical office. I've been part of companies where this works very well. That being said, yes, you usually don't want to be the special remote snowflake in the middle of a strong on-site culture.
- moocowtruck 6y agoI don't feel like it needs to be one or the other, missing out on things doesn't bother me
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoSeems like its conditioned on management always being in the office- something which might decline over time.
- znpy 6y agoYes and no. My current employer and the previous one had more than one branch, geographically located in different areas (and nations). To me all the colleagues from other branches were "remote". As far as I can tell, it made no difference to me if they were in their office or at home, I still interacted with them via tickets, instant messaging, video calls etc. And yet we all worked together.
- ghaff 6y agoI have a feeling a lot of people come at this from the perspective of small companies. In the case of large/global businesses, you may have teams that are largely co-located but you're probably on calls in the course of a given day with people on different continents. One of the main teams I work with, even if everyone were in the offices where they are technically located (or were) that would be two different although relatively nearby offices and another 6 time zones away.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoExactly this. Multinational companies are relaizing that they've already incurred the cost of distributed teams and that since there's really no difference between your manager being in Munich, Germany and Munich, North Dakota they may as well cut costs by allowing the latter case.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoYou missed my point. I didn't say remote doesn't work, I said remote will disadvantage remote employees if not done right.
- drdeadringer 6y agoI have experienced "remote not done right". I routinely felt and was in reality disadvantaged in that situation. I am currently [back into the] same industry during COVID and am splitting time between WFH and the [pretty much] deserted office. I do not feel disadvantaged in this current situation. I can tell you that the manager and the team makes an incredible difference.
- ghaff 6y agoAt the extremes, maybe. If 9 people on a team are in an office and 1 is remote, perhaps a few time zones away, that tends to be a problem. "Oops, we forgot to set up a dial-in AGAIN." But, in general, not really. I work for a company that normally has offices but also has quite a few remote people. And we're a global company anyway so people are going to be in different offices in any case. Even our management is pretty distributed. >Not to mention, you can't really move far away from the office either since you could at any time be expected to show up in the office for $IMPORTANT_MEETING. Again, in normal times, there are planes etc. I work in a broader group that's scattered across the world and we would normally get together for team meetings a couple times a year.
- picodguyo 6y agoAgreed, I worked on a small company where we offered the choice to work from home or come in. Half the company hated coming in and half hated working from home. The end result was low energy in the office and poor bonding across the team. I personally prefer working from home, but I don't think anyone has figured out how to do the remote thing without alienating a portion of the workforce, which is why many companies are hanging on to in-office policies (e.g. Netflix).
- raxxorrax 6y agoI don't think that rents are the motivation behind this and instead I believe they want to get new heads and make work at Microsoft more attractive. I get what you mean with either/or, currently you just don't know who is available on a day to day basis, which can ruin any planning. One the other hand I would like to see mixed models like having 2 WFH days per week where I can work without the usual office distractions. For productivity purposes it would probably be best if those day are synchronized for development work of course.
- ghaff 6y agoIf you still have to come in multiple days per week you now still need to live within a reasonable commuting distance of the office and preferably have a decent home office. Less of an issue if the office is in a suburban office park. More so if it's downtown in a city. If it's one day per week, it's probably more tractable because you can probably put up with a pretty long commute if need be if it's just once a week. So the details matter.
- tinyhouse 6y agoSome good points but I think now things are going better for partially remote companies since most companies shifted their culture to fully remote even if not everyone is remote. Then there's also all the work visas implications. Companies like MS rely heavily on foreign talent and I don't think they can bring them over without an office. The onsite employees would still have an advantage of forming relationships with more people and knowing more what's going on in the company from informal lunch conversations etc. Not everyone can work effectively from home. Having an office you can go to whenever you want is a big plus.
- everdrive 6y ago>the colleagues who will be in the office will seem to get really lucky in regards to promotions and opportunities for some reason and you'll be left out because you'll miss the coffee/water cooler/cigarette chit-chat where future projects/directions are discussed casually and off the record without you The reality is that merit is only one of many reasons that promotions happen. And often not the primary reason.
- calcifer 6y ago> merit is only one of many reasons that promotions happen. And often not the primary reason. Related thread from 10 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24618707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24618707
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoNot sure about other peoples experiences but all the best and smoothest projects of my career were done with groups who had good social cohesion, got on with each other, supported each other and most importantly socialized with each other. There is close to zero opportunity for free creative brainstorming in the workplace and all the true innovation we made came out of discussions outside of work at the pub. Definitely know there's benefits for working at home, especially for the first few years of your kids lives. But career wise if you reduce your presence to a name in a slack sidebar and an occasional face on a videocall, don't be shocked if you're treated like a name in a sidebar because just like any relationships in life presence makes a difference.
- jakupovic 6y agoThe group ideas are only as good as the smartest member. All this chit chat talk is bullshit
- filoleg 6y ago>The group ideas are only as good as the smartest member Even the smartest members tend often to not realize the brilliance of a random idea they have (out of their list of many). A cohesive group of people that you trust and can bounce ideas off of is valuable, both in case of bad and good ideas.
- netcan 6y agoIn a sense, those are the breaks. Companies don't exist to be fair, and fairness isn't built into promotion/advancement necessarily. This might just be another one of those insider edges that you may or may not have. Companies are already full of these.
- awinder 6y agoThere’s 2 real world things that I think would need to happen in order for companies to go all-in: 1. Companies need success stories of that kind of ad-hoc innovation happening from within the company remotely. Otherwise someone will 100% kill it. Somewhat a function of how long until return to normalcy if that’s possible. 2. Another uncontrolled viral outbreak in the next decade changes the math on financial sustainability of the large campus and externally forces companies to go all-in. From what I’ve seen I think companies hedge #2 happening by allowing remote in perpetuity, and it solves gnarly issues with “forcing” people back in. But at this point I don’t think #1 happens with this pandemic.
- screye 6y agoNot really, it works really well in my team. Usually Mondays and Fridays are no-meeting focus days, so they are easiest to wfh on. The "team-building and fun" events are all crammed on the same days when you have meetings for which you'd usually come into the office anyway.