10 ms·
Cells are fast and crowded places (2011)
- reubenswartz 6y agoYeah, it's pretty mind boggling... Amazing that it "works". And I think debugging single-threaded code can be hard. ;-)
- jszymborski 6y agoI mean, getting there took millennia of evolution, which is a long-time of brute-forcing. It's an incredible and beautiful thing to think about, and it's wilder than any one person's imagination, but I don't know that it's efficient ;)
- ahelwer 6y agoI don't know... look at ATP Synthase, it's basically an electric motor made out of crazy nanotech from the future. Seems pretty efficient to me.
- dllthomas 6y agoWhether the design is efficient is a different question than whether the design process is efficient.
- jszymborski 6y agoYes, this is precisely what I was trying to get at. The process is inefficient in that it takes a long time for it to get to a workable solution, but the solutions are usually incredibly efficient.
- reubenswartz 6y agoYeah, pretty crazy that these things have been turning like mad for billions of years... ;-)
- reubenswartz 6y agoNot saying it's efficient, in the way we would think of "coding" things. One way I like to think of evolution is how long it takes to get from one state to another. So it took hundreds of millions of years for the first "life" to evolve-- perhaps close to a billion. This includes RNA, DNA, ATP, etc. Then it took about a billion-ish years to go from prokaryotic to eukaryotic life. Then about another billion-ish years to get multicellular eukaryotic life. Then it only took about a quarter billion years to have dinosaurs. It only took about 10-20 million years to go from the ancestors of all apes to having chimps, gorillas, and people. (!!!) And when you have people directing evolution, like with dogs or crops, you can make things happen very "quickly".
- Terr_ 6y agoEfficiency tends to come at the cost of not being robust against the unknown. The crazy mutant random number generator might not go fast, but perhaps it's less likely to get stuck...
- qwertox 6y agoIt's crazy what happens in there. It's as if other lifeforms exist at this cellular level, which wouldn't even care if they form part of a human or a plant, acting as if they have their own life, their own motivation and ability to execute it, their own purpose and will to live by it. As if what applies to us individuals, with our thoughts and actions, also applies to these subsystems of a cell, in a different form. What could be their motivation to build humans, to assemble brains that can reflect, eyes that can see, senses built to enable interaction with this world? Where do these instructions come from?
- Schinken_ 6y agoWith things like these I always like to visualize it backwards. These things don't want anything. It's just the way things work. If you manage to form an organism that survives better than other organisms, there will be more of you (and your cells). There is no "want" and "like" in evolution, just "works" and "replication".
- pharke 6y agoIt's more interesting to think that evolution is guided by the selective pressures that exist in the environment. That means that all of the current forms of life are finding the optimal design for their environment and interaction with other life forms. Human beings have evolved to fit this world and if we continue to expand beyond it we will continue to evolve to fit the solar system, the galaxy, and the universe. It's hard not to feel that there is some optimal thing that we are heading towards, the solution to the question posed by reality.
- leetcrew 6y ago> It's hard not to feel that there is some optimal thing that we are heading towards, the solution to the question posed by reality. depends how optimistic/pessimistic you are. I find it far more likely that humans will eventually hit some local maximum in a trough too deep to ever escape.
- benlivengood 6y ago
- unavoidable 6y agoDNA is spaghetti code... but it all works somehow.
- agumonkey 6y agolet's take polymer, thermodynamics and statistical physics and make a new harder field out of these..
- hi41 6y agoNice work by op. When I see the world and space, I cannot stop being awestruck by how everything is so beautiful. I am not able to explain all of this just based on randomness and Darwin’s evolutionary theory. I think there is God. Does anyone else get the same feeling? I also admit that I don’t know who the real God is. I also feel terrible sadness that the real God does not reveal himself to each individual when the expectation is that being the father he has responsibility to lead each individual.
- ksk 6y agoI think you have the right approach. We all have to be humble and accept wherever science leads us. If god is part of the natural order, and we find evidence for this phenomenon, then it should be accepted.
