7 ms·
I think that the key point that should be addressed by those against this bill and these laws in general is: How to conduct legitimate law enforcement business
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
I think that the key point that should be addressed by those against this bill and these laws in general is: How to conduct legitimate law enforcement business and police investigations at a time when most communications have moved online?
The reason the Attorney General and the DOJ want some sort of access to communications is not to undermine free speech and to take over the world, it is because they know that without legal provisions technology can make it impossible to access communication during legitimate police investigations.
How do we solve this problem?
- choward 6y ago> they know that without legal provisions technology can make it impossible to access communication during legitimate police investigations > How do we solve this problem? It's called a search warrant.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoWell, no. That's the issue! If you only have peer-to-peer encryption with communications still passing through servers unencrypted then, sure, you can get a warrant to force disclosure. With end to end encryption, however you can show up with a warrant all you want it makes no difference because they physically cannot hand you clear-text communications. Same for encryption at rest. The strength of the encryption algorithms we have today makes it near impossible to recover the clear-text data.
- monocasa 6y agoA search warrant for the endpoints.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAnd I will refuse to cooperate because I know what my "endpoint" contains, because of course my device is also encrypted and/or will be destroyed if I think I'm about to get caught. Your script kiddie might break at the suggestion that refusing to cooperate means 2 to 5 years in jail but organised crime, or people who are risking a much harsher penalty, won't. These are the real, down to Earth issues, not utopian discussions about individual liberties.
- choward 6y agoBecause criminals will follow the encryption laws? If they're not going to comply with a search warrant why would they stop using encryption? The logic makes no sense. The only people this law will affect are law abiding citizens. I'm not willing to give up my privacy just because other people are committing crime and the cops can't figure how to do their job. I'm in the US and the 4th amendment says I don't have to.
- Jon_Lowtek 6y agoGiving the government the option to show up at your door with some random garbage data and asking you to make an impossible proof of innocence or go to jail has some very obvious problems.
- t-writescode 6y agoA very real problem with "backdoors" and wiretapping in the digital age is that, in the past, wiretapping was for future communications and between two specific individuals. That is not how E2E encryption breaking will be used. For E2E encryption breaking, they won't ask for "future conversations between A and B for the next 2 weeks" they will say "give me all historical communication from this person between all of their followers for the last 5 years". For the first time in the history of the world, were are in a time when, not just your future communications, but your past ones, the ones that you think are private between two people in a modern-world way (that is, over the internet) are not private except when E2E. Worse, by all accounts from a normal person - they are private. I mean, we certainly act like the messages we send family iMessage or whatever are private, and we assume the same level of privacy we'd be afforded for a phone call, except that's not present; and, with laws like this, it will be even less present. And not only is the former bad, but the latter is much, much worse.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoSMS texts and call logs are already accessible, for example. Letters kept have always been accessible. The fact that they may be accessed by law enforcement agencies in specific circumstances does not mean that they are not private. If you are seeking absolute privacy for all time, i.e. absolute secrecy, the only option now and since writing was invented is to leave no trace: either communicate face to face discreetly or hand deliver letters and destroy them after reading. What has changed recently is that we are effectively communicating in writing for virtually everything (even a voice call is affectively "in writing" as it's data stored on a medium) and that the cost of storing those writings has dropped to zero. In addition, and that's the issue, encryption has reached a stage where what I suggested (to hand deliver letters and to destroy them after reading) has become 'easy' and cheap for all communications if you want to, which creates big problems for law enforcement and security agencies. I think this is a legitimate issue. The level of the debate, for example in this thread, is low and not helpful because, at least in some tech circles, people refuse to acknowledge real world issues and there is an extreme and utopian view than anything less than absolute secrecy is absolutely unacceptable.
- 6y ago
- choward 6y ago> With end to end encryption, however you can show up with a warrant all you want it makes no difference because they physically cannot hand you clear-text communications. Well, no. That's the issue! They shouldn't be executing search warrant behind your back to some their party that happens to be stirring your data. They should execute the search warrant on the person who owns the data they're investigating. If they refuse to give up the data they're breaking the law. > Same for encryption at rest. The strength of the encryption algorithms we have today makes it near impossible to recover the clear-text data. Same for encryption at rest. We already have laws for that. Get a search warrant. If they refuse to give the data you have a warrant for they broke the law. For example, if you have something in a safe the cops won't just come into your house and crack your safe. They'll get a warrant first then in theory you'll open it for them or they'll have to crack it if you break the law and don't open it.
- nybble41 6y ago> If they refuse to give the data you have a warrant for they broke the law. Warrants aren't issued for data, they're issued for property. A warrant authorizes law enforcement to search for and/or seize evidence (i.e. physical property) without regard for the owner's property rights. The owner doesn't have to give them anything or aid the search in any way beyond simply not interfering. Standing back and leaving them to break into the safe on their own does not violate any law. You might open it anyway just to show goodwill and avoid damage to the safe, but there is no obligation to do so, and unnecessarily demonstrating that you have the ability to open the safe may, in certain situations, amount to testifying against yourself.
- selfhoster11 6y ago> How to conduct legitimate law enforcement business and police investigations at a time when most communications have moved online? The old-fashioned way: physical surveillance for the cases where they strongly suspect a crime. It's even easier these days with the new surveillance capability.
