6 ms·
That would raise a ton of questions. Most of the deals Facebook did to buy WhatsApp, Instagram and others where approved by the US government. But if those app
by mrweasel 6y ago
That would raise a ton of questions. Most of the deals Facebook did to buy WhatsApp, Instagram and others where approved by the US government. But if those approvals can be reversed, why bother requiring them to begin with?
Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business, those two product can’t turn a profit on their own, as proven by Mozilla. Would the lawmakers force a creation of companies who are doomed to fail?
Lawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. Many of the issues we face with big tech is because lawmakers are to inept at seeing the long term consequences of the deals they themselfs approved.
- sn41 6y agoI don't think this argument is entirely justified. There is a "sandpile" effect as more acquisitions come about, plus the merging of profiles in the context of social media platforms. The net effect is definitely more than the sum of the parts, so the monopoly effect is much more than the sum of the individual parts' market shares. Moreover, pointing out to earlier oversights cannot be a justification for an absence of oversight now.
- tobr 6y ago> Moreover, pointing out to earlier oversights cannot be a justification for an absence of oversight now. Got confused trying to parse this, then realized you are probably using the word “oversight” in two diametrically different ways in this sentence.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago"Oversight" is its own antonym! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-antonym https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-antonym
- wobblyasp 6y ago> Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business Maybe, maybe not. Loss leaders are definitely a thing. Nothing forces them to be "doomed to fail" however. > those two product can’t turn a profit on their own, as proven by Mozilla Proven? Mozilla failed, sure. That does not mean its a foregone conclusion.
- beiller 6y agoActually your comment brings an idea into my head. What if loss leaders could be a great probe into whether or not the behavior is anti-competitive. I know loss leaders exist, but how do they exist in a positive aspect? They seem to purely exist in order to siphon off capital from one business arm in order to extinguish competition in the loss-leader's sector. It seems to be it gets at the crux if this issue.
- salawat 6y agoDing ding ding, we have a winner. At least until you realize most bars utilize the same mechanism. It needs to be more of a combination of a high degree of departure from one's primary industrial/service vertical as well to really work as a canary though.
- dannyw 6y agoLoss leaders are fine when they’re the same business. Like McDonalds offering a loss leading burger or drink; or even a cinema offering a slightly loss leading ticket to make up on concessions.
- numpad0 6y agoThe act of using loss leaders to destruct a market, beyond growing a business, is called “dumping”. It’s a very old tactic, some regulations do exist against it...
- vimax 6y agoTo add to it not being a forgone conclusion: One anti-trust argument is that Mozilla couldn't succeed against Chrome due to Google's use of a monopoly position in Android and search results. The beta version of Firefox was released in 2002, the same year that the final ruling came down on the Microsoft anti-trust case. The first release of Firefox was 2004, and it quickly beat out IE, and was the market leader until Chrome overtook it. It is hard to say what would happen if Chrome were not the default browser on Android, and Chrome ranking above Firefox in search results and Google Play.
- ffpip 6y agoAndroid can be profitable. All the ripoffs like OneUI and MIUI have a shitload of ads. So charge them a small amount per device. Chrome will have default search engine as Google. It is already profitable.
- inetknght 6y ago> Lawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. What you're saying locks people into thinking that minds can never be changed with new information. That's wrong on so many levels.
- whimsicalism 6y agoI've found that posts related to anti-trust enforcement of big tech on here generally have these sort of sloppily-reasoned comments at the top. The reality of "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it" hits home in pretty much every discussion I have on anti-trust.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoWe know from the Oracle lawsuit that Android is a multi-billion dollar business. Android may be open source but Google Play Services is not, so that's a few dollars of revenue for every phone sold. In addition, Google Play app store revenue for 2019 was $21.9 billion, and Google takes a 30% cut on most of that.
- treis 6y agoAndroid is probably more profitable outside Google than in it. Apple gets something like 7 billion a year just for Google being the default search engine on their devices. Add in stuff like maps, hangout/meet, youtube etc. and that number goes up.
- aikinai 6y agoWhich they also want to make illegal.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoAh but if Android was a separate company from Google, and Palm and Blackberry were in the field too, with separate app stores and revenue split between them, what would the landscape look like?
- zepto 6y agoPalm and Blackberry failed before Android succeeded.
- mywittyname 6y ago> Lawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. Many of the issues we face with big tech is because lawmakers are to inept at seeing the long term consequences of the deals they themselfs approved. A) The pool of lawmakers is in constant flux. B) Most lawmakers are bribed by the very companies that they seek to regulate. C) Companies lie all the time in their filings, and the moment they have the flimsiest of justifications, turn around and do the exact thing they promised not to D) People who make a bad decisions in the past should be encouraged to fix it.