- dev_tty01 6y agoAgree. The difficulty is that as we learn more, we often (not always) tend to believe that we have most of the answers and become less open to other possibilities with respect to God or simply more understanding. We have to keep in mind how much of our current knowledge has been acquired in perhaps the last one or two hundred years. In other words, we are probably complete neophytes with respect to our understanding of the universe as a whole. As a result we have to resist our more arrogant tendencies and try to keep an open mind to things that we may not yet be able to sense or measure. As scientists, I think we have to recognize that God may not exist, but we must also recognize that it may exist, keeping in mind that our definition of "God" is probably way off base from what we might eventually come to recognize.
- ksk 6y agoYes, and we have to guard against knowledge regressions (dark ages) too. It is critical that we preserve our human tradition of passing inter-generational knowledge to the next generation. As an example, I see several older nerds complain that the new generation keeps re-inventing the same-old same-old tech, and I do see a small grain of truth there, but by and large I think we have successfully managed to transfer our knowledge and experience to the new generation so that they can push the boundaries even further. I remember reading (think it was Neil Tyson) that at some point in the future, if the universe continues at its current rate of expansion, we (earth) might arrive at a future state where we cannot detect the cosmic b/g radiation and other markers which confirm certain physical characteristics of the universe. I wonder if the future humans will accept that the humans who came before them really observed this phenomenon and that they can rely on that data :)
- koeng 6y agoIf you want beautiful representations of what cells look like, highly recommend David Goodsell’s pictures. They’re highly regarded in the field of biotech
- rattray 6y agoLink?
- Klinky 6y agoSome of them are at http://pdb101.rcsb.org/sci-art/goodsell-gallery/ http://pdb101.rcsb.org/sci-art/goodsell-gallery/
- epistasis 6y agoHere's a profile that includes some of his watercolors: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/04/meet-scientist-painter-who-turns-deadly-viruses-beautiful-works-art https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/04/meet-scientist-paint...
- Emphere 6y agoHis book, "The Machinery of Life", is just wonderful.
- flobosg 6y agoI also like his renderings of protein structures: http://pdb101.rcsb.org/motm http://pdb101.rcsb.org/motm
- twic 6y agoIn case anyone missed the caption: the second picture on the page, "a representation of how crowded cells really are", is by Goodsell.
- jfarlow 6y agoGoodsell's book, "Machinery of Life" is fantastic at giving a first-pass representation of the basic interactions in a cell that are otherwise invisible. https://ccsb.scripps.edu/goodsell/machinery-of-life/ https://ccsb.scripps.edu/goodsell/machinery-of-life/
- searine 6y agoYeah that "crowded" cell picture is iconic. I remember my biochemistry teacher showing it several times in undergrad years ago, and really trying to hammer home the density of the cytoplasm. Sometimes we have to reset our natural intuitions and I'm glad that professor did her job in making me more accurately imagine the interior of the cell.
- ramraj07 6y agoWhat's more interesting is its not just crowded but organized. We are starting to discover that large patches of cell membrane as well as the cellular volume might also be highly structured (p granules, etc) and gel like, and God knows what other mechanisms are involved.
- aylmao 6y agoI'm always awe-struck thinking about the fact we know this. For example the ATP synthase motors in the Mitochondria— we have figured out ways to discover these sorts of things without seeing them, just by chemical analysis, computer modeling, trial and error. Moreover, this is just what we know, but there must be so much more we don't know. It's astounding to think just how much more might be hiding in these very complex systems.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoTo think that the machinery of the human body evolved from water and basic elements. It's hard to believe sometimes.
- mdavidn 6y agoMost of life's history on this planet was single-celled. That's especially astounding when you consider the short generation time of single-celled life. The building blocks for these complex molecular machines existed before multicellular life was possible.
- wombatmobile 6y agoThe first 2 billion years was single celled. Since then, life on earth has been a combination of single celled prokaryotic cells, and much larger (100x) eukaryotic cells. The evolution of eukaryotes, which comprise all the plants and animals you see on David Attenborough's Life on Earth show, didn't occur until the Earth had developed an oxygen rich atmosphere. What's amazing about eukaryotic cells is that they formed from colonies of prokaryotic cells, in a process called endosymbiosis. There's a reason why the mitochondria in eukaryotic cells look like little bacteria like organisms. They actually were once separate prokaryotic organisms. Same for chloroplasts in plant cells. How Two Microbes Changed History https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhF5G2k45vY&t=343s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhF5G2k45vY&t=343s
- jfarlow 6y ago
- nynx 6y agoHonestly, some of these, like the ATP synthase, spin/move slower than I expected. The ATP synthase spins at ~700 Hz. I'm not sure what I was expected, but it was in the tens of kilohertz.
