6 ms·
> And why, when you raise your right hand, does your mirror-self raise its left hand, but it still moves it up rather than down? The words “up” and “down” are
by teddyh 6y ago
> And why, when you raise your right hand, does your mirror-self raise its left hand, but it still moves it up rather than down?
The words “up” and “down” are absolute, but the words “left” and “right” are relative to you. If we instead of “left” and “right” use the words “south arm” and “north arm”, then the mirror suddenly does not “flip” anything. This is a strong clue that the apparent paradox is conceptual, not real.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iforgotpassword 6y agoHmmm. Just made me think that you probably couldn't explain that "paradox" to most 6yo who just about learned to tell left and right apart. In my experience they will consistently get left and right hands of others wrong when facing them, because they always treat those relative to themselves. So the mirror doesn't flip anything to them.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Hmmm. Just made me think that you probably couldn't explain that "paradox" to most 6yo who just about learned to tell left and right apart. A typical 6-year old can say what their left-hand is. But if you tell them to point to MY left hand, they will instead point to my right hand. It takes additional effort and training to teach young children how to see from other people's perspective.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoThis seems reasonable explanation on first glance, but on further thinking it seems to miss something. Assume 'down arm' as leg, and 'up arm' as head, relative to the person who has the arm just like left and right arm. Even then the mirror doesn't flip up and down arm, but only flips left and right.
- hammock 6y agoagreed. As another commenter mentioned, what a mirror does is not flip left-right, but front-back. (notice front-back are still relative terms, so parent comment argument is moot)
- cmroanirgo 6y agoUp and down are relative too, and not absolute. People in the Northern pole vs Southern pole will both point "down" toward the centre of the earth, in opposite (absolute) directions. The concepts of North and South also fail dramatically when close to the poles.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The concepts of North and South also fail dramatically when close to the poles. No they don't. They only fail when on the poles.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- noxer 6y agoThe article is just simply wrong. The mirror "person" also raises the right hand. Its just our brain tricking us into thinking that if we would be in the position the mirrored person appears in (rotated 180 degree), that it would be our left hand but we cant be in a mirrored position ever.
- quietbritishjim 6y agoIndeed, like we physically did with the piece of paper, we have mentally chosen to think of our image in the mirror as like ourself but turned horizontally (around the verticle axis) to face us - ending up flipped left-to-right. If we instead think of our image as like ourselves but turned vertically (around the horizontal axis) - like you lept headfirst into the mirror and landed upright on your head - then you'll find that your left and right sides are the correct way round but the image is vertically flipped. It's very hard to think this way because (a) we're mostly symmetric horizontally, certainly a lot more than vertically, and (b) we very often interact with other people that have turned horizontally (around the verticle axis) to face us but very rarely interact with other people that have turned vertically to face us. Another aspect that makes this hard mentally is that if you have any identifying non-symmetrical features, like birthmarks, then they appear horizontally flipped in the mirror compared to photographs. Again, it's the photograph that's turned incorrectly. This one is particularly hard to sell, because surely a photo with a ground at the top can't be the right way round? The answer is, for the purpose of matching your left and right, the "correct" way round is for the photo to face away from you. Makes logical sense, but very unintuitive.
- undersuit 6y agoYou see the mirror raising your mirrored hand. I see a two identical individuals raising their opposing hands in unison.
- noxer 6y agoYou are tricked by what you see. You assume the other person is a person that looks like you but is rotated towards you, while in reality the other person would need to be a mirrored version of you. Your brain doesn't see that it's mirrored because you are used to see "yourself" this way.
- quietbritishjim 6y ago> The words “up” and “down” are absolute, but the words “left” and “right” are relative to you. I disagree. In this sort of conversation, "up" refers to the direction from your feet to your head, not away from the ground. If you do a handstand and hold your piece of paper up to the mirror then you'll still find it flipped left-to-right but not top-to-bottom if you turn it the instinctive way, and still find it flipped top-to-bottom but not left-to-right if you turn it vertically.
- yeellow 6y agoAnd what if you stand on a mirror?
- quietbritishjim 6y agoI'm not sure if you're joking but that doesn't change what our perception of up and down are.
- yeellow 6y agoI am not joking. When you stand on the mirror the direction from your feet to your head is different than for the guy in the mirror. It shows that the mirror changes only one axe, orthogonal to its surface. It does not rotate anything nor change up/down or left/right. So when I look at the mirror en face only the direction of y axis is changed, x and z is not affected.
- quietbritishjim 6y agoI agree, and that doesn't contradict what I said in my original comment. I think we are just getting tangled in semantics rather than fundamentally disagreeing on anything.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 6y ago
- Retric 6y agoMirrors flip things inside out not left to right. You see your images face not the back of the head. This confuses left to right as you’re referring to port and starboard, assuming your image isn’t inside out.
