5 ms·
Maybe we need more male teachers for kindergarten and the younger grades. Perhaps some sort of affirmative action or preferential hiring for male teachers for k
by fortran77 6y ago
Maybe we need more male teachers for kindergarten and the younger grades. Perhaps some sort of affirmative action or preferential hiring for male teachers for k through 6th grades?
- baskire 6y agoI’ve actually been suprised feminist aren’t pushing for this. It’d help their overall narrative. You have similar gender gaps in nursing as well.
- goatinaboat 6y agoYou have similar gender gaps in nursing as well. British teaching unions shot it down - said it was misogynistic to hire men as it implied women weren’t doing a good enough job. This logic of course doesn’t apply to tech.
- annexrichmond 6y agoDo you have a source for this?
- MyHypatia 6y agoI think some feminists do push for this in the name of gender equality, and caretaking not only being a female responsibility. At the same time, the idea that mainly women should solve the problem of "young boys need positive male role models" seems ironic. I'm sure many women do care because they want their sons to thrive, but men want their sons to thrive too, right?
- HarryHirsch 6y agoI thought in nursing the gender gap is closing because it's one of the few careers that actually pays off these days. At regional colleges the nursing major is usually the one with the highest salary, you can check that on the Department of Education's website. High school leavers seem to be directed towards it, especially first-generation students.
- MyHypatia 6y agoThere are various initiatives to attract more male teachers, but research suggests that the low status and pay of teaching deter men from entering education. Raising the respect and salary of teachers would be a good starting point. Preferential hiring to balance the gender ratio of role models in a school may be helpful as well. https://www.edutopia.org/male-teacher-shortage https://www.edutopia.org/male-teacher-shortage
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoI’ve heard from a friend whose a special ed teacher that there effectively is a strong desire for male teachers in these grades. But there’s also so much need in this space that there’s a desire for any credentialed teacher. It’s not really like software engineering where people have to know algorithms and do whiteboard exercises. It’s about credentials and desire.
- joshuaissac 6y agoQuotation from the paper:[1] > I find that the gender bias does not differ by teachers’ gender in literature, and only marginally in math. In this subject, female teachers are less biased in favor of girls than male teachers So adding more male teachers might marginally increase the discrimination rather than decrease it. 1. http://ftp.iza.org/dp10343.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp10343.pdf
- MyHypatia 6y agoThat's interesting thanks for sharing. I guess that begs the question: even if there are some documented negative effects, does it outweigh the benefit of young boys experiencing positive role models in the classroom? Measuring the benefit of role models is really hard to quantify, but role models definitely influence people.
- newsclues 6y agoMaybe we need robot teachers to remove the bias?
- etempleton 6y agoElementary and middle schools in the United States would welcome more male applicants. The issue is there are not many males that major in education at the undergraduate college level and so there are not many male applicants to choose from. This is a societal / financial issue. Societal because boys see education as a woman's job, which is reinforced through their educational experience of having mostly female teachers. Financial because as much as Americans like to think that they live in a progressive society, males are typically expected to be the primary income earner. Education simply does not pay well; particularly when you consider the education and credentials required. Education in the United States has added increased prerequisites to become a teacher in a public school. In all likelihood, your child's teacher either already has or is working on their master's in education to maintain their teaching credentials. If they have aspirations of being an administrator they are likely working on a doctorate. This to earn a maximum annual salary of less than $100,000 and only after decades of working for a school district.
- jdbernard 6y agoAnother reason is that American society today often assumes there is something wrong or creepy with men who choose to spend their time with children. I don't think this is a valid assumption, but it is a common one, at least in my experience as a father.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoThe pedophile hysteria in the US makes teaching elementary school an actively hazardous career choice for men.
- worker767424 6y ago> The issue is there are not many males that major in education at the undergraduate college level and so there are not many male applicants to choose from. This is like the mythical pool of untapped female engineering talent VPs of Diversity and Inclusion imply exists.