- Jon_Lowtek 6y agoHow was it solved before modern communication tech made it possible to automatically record, transcribe and search peoples private communication?
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe key problem is not automation, it's access. It's simple to read a letter. It's not difficult to eavesdrop on a phone copper wire. But it's impossible to intercept communications encrypted end-to-end, or encrypted at rest, considering the strength of the algorithms freely available today.
- choward 6y ago> The key problem is not automation, it's access. I agree. There is a problem if they have open access to everyone's data. > But it's impossible to intercept communications encrypted end-to-end, or encrypted at rest, considering the strength of the algorithms freely available today. What about to people talking to each other in private. That could be considered as "problematic" as end to end encryption. Should their phones be recording them so the government can snoop later? And for encryption at rest, what if someone has a safe that self destructs is someone unauthorized tries to open it? Should that be illegal?
- tpxl 6y agoIt's difficult to read every single letter. It's difficult to eavesdrop on every single copper wire. It's easy to store every bit of internet communication. Almost nobody here has a problem with warranted access, but this isn't about warranted access, this is about blanket recording of every user's interaction for no good reason.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWe currently are in the middle of prosecuting a whistleblower that made clear that intelligence agencies maliciously abused this kind of access without any indication that this access providing a boon for security aside from perhaps letting some people interested in control sleep at night.
- 6y ago
- Aozi 6y ago>How do we solve this problem? We don't, we accept that encryption is part of the modern world and learn to live with it. Because there's nothing else you can do about it. See encryption is just math, and you can't really outlaw or limit how math is used. If we have bad actors who want to encrypt their communication, they absolutely can with or without this bill. Even if Whatsapp/Telegram/Whatever has to provide the US government with a backdoor to decrypt all messages, anyone can make their own communication platform and simply not give the government a back door. Implementing secure encryption isn't difficult and it's very easy to research how to accomplish it. Grab a few devs and they can create a simple encrypted messaging app in a few days. You don't even need to distribute it through official channels. Android allows you to sideload apps from anywhere and you can jailbreak iPhones to install apps from anywhere. So our bad actors can create secure encrypted communication platforms and distribute them without anyone ever knowing about it. How will this bill prevent that? How will it prevent a few random developers from whipping up their own apps? How will it make it impossible for anyone, anywhere at any time to implement encryption into any app or platform?
- mr__y 6y ago> anyone can make their own communication platform and then the users of that platform would simply stand out in ISP logs making it actually easier to spot them. If this platform was a dedicated tool developed by/for a bad actor, then everyone working with/for that actor would be easily found. Given that, it seems that steganography (combined with encryption) could be a solution with a "battle" between steganographic methods and algorithms to detect them
- Aozi 6y ago>and then the users of that platform would simply stand out in ISP logs making it actually easier to spot them. Yeah no. Encrypted data would still be flowing all over the place, if our bad actors use VPN's to hide their traffic then it would become impossible for ISP's to see what they're doing or using. In addition, even if you can pinpoint who's using encrypted communications, unless you can prove they're actually engaged in some criminal practice, it won't do you much good. With EARN-IT the responsibility is on the encryption providers, so those two random devs who made the app. You can't tell what the users were talking about since communication is encrypted, you can't really prosecute any of the users for anything besides maybe using those apps if it becomes completely illegal or you can prove that the app is only used by criminals and no one else. Now you can potentially go after the devs, assuming of course you can figure out who made the app, and assuming these people are in a place where US laws apply. The global nature of the Internet makes things very difficult. If a Swedish team develops and encrypted communication app and distributes it on their website, are they still required to comply with US laws? If they prevent US citizens from downloading the app with geoblocking but people get around it with VPN's, are they still required to comply with US laws?
- mulmen 6y agoWe don’t because it isn’t a problem. It really is that simple. The cops can do their jobs in meatspace.
- NateEag 6y agoThey used to be able to record phone calls with a warrant. They used to be able to read letters with a warrant, IIUC. With E2E encryption now widely available, no sane criminal will use any non-encrypted channel. So, a lot of methods law enforcement used to find very helpful effectively no longer exist. The steelman principle says that this is what you need to argue isn't a problem. Disclaimer: I lean towards the EFF's position on this one, but I can see there are some debatable issues here.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> So, a lot of methods law enforcement used to find very helpful effectively no longer exist. Exactly, this is a big practical problem and what these laws try to address (in a good or bad way...). IMHO, this is a legitimate worry and opponents should indeed come up with practical alternative solutions. I think the EFF and others do not take a pragmatic approach but rather camp on ideological positions that will get them nowhere.
- danaris 6y agoPerhaps what we need to be doing is not finding new and creative ways for law enforcement to read people's correspondence, but finding new and creative ways to eliminate the underlying factors that cause people to turn to crime in the first place.
- dane-pgp 6y agoBut if the government stopped the factors that lead to crime, then how could it justify its massive spending on a surveillance and selective enforcement regime that it can use against its political enemies (e.g. voters in the wrong demographics)?
- mulmen 6y ago
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt isn't a problem - it is a solution. The answer to the question is "Go after the crimes in the real world you disingenuous lazy assholes!". If they said that they couldn't stop mobsters because they whispered to each other and talked in euphemisms they would be rightfully be thrown out on their ass as a worthless incompetents.