3 ms·
I'm always fascinated by these old techniques. Two surfaces can slide along one another if they are both spherical, but not three. You can make three wooden str
by analog31 6y ago
I'm always fascinated by these old techniques. Two surfaces can slide along one another if they are both spherical, but not three. You can make three wooden straight-edges this way too. Instead of blue ink, you can use chalk.
One thing I'm curious about, is whether this is actually how granite surface plates are still made. Or have they switched to some kind of interferometry.
- ethanwillis 6y agoI'd love to know the answer to your question too. I initially learned of this method while reading through Wayne Moore's "Foundations of Mechanical Accuracy" which was written in 1970 afaik.
- jbay808 6y agoInterferometry still only acts as a comparison (to a reference mirror). So there's still the 3 plate method at the heart of it, although I expect most commercially produced surface plates are just machine-ground and then measured against a master, rather than hand-made three at a time. Edit to elaborate -- to make those ultraflat mirrors, you can also use an interferometric variant of the 3-plate method when, instead of granite or cast iron surface plates, you're making optical flats. Instead of looking at contact patterns with dye, you can observe the interference bands that show up between two optically flat, smooth surfaces to compare them, which is generally more sensitive. But it's still a comparison process. You still proceed by lapping the high spots and checking again...
- mikewarot 6y agoWyler makes inclinometers that are accurate enough to measure the change in angle of a surface plate directly. It's amazing technology. Here is a YouTube video from 2011 that talks about how they were developed. I remember that I was watching videos about surface plate calibration, and this came up. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0doCHgJa3Ps https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0doCHgJa3Ps
- imtringued 6y agoYou only need this method to create the first one. Based on that reference surface you can scrape as many flat surfaces as you want. If you build a flat machine like a surface grinder then that surface grinder can transfer its own flatness onto a surface plate.
- ganzuul 6y agoIt is a wonderful feeling in machining when you figure out how to transfer features mechanically without going through a numerical intermediate. You are essentially working with a compass and straightedge in your mind, comparing surfaces, lines and single points of contact directly. There is no accumulation of error from approximate measurements. Regardless of accuracy, your precision is infinite. Look up a 'sine bar' and gauge blocks for inspiration. :) It is also interesting to note that functional surfaces are very simple, being composed of flats, rounds and inclined planes. This is why you can make nearly anything with a lathe (and a mill to spare your sanity).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]