- tristor 6y ago> A) The pool of lawmakers is in constant flux. Unfortunately due to the absence of any meaningful term limits, this is not the case. People who make it into Congress and play ball with establishment elites tend to stay there for their entire remaining lifespan. > C) Companies lie all the time in their filings, and the moment they have the flimsiest of justifications, turn around and do the exact thing they promised not to Yes, because they get away with it. Perhaps if the incentive structure were different we'd see different results.
- mywittyname 6y ago97 of 535 Congresspeople are in their first term this session. That's a healthy amount of turnover every few years. The average term in Congress is for people serving after 1950 is 12 years, so two terms. Yeah, some Congresspeople operate in "safe" districts and never see a challenger, but those are rare (and valuable). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_freshman_class_members_of_the_116th_United_States_Congress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_freshman_class_members...
- thehappypm 6y ago12 years is 2 terms for the Senate but for the majority of Congress, it's 6 terms.
- tssva 6y agoThe FTC and DoJ approve mergers and acquisitions not lawmakers.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business, those two product can’t turn a profit on their own, as proven by Mozilla. Microsoft and Apple have shown that licensing an OS and selling cell phones can both be lucrative. Google's Android business does both of these things; if it were spun out on its own, why would it be doomed to fail?
- dodobirdlord 6y agoI don’t think there’s all that much more money to be pulled out of Android, since (a) it’s available under a very permissive license and (b) it’s used all over the world by people who don’t have much more money to spend on their phone. Google already barely has influence over the OEM’s that choose to use it, case in point their recent spat with Samsung over the fact that Samsung keeps patching the kernel in ways that introduce security vulnerabilities. Samsung hasn’t stopped, Google has just started publishing the vulnerabilities to shame Samsung into maybe doing something about it. Is this a scenario where it looks like Google is leaving money on the table? And if this is all the money available from Android that spells bad news for an independent company, since we know from the Google v Oracle filings that Android has made Google something like $10B total over all the years it’s been operating. Android might break even, but I assume it’s operating at a loss so that Google can benefit in a bunch of less direct ways from the fact that it exists.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> [...] we know from the Google v Oracle filings that Android has made Google something like $10B total over all the years it’s been operating. Over the last year and a half, Google has made over $46b in app revenue ($29.3b 2019 [1] and $17.3b H1 2020 [2]) which at a 30% cut is around $14b. That's just apps on Google Play — not counting other forms of media, Pixel sales, Android licenses (they can always re-license if it's too permissive), etc. Do you have a source for that $10b figure? I imagine some specific part related to the suit has made much over its lifetime. It seems like Google's Android business as a whole has made much more. [1] https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-2019 https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-2019 [2] https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-1h-2020 https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-1h-20...
- protomyth 6y agoLawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. The Lawmakers in question are not involved in the actual approval process. They create the rules, but sadly don't do the full rule making[1] nor do they administer the rules. So, this is their check on what the executive branch has done. 1) its amazing how many laws are passed with the actual rules determined by departments in the executive branch. That's why it is so important to look at the announcements in the federal register.
- bgilroy26 6y ago8-9 years ago there was a small movement to popularize Federal Register highlights on reddit. I hope it works someday. If there were a Federal Register fact of the day TikTokker, I would follow them
- tw04 6y ago>Most of the deals Facebook did to buy WhatsApp, Instagram and others where approved by the US government. But if those approvals can be reversed, why bother requiring them to begin with? Most of those deals had pre-conditions and promises by Facebook. Facebook has ignored most of the obligations with basically a "what are you going to do about it" attitude. For instance: >The FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, in a letter to the two companies on Thursday, said WhatsApp must adhere to its current privacy practices after the merger, including a promise not to use WhatsApp users’ personal data for targeted ads. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-whatsapp/facebook-says-whatsapp-deal-cleared-by-ftc-idUSBREA391VA20140410 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-whatsapp/faceboo... So they directly ignore that requirement and try to claim "well it's in the T&C!" which they KNOW users don't read. And even if they did, end-users accepting a T&C doesn't give you some magical power to ignore a government mandate. https://techcrunch.com/2016/08/25/whatsapp-to-share-user-data-with-facebook-for-ad-targeting-heres-how-to-opt-out/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/08/25/whatsapp-to-share-user-dat...
- senko 6y ago> Most of the deals Facebook did to buy WhatsApp, Instagram and others where approved by the US government. Facebook promised at the time that Instagram and WhatsApp would operate independently, which probably played a part in the govt. decision. That promise has been broken. Seems fair that the approval might be reconsidered in light of this.