- noxer 6y agoMirrors don't flip anything. They change direction of photons. Trow a ball on a wall at an angle it bounces of at the same angle there is no flipping. Write a word on a paper with fresh paint then press in on a wall then remove it. The word on the wall is exactly want you pressed on the wall it didn't flip the paint you did when you flipped the paper.
- Retric 6y agoBouncing is flipping direction. A light source moving away from you to a mirror is getting dimmer, but it’s reflection is getting brighter. That’s a measurable physical property that’s reversed. Similarly, a red or blue shifted object between the mirror has a reflection that’s revered in the other direction. However, when looking at an object behind you that doesn’t happen as the reflection shows the same side.
- noxer 6y ago>A light source moving away from you to a mirror is getting dimmer, but it’s reflection is getting brighter. The distance to the light source grows if you move it away toward the mirror it gets dimmer. The the distance of the light in the reflection however gets shorter so it get brighter. If the light is right next to you the distance is zero. The reflected light however traveled 2 times the distance to the mirror (dimmer). If you move the light to the mirror both "lights" are one mirror distance away so they have the same brightness (assuming a perfect mirror). There is no "physical property reversed" at all. You could remove the mirror and measure the light intensity twice the distance away instead. Then move the light to the middle where the mirror was and obviously the sensor would measure and increase while you see a decrees in brightness.
- clairity 6y ago'inverted' might be a slightly better descriptor than 'flipped', but still, my left hand is on the left in the mirror as well, but it's still the mirror person's right hand. and your distinction of 'real' vs 'conceptual' relative to paradoxes doesn't make sense. a paradox is real because it's conceptual, as paradoxes are relative to humans (or more generally, earthly life).
- Someone 6y agoAnd yet, your west nose becomes an east nose.
- nendroid 6y ago>The words “up” and “down” are absolute, but the words “left” and “right” are relative to you. If we instead of “left” and “right” use the words “south arm” and “north arm”, then the mirror suddenly does not “flip” anything. No dude. The mirror flips left and right Relative to you. The mirror ignores up and down relative to you. The paradox is real when thought of in these terms. Truth be told the flip is neither left or right nor up and down. actually It is actually inside out on the z axis: towards you. Translational coordinates along the xy plane must be preserved and this is what causes the perceived left right flip. The actuality is nothing was flipped along x or y, it was kept the same. That's what trips everyone up.
- jstanley 6y agoThe mirror doesn't flip anything at all. As humans we normally keep our feet on the floor and turn around by rotating around the vertical axis, thus when we face another human they've normally rotated around the vertical axis relative to us. We're just not used to seeing the fronts of humans who have not rotated relative to us, so the mirror appears to have flipped the image horizontally. If we customarily rotated around a horizontal axis, i.e. every time you look "behind" you're upside down (note this won't actually work very well given that you'd normally want to rotate around the axis perpendicular to the surface of the Earth, but just for sake of argument...), then we might believe that the mirror has flipped things vertically. It still hasn't actually flipped anything, it's just that we are viewing the front of a person who has not rotated.
- lordnacho 6y agoFussball players do the horizontal flip. You're still right of course.
- jstanley 6y agoHa, perfect example, I'll use that in future! A table football player looking at himself in the mirror would wonder why he was upside down.
- rixed 6y agoExactly. And it is even easier to convince oneself that that's actually what is going on if instead of trying to explain why the mirror "flips" the image of a person, one try to explain why the mirror "flips" a written word. Take a piece of paper, write a word onto it, and turn it towards the mirror. Now observe the word. Is it flipped left to right? If so, it's because when turning it towards the mirror _you_ turned it around the vertical axis. Do this again, this time rotating the paper around the horizontal axis and voilà, the word is now flipped upside down. IIRC that's Feynman who have written somewhere that mirrors do not flip things right to left, nor top to bottom. They flip things front to back.
- unkulunkulu 6y ago
- hjntmp 6y agoWhat about letters?
- RichardCA 6y agoYou mean like, why do the people who paint markings onto an ambulance have to do it reversed? Yeah that's a good question. If I'm sitting in my car and looking at an ambulance in the rear-view mirror, it's not the mirror itself that reverses the lettering, and that's the key thing to understand. The only thing the mirror is doing is reversing the Z-axis. So the question becomes, why does a Z-axis reversal cause me to perceive that the X-axis is getting reversed? If I turn around to look at the ambulance, I just took my head through a 180 degree rotation around the Y-axis. Then (and only then) does the image get reversed on the X-axis. If you could imagine being behind the ambulance, and it were made of some imaginary transparent material, you would still see the lettering as not reversed. The key is to be precise when you use words to describe an optical phenomenon. A mirror reflects, and that's all it does.