3 ms·
> 3) Act as a filtration mechanism. which begs the question - why must university be a filtration system such that others (like employers) get to have a free-r
by chii 6y ago
> 3) Act as a filtration mechanism.
which begs the question - why must university be a filtration system such that others (like employers) get to have a free-ride off of it?
Presumably it's just an unintended consequence of university study and qualification - that employers don't want the expense of sorting out candidates, and that someone capable of graduating with a degree must have some level of competency.
So, what if the gov't make university degree something that employers cannot discriminate with - like race or religion. If they want to ensure their candidate is capable, they can administer a test (or pay a central examination service provider for such a test). A candidate looking for jobs do not require a university degree, but do require taking this test (or have taken a prior test and show the results).
This way, university can remain "pure", rather than a gateway which people pay as an entry-fee for employment.
- im3w1l 6y agoThat's so crazy it might just work! I'm very impressed with this unorthodox idea.
- thatfrenchguy 6y agoNormal universities in France do this (no filtering), it comes with a bunch of issues as well, notably that special schools / programs do filter and they end up being seen as more prestigious.
- aidenn0 6y agoEmployers don't want the liability of sorting. They are outsourcing the legal status of being non-discriminatory. If a large company were to give an IQ test to every applicant, they would get sued and asked to prove it does not discriminate against a protected class. If a large company hires only from Harvard, they just say that Harvard is non-discriminatory, so that policy is as well
- dragonwriter 6y ago> If a large company were to give an IQ test to every applicant, they would get sued and asked to prove it does not discriminate against a protected class. If a large company hires only from Harvard, they just say that Harvard is non-discriminatory, so that policy is as well It is just as easy to prove that a pro-elite-university hiring practice has a differential impact on a variety of protected classes as one that uses an IQ test, and there's probably better evidence for lots of jobs that performance is predicted by IQ test results, to overcome the presumption of disparate impact discrimination from the differential impact. IQ tests, however, have a greater cultural awareness of the potential for illegality, which probably translates to a greater risk of an employee talking to an attorney and thus a suit being filed in the first place. Hiring from elite universities exclusively is a safer way to discriminate because there's less chance that the victims will seek redress, not because it outsources responsibility.
- aidenn0 6y ago> It is just as easy to prove that a pro-elite-university hiring practice has a differential impact on a variety of protected classes as one that uses an IQ test, and there's probably better evidence for lots of jobs that performance is predicted by IQ test results, to overcome the presumption of disparate impact discrimination from the differential impact. If this is true, then why haven't elite universities been successfully sued for discriminatory admissions (recently that is)?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> If this is true, then why haven't elite universities been successfully sued for discriminatory admissions (recently that is)? Employment and educational discrimination are covered by different laws, so it's not the same question, and, Even if the standards applied were the same, whether admissions are illegally discriminatory and whether hiring by graduation is would be very different questions.
- chii 6y ago> give an IQ test tho it doesn't have to be an IQ test. It could be the same sort of examination a university would administer for their degrees for their field. Except the result of the test is independent from the degree, and you can take the test without having paid for a degree (you just pay for the test - or the bill is picked up by employer, or whatever arrangement the market settles on).