5 ms·
> It’s a valid concern that your car manufacturer will use the interior cameras to blame a crime on you. Don't see when they would ever be responsible for a cr
by judge2020 6y ago
> It’s a valid concern that your car manufacturer will use the interior cameras to blame a crime on you.
Don't see when they would ever be responsible for a crime legally, outside of being 'blamed' in dozens of national news headlines; the current legal landscape has continued to uphold that you are responsible for the car even when it's trying to drive itself.
Even with Navigate on Autopilot, you have to continuously apply force to the wheel to prevent it from nagging at the driver. The feature mentioned in the article would be used if regulation increased to require the car use a camera/similar system to determine if a driver is inattentive while autopilot is enabled.
- BoorishBears 6y agoWhen the creator of your car makes comments like "Your hands are just there for regulatory reasons" Then turns around and blames you for acting like that's true when a known defect kills your wife (aside: Why do you think Mobileye had the same tech as AP1 in multiple other cars but never turned it on continuously? Why do you think it was always limited to highway speeds and correcting a lack of input? Well that's because it can't tell an overhead sign from a stopped firetruck very well...) Are we really then allowed to go back and go "well they had a nice disclaimer". - It's funny really, because calling it Autopilot wasn't enough (spare me the airplane comparisons). Now there's a feature list called "Full Self Driving... capability" Like, the term FSD is used as part of a label for a collection of features, of which NOT A SINGLE ONE is even a COMPONENT of self driving, because EVERY SINGLE ONE requires full time driver attention. They're literally using the fact that theoretically, one day, the SENSORS MIGHT OVERLAP WITH WHAT FSD REQUIRES to sell it as... not FSD. FSD capability. What a joke. - Tesla has gotten away with homicide, and I guess we're ok with them continuing to. The useless comparisons about "Tesla with AP is safer than Tesla without", show me the comparison that Tesla with AP is safer than AEB+LKA+ACC (pretty much AP, minus the party trick that lulls drivers into a false sense of security), and I'll show you a made up study. Because that would be AP being exactly what it already is, minus the one mode where the driver is supposed to be a safety net for the computer. Where the driver already has responsibility to make sure it doesn't crash! It's literally like removing the ability to steer your bike with the training wheels, the training wheels are still there! It's simple really, Tesla has put marketability of a safety feature, over the actual safety benefits, at the cost of human lives.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI agree that the marketing is misleading and unreasonable but I think the last part of your comment is going too far. I drive a car without any of those features. I think my car's level of safety is acceptable. If AP can beat that level of safety, it's good enough. It's okay if AP isn't the absolute safest mode, just like it's okay if companies sell cars that "only" have a 4-star crash rating.
- theshrike79 6y agoExactly this. People are expecting car "autopilots" to exceed all human drivers in every situation, which is a completely silly place to move the goalpost to. I see it more as an assistant that makes us all better drivers by letting us concentrate on stuff the computer can't do. Even my Hyundai can drive automatically perfectly well at highway speeds and follow the road and even slow down with the traffic. This lets me relax behind the wheel and concentrate on other things than keeping the car in the lane. I feel I'm a lot less tired and more anttentive when driving with an "autopilot", all the little micro-adjustments needed vex on my brain like nothing else.
- dafoex 6y agoI agree, but I interpret the argument as such: Tesla, by using language like "your hands are only there for regulatory reasons" makes no effort to dispel the myth to the driver that the car autopilot can exceed all human drivers in every situation. It aught to be on Tesla's head to instruct the driver that they are the safety net to the computer. To use the aeroplane analogy that Tesla wants to market: the computer is the first officer in charge of flying the plane, the driver is the captain in charge of everything else.
- theshrike79 6y agoYea, the Tesla marketing team has gone a bit overboard and some people are taking their spiel as gospel. On the other hand, event the new VW ID.3 can drive on regular roads, manage roundabouts and adjust speed according to speed signs, they're just not making a huge fuss about it.
- fudged71 6y agoTesla & Co have used telemetry for PR to save face for their autopilot features, independent of the courts. If your car goes through a green light and gets T-Boned but the car flags you as being inattentive, it would be an interesting case, because without the data it would be clear that you were not at fault in any way.