7 ms·
Exactly. The amount of effort put into finding multiple critical - high vulnerabilities of a $1TN+ company and the result is $51k + taxes to possibly share bet
by rvz 6y ago
Exactly.
The amount of effort put into finding multiple critical - high vulnerabilities of a $1TN+ company and the result is $51k + taxes to possibly share between 5 hackers for 4 qualifying bugs for that bounty sounds like Apple took them for a cheap ride through their campus.
Compared to 1 hacker, 1 month, JWT signature check failure = 100k from Apple [0]:
[0] https://bhavukjain.com/blog/2020/05/30/zeroday-signin-with-apple/ https://bhavukjain.com/blog/2020/05/30/zeroday-signin-with-a...
- amenod 6y agoThe 4 exploits they got paid for don't seem like the biggest ones though. I would expect Apple to pay $500k - $1M for this session in the end, and it would be in the best interest of all parties if this happened. Apple would encourage responsible disclosure (and attract more white-hat bug hunters) this way. The amount of vulnerabilities found is a proof by itself that team work does pay off, if the team is strong. Also, this is a drop in the bucket for Apple. It would probably cost them much more to have them on the payroll for the same amount of time.
- appleflaxen 6y ago10 person months would be 10/12ths of a programmer salary i Silicon Valley, which would probably be around $200k
- phonebucket 6y ago> 10 person months would be 10/12ths of a programmer salary i Silicon Valley, which would probably be around $200k To my mind, this team deserves a higher salary than typical Silicon Valley programmers for this work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- appleflaxen 6y agoAgree; these people are incredibly skilled. The conclusion is the same: they are underpaid by a factor of approximately 4+
- ska 6y agoFWIW Typical SV programmers don't make anything like 200k/yr, so they are already above that range even if there aren't more payouts...
- tptacek 6y agoWhere did you come up with that number? $500k is much more than a sitewide external app pentest of comparable scope would cost Apple, by an integer multiple. The bugs here are good, but they're not "bug bounty black swan" good; they're what you'd expect from a sitewide pentest. I agree Apple got a great deal here (that's the point of bounties, and anyone who thinks they're a bad deal for strong researchers is... right). But I'm always going to point out that HN has weird misconceptions about the economics of this stuff.
- saagarjha 6y ago> $500k is much more than a sitewide external app pentest of comparable scope would cost Apple, by an integer multiple. By a team of four experienced security researchers working for multiple months?
- TheRealPomax 6y agoA classic false comparison: the four experienced security researchers working for multiple months covers 55 issues, not "that one issue". If we're cherry picking a single one, the associated involvement and timeframe drops dramatically, to something much closer to one or two people, tops, over the course of just a few days, tops. That's something a pentesting team can absolutely achieve for far less than $500,000 over the course of a few days, too.
- saagarjha 6y agoI’m unsure what your point is? I see dozens of different issues listed in the post, on different endpoints, all of which presumably took time to find. When they said they had a team of multiple people work for months on this, I am unsure why you think they haven’t spent their time as efficiently as “a pentesting team”. Actually, I’ll be stronger: looking through the list of things they discovered, it seems like they were absolutely churning out vulnerabilities for the entire period. A real team would have certainly cost much more than what they’ve currently been paid.
- 6y ago
- Spooky23 6y agoApple paid with public exposure. Anything Apple is a story of interest, which has a value especially in security circles where half the business is a pure PR exercise. I’ve spent time in my career with a “big gorilla” employer whose business is very visible within its community. Companies will “pay” a lot to say “We solved FooCorp’s problems with <x>” or “FooCorp bought our <y>” Lazy buyers assume that their peers have their shit together.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoWhile it's a great marketing and reputation building tool, it's still pretty poor to pay people in exposure; they could have taken each and every one of these exploits to the black market instead and they probably would have earned a lot more money.
- derefr 6y agoAlternatively, the Apriso exploit alone apparently would have allowed them to create fake manufacturing-level employees with fake payroll going to arbitrary bank-account targets; so an unethical attacker probably could have collected an unbounded amount of money just from that (since it likely wouldn’t have been caught until after the first event; and payroll would happen all at once, paying out to as many different accounts as the attacker wished.)
- Spooky23 6y agoYour assuming the security professionals in question have a desire to commit a felony.
- engineer_22 6y agoPR is good but it wont keep the lights on. If you want them to return to work for you, pay them with exchange currency. Apple's motive should be to encourage skilled hackers to come forward with exploits - i.e. make it worth their time. Not drive them into the arms of a competitor.