- switch11 6y agothey also promised to not share data between services which is also broken
- Balgair 6y agoI think the change is coming because Zuck couldn't make his end of the bargain with Congress. It's a boilerplate deal. We've seen it with railroads, telecoms, sugar, cigarettes, etc. The industry gets a little too rowdy for the good of the country and other businesses. Congress gets them to testify for a few hours and makes sure that they tell a lie somewhere in that timeframe. Now, Congress has leverage on the industry. In return, the industry gets to write the laws surrounding themselves. They become, effectively, a poly/monopoly. Sure, the big gains are gone, but so are the losses. Your industry, yourself, and all your relatives and descendants will never be poor again. You make a tidy 3% profit for eternity. Congress gave Zuck that deal. Clean up social media; this Russia/flat-earth/vaccine stuff has got to stop. But Zuck can't do it. The ML/AI approach gets you to 99.9%. But to actually clean up the mess and get all the plebs to take their vitamins again takes 99.999% (or something like this). You need real people monitoring the site, like China's 50-cent army. But those people cost way too much to make FB profitable. It's the same for all the social media sites. They don't have a business if it's a clean one. It took a while (hey, it's Congress), but the folks on Capital Hill finally got the message that Zuck can't do it. But, look, it just has to be clean. The mess is affecting other businesses now. Those 5G towers are expensive and took a lot of investment, we can't have people just hacksawing them. So we're going to see the congresscritters start to find ways to get the job done. One way, per this article, is to split them up. Take all the Facial-Feature-books (NoseBooks? EarBooks? EyeBooks?) and clean them up or let them fail outright. I'm sure we'll see negotiations with Zuck in the near future. But the end objective, powered by the hulking slow weight of congressional subpoenas, is the same: no more messes.
- meroes 6y agoThis works for FB but how about Google, Apple, and Amazon? FB's messes go beyond market domination as you point out. But for the others, where and when did they cross the line?
- soperj 6y ago>as proven by Mozilla Because Mozilla hasn't existed as a company for 20 years? The fact that they still exist despite multiple companies massively subsidizing their products for market share means nothing apparently.
- thethethethe 6y ago90% of mozillas revenue comes from Google paying to be the default search engine. Seems more like a subsidy than a successful business model Disclosure: I work for GOOG
- srtjstjsj 6y agoPaying money for a valuable service is commerce, not subsidy. Half of Google's revenue is paying people for traffic from AdSense to browser search bars and all in between. Is my business nonviable just because it's funded by Google ad placements?
- thethethethe 6y agoThere is a pretty big difference between Google directly paying you to exist using money it makes from ads in a different product segment and making money for displaying ads through Google.
- bzbarsky 6y agoDo you know how the payment amount is determined? I don't, but other such things are often structured as revenue share agreements, in which case it would not be exactly "ads in a different product segment", but rather "a fraction of the ad revenue directly attributable to Firefox". At which point it's really no different from how AdWords or the like work.
- yyyk 6y agoIn theory you are correct. However, I wonder how much of Google paying is actually 'we better have a competitor to avoid anti-trust' rather than paying for the searchbar. Mozilla should have gotten a smaller amount last time due to falling behind in marketshare, yet that did not happen.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIf Chrome could not exist, Google would likely pay Mozilla even more to fund Firefox and get Search traffic (or pay MS for IE or some thing). Sure, it'd still be supported by the ads business, but that doesn't mean it isn't a profitable enterprise.
- adrianmonk 6y ago> Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business, those two product can’t turn a profit on their own The Google Play store has multiple billions of dollars of revenue. Revenue which comes from consumer spending, not ads. An article from SensorTower (https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-1h-2020 https://sensortower.com/blog/app-revenue-and-downloads-1h-20...) says that in the first half of 2020, people spent $17.3 billion through Google Play. Assuming Google gets a 30% cut of all of that, it would be $5.2 billion of revenue for half a year, so annualized that'd be over $10 billion/year. Perhaps Google doesn't get a 30% cut of absolutely every transaction (different rules could apply to books, music, TV, and movies), but it gives you a ballpark number. The Play store and the Android OS aren't the same thing, of course, but creating Android obviously helped put Google in the position to get that Play revenue. And if it were to stop developing Android, that would probably hurt Play revenue.
- gumby 6y agoDo they spend more than $5B on android though? I don't know, though I wouldn’t be especially surprised. Edit: I made a typo and left out “wouldn’t” which reverses the sense of my comment.
