3 ms·
Ah, I've been thinking about this, what we need to ban is this: * The creation of products or services derived from the collection of users private information
by mrweasel 6y ago
Ah, I've been thinking about this, what we need to ban is this:
* The creation of products or services derived from the collection of users private information.
I don't expect Garmin to not track their users, that's basically the feature we bought when we buy their watches. Sonos/Samsung/Facebook/Google, who-ever, should be allowed to collect data on their users, BUT they should NOT be allowed to turn that data into a product that is resold to third parties.
For most companies that would mean the end of data collection, while not preventing those companies who use the data for creating meaningful services to do so.
- teddyh 6y agoWouldn’t that merely create an incentive to work around the “no third party” rule by doing everything in-house? Like Google, for instance.
- amelius 6y agoYes, data brokers should not be allowed to exist [1]. But I also think that any collection of data for advertising purposes (e.g. by Google) is unjustified, simply because if the user is looking for a product they can enter the data that they think is relevant in a search (which is immediately forgotten), and this could provide similar accuracy to following the user without the downsides. (In case of such a "product search", Google could extend the search procedure by adding some questions and/or checkboxes, as long as they forget the data immediately.) [1] https://clearcode.cc/blog/what-is-data-broker/ https://clearcode.cc/blog/what-is-data-broker/