- ncmncm 6y ago170 mV across a membrane only, what, 40 angstroms thick, is a field strength of >40 million volts/meter.
- mncharity 6y agoThere's pretty video of bacteria with green-fluorescent-protein electric-field probes, flashing like (mostly on) fireflies, as they briefly drop membrane potential to dump charged waste without having to pump it against gradient.
- mncharity 6y ago"Membrane potential changes results from very small net charge movements across the membrane"[2], like 10^-4th or 10^-5th[1] of the potassium ions in a cell. Bionumbers is a fun site: "membrane potential" https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/search.aspx?trm=membrane+potential https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/search.aspx?trm=membrane+... [1] https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?id=106433&ver=0&trm=membrane+potential&org= https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?id=106433&... [2] https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?id=110762&ver=4&trm=membrane+potential&org= https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?id=110762&...
- Pulcinella 6y agoI remember doing some back of the envelope calculations that showed the potential across the membrane was equivalent to only a few dozen potassium ions more on the outside or inside. Basically a countable number of atoms have to be moved by the cell to develop that potential.
- munificent 6y agoI find this initially unintuitive, but it makes sense when you think about it. Look at any other system that produces aggregate emergent behavior out the behavior of smaller parts. For example, here's Conway's Game of Life implemented using... Conway's Game of Life: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xP5-iIeKXE8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xP5-iIeKXE8 It takes many many steps of the inner game of life to produce a single iteration of the outer simulation. In general, with emergent behavior, it takes a lot of inner steps to produce a single meaningful step in the outer system. So it makes sense that our cells are much faster than we intuititively think of as "fast". Because our intuition about speed is itself the product an emergent system. We are that larger Game of Life there, so it looks incredibly fast to watch the inner one according to our own time scale.
- gotostatement 6y agowhat's interesting is that the GoL inception is (as far as I understand) highly sensitive to initial conditions and timing in order for everything to sync up properly, whereas the cell is really robust in terms of everything just jumping around randomly and yet still getting its tasks done
- Pulcinella 6y agoYeah it feels as if the cell is a ridiculously parallel array of molecules where every molecule in the array is rapidly iterating through the array (colliding with every molecule in the cell as it diffuses) and type checking those items to see if it can operate on them (e.g. a protein breaking down a small molecule). It all works out because the operations are atomic (heh) (don’t need to worry about two proteins trying to break down the same molecule at the same time) and the type safety (proteins are highly specific on what kind of chemicals they target) means you don’t need to worry about trying to perform some invalid operation. Turns out collision detection is real fast in real life!
- xwdv 6y agoWhat would happen if a cell were somehow to be optimized such that every operation occurs in O(1) time rather than having to iterate?
- gambler 6y agoReminds me of some Alan Kay talks: https://youtu.be/YyIQKBzIuBY?t=1384 https://youtu.be/YyIQKBzIuBY?t=1384 He actually mentions the book that is the source for the first illustration in the article. He also often talks about the speed of molecules and how it's counter-intuitive to the commonplace idea of cell operation. Cell biology was an inspiration for original OOP (which wasn't much like Java/C++ at all). When reading about Covid stuff and immunity, I often think how these mechanism could be imitated in engineering. I definitely believe there are some general principles that we could benefit from without trying to "simulate" biology. Edit: Sorry, same author/illustrator, but different book.
- selestify 6y agoAny chance you could provide a summary of how OOP was originally much more similar to cell biology? :)
- gambler 6y agoSome of the ideas that were translated to reality are covered here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjJaFG63Hlo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjJaFG63Hlo Some of them never got fully translated to reality at Xerox because of various reasons (e.g. memory limitation of hardware at the time). This is worth a read: http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~mt/thesis/mt-thesis-Contents.html http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~mt/thesis/mt-thesis-Contents.ht...
- amatic 6y agoOOP could only have been inspired by the then-available knowledge of cell biology, and it seems that even today we still have a lot to learn.
- ncmncm 6y agoWe know way less than we don't know. And much of what we think we know is wrong.