- dannyw 6y agoIf they do, then it’s uncompetitive and it deserves to be broken up. We may not be in a mobile OS duopoly if Google wasn’t allowed to dump infinite amounts of money into a loss leading product.
- sgc 6y agoIn that case every device should allow users to trivially change their OS, or hardware manufacturers who make operating systems could be accused of the same thing. Many companies make products that don't make money but help promote and sell their products that do. My point is that os/app store metrics are too narrow rather than approval, because I am far from in love with the business model of any of the companies targeted by this report. Although I think the right move would be more consumer-friendly regulation rather than break ups.
- dmos62 6y ago> Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business, those two product can’t turn a profit on their own That's a good point. If we took these products to be public infrastructure, like roads, would we consider them being owned by ad companies a good idea? I'm leaning towards maintainence schemes for these public infrastructure projects similar to what we have for physical public infrastructure, like roads, rail, bridges, etc. Them being international would be an interesting challenge of course, but I think it's solvable.
- dannyw 6y agoI don’t want my government making a web browser, but I do want it to keep a competitive market for web browsers.
- dmos62 6y agoMaking and financing open-source isn't the same thing. If you want privately funded browsers, they will be either subscription based or ad-oriented. Neither is good. Healthy competition is also hardly possible because of how bloated Web is. It's so expensive to maintain that we only have ~3-5 well maintained browsers.
- bogwog 6y ago> Google only develop Android and Chrome to fuel their ad business, those two product can’t turn a profit on their own That's doubtful. > as proven by Mozilla Mozilla? You mean that one terrible company that only exists due to Google's pity? Or rather, Google's strategic philanthropy so that they can show regulators that they aren't a monopoly because Firefox exists. The reason we don't see other competitors in the space is because Google's (and Apple's on iOS) monopoly makes it extremely difficult to compete. I could totally see myself paying for a high quality, privacy-focused, cross-platform, ad-blocker-friendly web browser. I wouldn't pay Mozilla, I wouldn't pay Google, and I wouldn't pay Microsoft, Amazon, or Apple. But I would pay a small software company who isn't trying to exploit me at every turn in the pursuit of unsustainable growth (or LARPing in Mozilla's case). Maybe not everyone would agree with me, but I'm sure a lot of people would. Maybe enough to build a sustainable business. I feel like people are forgetting that a company doesn't need to be a Google-scale behemoth or monopoly in order to be successful and sustainable.
- john_moscow 6y ago>Would the lawmakers force a creation of companies who are doomed to fail? Strongly disagree. The current market structure with free browsers forces the users to pay for a browser with their private data, having little control over it. If the antitrust laws instead forced the users to pay for the browser directly, they would be in much better control, leading to increased competition and better products.
- mav3rick 6y agoNot everyone can afford to pay for a browser. Get off your privileged horse and stop imposing your privacy argument on everyone. A mother in the bronx fighting for survival is not going to pay for a browser. The free browser is a godsend.
- aspaceman 6y agoYou don't need to be on a privileged horse to make both the privacy argument and the welfare argument. You don't have to argue against them. There's options for public funding of such things. I know that's nowhere near where our political mindset is, but you could require a browser to be paid, but have government programs and subsidies that make the browsing free for most people. Then all the incentives are properly accounted for.
- mav3rick 6y agoThis will take 50 years to pass and countless kids will again be at a disadvantage while searching the Internet.
- john_moscow 6y agoThis is tricky. She is still paying for it because when she buys a box of cereal from the store, X% of the price goes to the ad budget, Y% of which goes to Google, and Z% of that goes to the Chrome developers. She also pays by getting a lower wage, because if most of the people had to pay $1/month for a browser, the salary cutoff point, beyond which people would simply not want to work, would be $1 higher. And then through supply/demand, it would slightly raise the average salaries. And, BTW, she would have one more opportunity to save money by not paying for a browser, and instead reading from a library computer. Or maybe using a cheaper volunteer-maintained Linux-like browser. The thing is, money is just a token of passing value between people. If Alice is developing the browser and Bob is using it, there will be a mechanism to pass value from Bob to Alice to compensate for it. It can be either straight-forward (putting Bob in control) or centralized (through some social program, or ad revenue or whatever), but there will be one. Otherwise, Alice would spend her day playing ping-pong with friends, or cycling, or whatever people do when they don't have to work. BTW, I do think that many social problems we are recently facing come from the fact that people are getting more disconnected from consciously producing value. If the abstract mother in Bronx had a clear path to making more money by opening a business and selling something to others, she would take that chance. And she would happily grow as a person and respect others who went the same path, regardless of their skin color. Except how many % of your monthly budget have you spent on owner-operated businesses vs. sector monopolies that treat people like drones and de-facto discourage professional growth to keep people more replaceable? That might also answer the question why the median salary in most areas barely covers rent, while the stock market is record high. Except instead of asking those questions and finding a way for people to contribute value in each others' lives without middlemen, we are turning tribal and trying to blame races, genders and political affiliations for a problem that truly affects us all.
