9 ms·
> we believe we addressed the issue before it was exploited by any malicious parties I wonder how they are sure of this. In their logs, there would be no diff
by Nextgrid 6y ago
> we believe we addressed the issue before it was exploited by any malicious parties
I wonder how they are sure of this.
In their logs, there would be no difference between a legitimate password reset and a malicious one, given that even a legitimate flow would result in an initial request from some IP address, then when the user receives the email with the reset link they will most likely click on that from the same computer, thus the same IP address showing up on the logs. In case of a malicious attempt the same pattern would be seen - there is no way for them to know whether the user obtained the reset token from the e-mail (as they should) or directly from the password reset endpoint itself.
- sebmellen 6y ago$50 says they're not. This is something every organization has to say for PR reasons, but saying "we believe" is very fishy wording. It could well be this bug has been around for months before it was discovered, and used by many black/grey-hat hackers.
- sneak 6y agoGovernments. It was likely used by governments. Bi men who live straight lives with a wife and family are ridiculously common. The ability to blackmail those people is extremely valuable to certain state organizations.
- on_and_off 6y agoI wonder why you are getting downvoted so much. I don't know how common bi-men are (probably more than bi erasure makes us believe) but it feels like a least a portion of them are not ready to come out as bi.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I don't know how common bi-men are (probably more than bi erasure makes us believe) They're not that common. The literature shows a bimodal straight/gay distribution of homosexual tendency in men and a more Gaussian distribution in women.
- anchpop 6y agoThe "bi erasure" phenomenon is that if a man is bi, many will believe he's just gay but in denial. Because he may prefer to be seen as straight than gay, he may just let everyone think he's straight. This would reduce how many men appear to be bi in surveys.
- djaque 6y agoAlternatively, I'm gay and even though I grew up in an area of the US which wasn't that homophoboic. I still hated myself for being gay enough that if I had an even slight attraction to women then I would have just killed off the male attraction side to me. If you're bi and grow up in a world where everything tells you that being gay is wrong, then that part of you that is attracted to guys will probably never get explored.
- mindfulhack 6y agoIt also may be because of what I observe as 'masculine thinking' vs. 'feminine thinking'. It appears to be drawn biologically from the genetic male sex and 'male brain' vs. genetic female sex and 'female brain'. Natural variations exist in all things, but if you look at what's most common, with biological sex differences (whch feed cultural 'stereotypes'), they still are what they are. See Robert Green's book "The Laws of Human Nature" (2018) for his take on the following. It's very insightful. (Chapter entitled, "The Law of Gender Rigidity") 'Masculine thinking' prefers to categorise and bifurcate. (Dualism.) I'm a guy and I consider myself having a 'super' 'male' brain in some aspects even more than the average. I find it very hard to multi-task, and I easily hyperfocus. Male thinking solves problems by breaking things down and focusing on one part of the picture at a time. It's about specialisation. Female thinking treats things more as a whole, with everything connected. It solves problems by looking at the whole picture at once. It's about multi-tasking. I now see that 'male thinking' (as opposed to males), such as 'specialisation', dominates modern capitalism and public policy, and often to detriment. Most females at top levels in business at this time in our culture would appear to mostly have this success because they are 'atypically' strong in 'masculine thinking'. Personally, I think such leadership needs more female thinking. I'm slowly trying to understand it more, as my own starting point. Modern diversity policies that change what's on the outside (how many penises are around the table) don't actually solve the real problems. We're still picking what's taking place on the inside. We need diversity of things far deeper - to embrace and celebrate true 'feminine thinking' - not just what's on the surface. So anyway, this could help explain why female sexuality is seen to be more 'fluid', on average, than among males. It's not so much how people actually are, as how people see themselves, because of how they tend to be wired. And this is not even factoring in that there is greater cultural stigma around a male being bi vs. a female being bi. I am a male, and 100% bi.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anonymousiam 6y agoI've never been gay or bi, and I've never used Grindr, but I have held government security clearances for almost 40 years. It's a lot different today than it was back then. Early on, I knew several people who had "experimented" in college, and they were denied clearances. (Actually the government never officially denied them because that would require an explanation of the criteria used for the denial. Instead, it was perpetually "pending".) Anyway, the basis for their denial was the potential for blackmail, which is a serious national security threat. Sometime within the past 25-30 years, they seem to have revised their policies so gay/bi people can get cleared, as long as they are open about it.
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s not really being bi that’s the problem here so much as cheating on a wife secretly
- np_tedious 6y agoAre bi guys that much more likely to do this than straight ones? I could believe 2x, but it doesn't seem like an order of magnitude kind of difference
- ohyeshedid 6y agoIt's more about them keeping it secret; secrets are some of the most valuable currency.
- setr 6y agoBut then it has nothing to do with being bi... unless they're secretely bi, in which case it has nothing to do with cheating...
- reanimus 6y agoFactually speaking yes but practically speaking gay/straight people tend to be doubly touchy about their partner "playing for the other team" so to speak. Which... I mean, cheating is cheating is cheating lol
- learnstats2 6y agoI'm not sure why being on Grindr is being seen here as a blackmail risk. If you are visible on Grindr, you have made a kind of public testimony. So, you have reduced your blackmail risk - since you're already at least somewhat prepared for this information to be public.
- neltnerb 6y agoA lot of the information a user who owns an account can see is not visible to the public. I don't see why being on Grindr in 2020 would be a blackmail risk IN COUNTRIES WHERE BEING GAY IS LEGAL.
- learnstats2 6y agoOK, but in that case you're at (potentially much) greater risk than blackmail. Why is blackmail the risk that people on this page are going to, then, is my question. If you're willing to make a public statement then blackmail is lower risk, not higher risk.
- neltnerb 6y agoI'm not sure, sorry. I'm not honestly sure why there's so much discussion about security clearances. If someone gets your grindr account they can get your (a) address, (b) phone number, and (c) private photos, none of which would otherwise be public. So let's just get that out there. A reasonable user would not expect that any of those three things are readily available to a stranger that they've never talked to who merely has their email address. Especially if they turn off distances specifically to avoid triangulation attacks on their location. Those pieces of information can be used together to harrass, commit violence, or threaten to leak your photos or personal (albeit sure, not "private") conversations. Those are the obvious ones, but other information in there can also hidden from public view, like HIV status. With this bug a malicious person could knowingly target you based on email address instead of finding you and even putting the work into catfishing you into sending them embarrassing photos. I'd say that's a higher blackmail risk but only because of the hack, a little. Catfishes still existed but this makes doing it invisible and massive in scale while associating it with a public ID like your email address.
- grayfaced 6y agoI was disturbed by that statement as well. It's pure PR spin based on turning a blind eye. They could detect mass malicious activity if a single IP was resetting thousands of accounts. But I'm skeptical they even checked based on the horrible initial flaw and specious response.
- rocqua 6y agosaying they are working on the disclosure system is good especially because it seems unprompted.
- godelski 6y agoNot saying they did, but couldn't you make an estimate by looking at frequency of resets by single accounts? If someone took over an active account presumably that person would reset the password to get back in (and have a weird email). ASSUMING Grindr logs the person out of the app when the password is reset. You might also have a few emails from users...
- Nextgrid 6y agoThis would detect a large-scale attack, but wouldn't detect small-scale, targeted attacks as they would just get lost in the noise of legitimate password resets. Furthermore, for dormant accounts (where the user is no longer using the app - potentially because they are now in a relationship) the user will not notice anything either, and the notification email is likely to get lost in the endless newsletter spam the non-technical majority has in their inbox.
- godelski 6y agoI think this is a good point. I'll admit that I'm naive about web and security (not my area). Are multiple password resets within a small time frame common? I would not expect this to be common, but user behavior has often defied my expectation. If it is uncommon I think you could create a correlation and get an estimate, if it is common then I completely agree that it would be lost in the noise. And yeah I agree that this type of analysis wouldn't help with dormant accounts and also does require them to log the user out on their phone (otherwise why issue another reset?). But both these could be captured. This is probably way too much analysis for such an attack and over engineering the issue, but hey that's what we all do, right? haha
- Nextgrid 6y agoIncreased volume of password resets would indeed suggest an attack, though it can also be explained by benign reasons (redesign of the app, marketing campaign prompting previous users to log back in, news exposure, the pandemic increasing loneliness and making more people use dating apps, etc). However the biggest risk here is that small, targeted attacks distributed over time (where a single attacker only targets a handful of accounts) wouldn't stand out in the overall statistics. In case of this incident, small-scale attacks (where a single person targets a single account of someone they don't like) are actually more likely which is why them saying they do not believe this was exploited while being completely unable to detect these attacks is so misleading and lures people into a false sense of security.
- empiko 6y agoThey didn't say they are sure of it. They said they believe it :)
- wlesieutre 6y agoSince when do beliefs require evidence? They don’t mention any, so this is the most positive sounding but still truthful position they can take. Best I can think of is geolocating IPs of the reset requests and then seeing if the real owner (near original location) does a second reset later to take the account back, but that’s not convincing especially if you know where the account you’re targeting lives and went through a VPN in the same city to match.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIt's still pretty misleading. They are supposed to be the experts (in the eyes of non-technical people) and if you don't have the skills to understand how the attack works it's reasonable (or at least used to be reasonable) to consider that the risk is minimal if "experts" do not believe it's bad. This response lures their users into a false sense of security.
- Judgmentality 6y ago> This response lures their users into a false sense of security. That's the entire point of their response though. If all you ever had to do was tell people the truth, PR wouldn't be a thing.
- HenryBemis 6y agoLogging IP address and have some AI/SIEM comparing IPs of regular/past use to IPs on-or-after a password reset can give 'some' level of comfort. E.g. if someone has extensive use from NY-USA IP address and the requests came from a Paris-FR IP address then 99% it is an attack and you block or send out email/SMS (just in case) or 1% that person's company guest WiFi surfaces in another country (e.g. mega-big insurance company in London has corp internet exiting in Chicago and guest network exiting in London). In any case, it is better/safer to cause some slight inconvenience to prevent data leak.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ozzie_osman 6y agoWell email tracking isn't perfect, but it can help a lot. A legitimate pattern you'd see an email open event, email click event, then successful reset in that order. An illegitimate one might have no email open or click before the reset, or clicks from multiple places or something like that. That could narrow down the list significantly. Of course, not all email clients allow send these events.
- matt123456789 6y agoIt’s possible that the emailed link contains extra query params which are logged. Checking for the existence of these query params in requests would enable them to verify that reset requests to date were clicked from email rather than using this method.
- anchpop 6y agoAlso, the referrer header may be different too? Although it's likely nobody thought to log it.
- komarov_om 6y agoI would expect a "Referer" value to be empty in both cases: - directly navigating to a URL after doing a copy-paste - opening a link from an email