- 01100011 6y agoI think what made it click for me was thinking of explosions. Think of something like the detonation of ammonium nitrate. It is incredibly fast on a human timescale. It is just a chemical reaction. Chemistry can happen at insane speeds. Even the monstrous molecules of biology can interact at incomprehensible speeds. Think of all that needs to go on just to make a neuron fire, much less a million neurons forming a thought. It's amazing that our bodies manage to last as long as they do. That is an awful lot of stuff that has to go right or else we die.
- modeless 6y agoIt always bothered me that in the standard explanations of how these processes work it always seemed that reaction ingredients would somehow magically seek each other out, such as in videos like this where the amino acids arrive at the ribosome in order: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfYf_rPWUdY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfYf_rPWUdY The molecules really do move randomly, not magically, and it's just that they go so fast and are so numerous and collide so often that even random chance puts the right molecules in the right place many times per second. This article was a revelation when I first read it and I'm quite disappointed that this was never explained properly in my entire school life.
- wombatmobile 6y agoDon't be disappointed. Most of the things you were taught in school were simplifications of reality. The curriculum is taught this way to make it easier for you to incorporate a lot of axioms from different fields into your fledgling, inexperienced mind. Once you have a number of these axioms at your disposal, you are equipped to leave the nest and go out into the world and make sense of new things yourself, at whatever depth and speed suits your circumstances and interests.
- modeless 6y agoThis isn't a simplification though. It's a complification. It's both more important and easier to understand than a lot of the biology stuff that I was taught. The curriculum should be rearranged to prioritize this higher.
- sthnblllII 6y agoCorrect. In most class-based education, biology is treated just like history and math and everything else. All subjects are just collections of disconnected factoids handed down from on high. Intuition requires initiative, and initiative means asking questions, and asking questions takes away class time from the unintuitive students learning more factoids. The point is: go to your professors' office hours!
- 6y ago
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI had no idea. I am really glad to see this piece. I've spent more than 19 years getting myself healthier while the world spit in my face and called me crazy. I did so by focusing on trying to understand my genetic disorder at the cellular level. Most genetic disorder involve a miscoded protein. Your DNA serves as the blue prints for a complex factory called a "cell" and when there is a bug in the code of your DNA, the 3D printer mechanisms translating those instructions into physical reality create something broken. That something broken is typically a bit of protein that normally gets folded up and used as a tool within the cell. When it is miscoded, it can't do it's job. It's sometimes kind of like a cog missing a tooth. As the cell gets more chemically deranged from the tools misfiring, you see more misfolded proteins. If either salinity or pH balance are off, those proteins are more likely to misfold. I think this accounts for what gets called "The normal progression of CF." It's a positive feedback loop -- aka a vicious cycle. More broken proteins leads to worse chemical derangement and worse chemical derangement leads to more broken proteins and we are off and running on a highway to hell. In cystic fibrosis, the protein that gets miscoded is known as the CFTR -- the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator. It serves as a channel in the cell membrane. You can think of it like a traffic light managing traffic into and out of the cell of certain proteins or an air lock and only certain proteins with the right ID card get to use it. It causes the body to misprocess salt (NACL -- sodium chloride) and also sodium bicarbonate -- aka baking soda. I think the misprocessing of sodium bicarbonate is a large factor in why people with CF are so prone to being very acid. I initially thought this my big discovery. It turns out everyone who knows anything about CF knows it causes excess acidity, including patients and doctors. They just don't bother to do a damn thing about it and act like it isn't clinically significant information. "You are people are dying. We know you are too acid. Meh. Can't be related. Moving on." Even though if you get ketoacidosis they promptly hospitalize you because you can be dead within three days. Ketoacidosis is typically rooted in diabetes and people with CF are at high risk of developing a special form of diabetes known as Cystic Fibrosis Related Diabetes (CFRD). But lets not confuse any poor doctors and scientists with the facts. The slow boiling of the tissues of people with CF in acid couldn't possibly be anything like this extremely deadly condition for which they promptly hospitalize you. No. Let's just ignore the acidification of people dying of CF. Can't possibly be clinically significant. The salt wasting we do has significant implications because as the salt gets sweated out at high rates, it drags other electrolytes with it. Reading up on Altitude Sickness was hugely helpful to my understanding of what was going on with my body and finally gave me a direct connection between the respiratory problems and the gut issues that both occur in CF. When you are altitude and can't get enough oxygen, you begin peeing more. You do this because the body cannot breath out all of the wastes accumulating in your blood and your body starts shunting those wastes through the kidneys as a backup system. So your blood chemistry directly connects what is going on in your lungs to what is going on in your gut. These are not "separate and unrelated systems that never interact." It is not "mere coincidence" that people with CF have both gut and respiratory issues. Of course, a more fundamental issue is that CF significantly impacts all epithelial tissues and all mucus membranes and your lungs and gut both fall in both categories. (Your skin is also epithelial tissue, but not a mucus membrane.) Anyway, glad to see cell biology getting some attention. This helps explain a lot about what I have accomplished and I am sort of glad I didn't get the memo earlier. Thinking of the cell in relatively simple terms was helpful to me, if only to make me feel less intimidated by the process of trying to get well while the entire world treated me abusively for not liking what was happening to my body and not wanting to quietly and meekly go along with their plans to gruesomely murder me so doctors and scientists could feel like they are smart and know things and former homemakers are clearly all "dumb blondes" or some shit. Yes, I have baggage. No, I'm not apologizing. The world could have been less awful to me. It chose not to be.
- nobrains 6y agoWow! So, molecular transports and reactions within cells happens to be probabilistic, and not mechanical. For me, this is new mind-blown level info.
- rini17 6y agoWhat if, instead of monolithic chip we had "cells" filled by fluid with tiny chiplets in brownian motion. They would bump into each other or the wall to exchange packets of data or to recharge themselves.
- Aperocky 6y agoYou would have a computer that display the intelligence level of a bacteria.
- mncharity 6y agoDoes anyone know of resources or groups with a focus on educationally conveying a feel for foundational biochemistry mechanics: extreme violence; random; crowded; with locality and concentration enhancement? For instance, there's a video of simulated viral icosahedral capsid assembly, where the panels are tethered together to maintain proximity, so you get to see realistic assembly and disassembly and reassembly, temporary misfits and irreversible fails, and just a whole lot of flailing and slamming around until something clicks. It's ok for showing 10 nm scale object violence, but I've never seen anything good for 1 nm or 100 nm scale violence. And for concentration enhancement, I've only ever seen nice slides in research talks. Given how pervasive related misconceptions are, it'd be interesting to have a page to point to where the best available misconception antigens are slowly accumulated.
- jfarlow 6y agoOne issue is that the scales don't well-match. And there are actually many time-scales beneath us, not just a few (and that biology/life is working at them all - including those on the order of millions of years. An event like a "protein folding" can take milliseconds, in a tube [1]. While atomic/biophysical/biochemical simulations have time-steps of femto-seconds. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFcp2Xpd29I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFcp2Xpd29I From https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3890418/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3890418/ "Traditional MD [Molecular Dynamics (protein folding)] simulations are limited in length by timestep limits. Studies by our group and others have shown that traditional MD is limited to timesteps of about 2 fs due to high-frequency resonance frequencies.1–3 Many biologically relevant motions occur on the microsecond to millisecond range, which is 9 to 12 orders of magnitude greater than the timesteps possible with traditional MD. Further, each step requires a costly force calculation (O(N) to O(N2)). As such, simulating medium-size proteins often requires months of computer time on a large distributed cluster such as Folding@home4,5 to simulate milliseconds of dynamics, while simulating a large protein (e.g. the β-2 Adrenergic Receptor) on biologically-relevant time scales (milliseconds through hours) using a standard desktop computer would take years. Thus, it is not feasible to simulate timescales of biological interest without substantial advances in MD methods." 12 orders of magnitude of difference in time is akin to the difference between causal events happening once per millisecond and those happening once per century. How do you show a movie capturing the nuance of someone's blink reflex, along with their birth life and death... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHeTQLNFTgU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHeTQLNFTgU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdmbpAo9JR4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdmbpAo9JR4
- agumonkey 6y agolife was described as a miracle but facts like that make it even more so.. how organized processes emerges from this HF mess is .. surprising.
- peterburkimsher 6y ago(2011)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]