- MR4D 6y ago> Would the lawmakers force a creation of companies who are doomed to fail? I would think that Gmail, YouTube, and Search would be three profitable companies. But you can never underestimate the government’s stupidity.
- throwaway_kufu 6y ago> But if those approvals can be reversed, why bother requiring them to begin with? certainly not to provide a guarantee of unknown economic markets in perpetuity. As much as you would like to hold law makers accountable for not seeing into the future, It’s ridiculous to think law makers approving mergers lead to anti-trust violations. Big tech companies are culpable because they unfairly use their market position to stifle competition to the detriment of consumers. Anti-trust is not purely about market size and dominance, it’s about the disgustingly gross behavior of the people in those companies with that type of power and influence.
- rleigh 6y agoMozilla is an interesting case, but I don't think it's representative of the wider ecosystem because it's unique. It's a corporation which isn't selling its products, and it's also a nonprofit which doesn't use its donations to finance its product development. And its main income source is Google advertising money. While I have some fondness for Mozilla, it's on a path to failure in the long term. It's trying to be both a corporation and an open source project and it's failing at both. I don't think the Google funding has been at all healthy for it. There is a demand for mobile operating systems and web browsers. While it is currently funded through advertising and other means, if this method of funding was ended, the demand would not vanish. The market would adjust to support that demand. After all, we did historically pay for operating systems and applications. Entire corporations' fortunes were made from software sales. In many ways, I would prefer a return to this model. It's simpler and it's honest. I very much prefer to be a valued paying customer rather than a product, with all of the privacy and other problems which result. It also results in a better product since the companies' incentives are more aligned with the paying end user. Absolutely agreed about the lawmakers being more careful. Looking back at the Microsoft antitrust trial, that seems small beans compared with what big tech is up to today. And even then, I personally think that a broken up Microsoft would have been better for both the company and the wider world. And I think that applies tenfold to the tech behemoths we have allowed to accrete today.
- nobody9999 6y ago>Lawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. Many of the issues we face with big tech is because lawmakers are to inept at seeing the long term consequences of the deals they themselfs approved. Lawmakers (in the US, the House of Representatives and Senate) have no role in approving or disapproving specific transactions. In case you aren't American and are unaware, unlike many (but not all) nations, sitting legislators (lawmakers) may not serve in both the Legislative and Executive Branches at the same time. As such, since it's the Executive Branch that executes and enforces the laws passed by the Legislative Branch, lawmakers have no say as to how the law is executed/enforced -- except by changing/repealing/passing laws. Instead, the Executive Branch, in these cases, the Federal Trade Commission[0], the Department of Justice[1] and perhaps other regulatory agencies (such as the FCC[2], FDA[3], etc.) that have a particular industry under their purview make such decisions. [0] https://www.ftc.gov/ https://www.ftc.gov/ [1] https://www.justice.gov/ https://www.justice.gov/ [2] https://www.fcc.gov/ https://www.fcc.gov/ [3] https://www.fda.gov/ https://www.fda.gov/
- sgift 6y agoConditional approvals are only valid as long as the conditions are held. It's the same as using open source software: You are bound by the license and if you break the license you loose the permission to use the software and maybe even have to pay a fine to the copyright holders. Facebook willfully broke the conditions set for the merger, so now its time to reverse said mergers and if this means Facebook has to bleed then that's the price they pay for breaking the rules.
- csharptwdec19 6y agoCan... Can we go do the same to Comcast? They fail to fulfill merger promises time and again.
- appleflaxen 6y agoYour point about more care during the merger is very true. However, just because antitrust regulators think it will be ok doesn't mean they can't change their mind. If it did, then breaking up monopolies would be impossible. Consistency in the law is critical (current US administration demonstrates this), but the economy is dynamic, and consistent principles ("no monopolies") are completely fine, and may give different results when applied to the same entities at different times.
- cannabis_sam 6y ago> Lawmakers should have been more careful about which mergers and purchases they approved. Many of the issues we face with big tech is because lawmakers are to inept at seeing the long term consequences of the deals they themselfs approved. It’s hard to see how that would happen after Robert Bork (and SCOTUS) reduced the criteria for antitrust enforcement to ”it causes higher prices for the consumer” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox