8 ms·
Apple says electronics recycler “illegally” reselling over 100k iPhones, iPads
- fmakunbound 6y agoReuse is better than recycling, so what's the problem?
- djsumdog 6y agoTheir contract may have not allowed it .. which shows how shitty the contract was. Apple doesn't care about preventing environmental damage. Fixing/Refubing and selling is WAY better for the planet than trying to extract all the components, melt them down, and build new product. This disposable phone world and infinite growth economy has got to stop.
- PakG1 6y agoEasier to do that if software requirements don't keep growing. If people were satisfied with lower resolution photos and videos, lower-quality graphics in mobile games, etc, etc, they'd find it much harder to release newer models and have such great sales numbers.
- dasil003 6y agoThis is a complete non-sequitur and a terrible apologist argument for a bad practice. Apple is literally stopping their phones from being recycled to a willing customer base. If there was no market for those phones then this wouldn't be an issue. Also, software is, and always has been, written to satisfy the capabilities of the hardware. If the market decides to stop upgrading, software will continue to work.
- tonywastaken 6y agoDo you think these devices were sold disclosing that Apple themselves found them to be not worthy of repair? Don't think so. Of course there is a market for cheaper Apple products. There is never a market for Apple products that catch fire in your pocket.
- Chris2048 6y agoIT's not clear to me what the difference is. What exactly are they recycling, and how. I can personally see how refurb/debugging an old iPad might be harder then just replacing all the cheaper parts (caps, PCBs, cheaper ICs) and retesting more expensive components; especially at scale. Also, even if they are melting them down and literally recasting them: ALU has pretty good recasting credentials.
- RandallBrown 6y agoApple does fix and refurbish their phones. Presumably the phones sent to this recycler were deemed too broken to refurbish (at least to Apple's standards.)
- strbean 6y agoSo 100% of iPhones older than the X are too broken to refurbish? That does not check out.
- Joker_vD 6y agoWell, very technically speaking, they did recycle those iPhones. Why is Apples so obsessed with controlling the entirety of their devices' life cycle, anyway?
- djsumdog 6y agoSales. Money. Power.
- Chris2048 6y agoAre apple still on the hook for warranty for those iProducts?
- Joker_vD 6y agoOf course not.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoApple’s concern would not be whether they are technically liable, but whether or not the cost of determining if they are liable and being scammed is more than simply destroying the items thereby reducing the probability of being scammed in the first place.
- entropicdrifter 6y agoThat's not their real concern anyhow. They just want to monopolize the supply by crippling the aftermarket as much as possible. That's been their MO for over a decade. It's also why they fight the right to repair court cases and third party repair services tooth and nail ( https://www.ifixit.com/Right-to-Repair/Intro https://www.ifixit.com/Right-to-Repair/Intro )
- RandallBrown 6y agoLets say you buy one of these recycled phones that Apple has already deemed unfixable. Maybe it mostly works, but the screen occasionally blacks out or there's a bunch of dead pixels. Maybe the battery dies almost immediately. It's Apple's reputation that gets tarnished by this.
- pwinnski 6y agoApple is probably legally in the right here, since the recycler violated their contract. But Apple seems very much in the wrong here on an ethical level. If the devices have resale value, then they should be resold, not destroyed! Reduce and Reuse are both higher priorities than Recycle.
- nottorp 6y agoYeah, that's what I read too. "Apple recycles perfectly usable iphones".
- bilbo0s 6y agoHaving gone through this exact situation with corporate attorneys before, I can tell you there is more than one contract in force here. Believe it or not, if you tell customers you will recycle old products for them, you'd better not sell them instead. When you told them you would recycle the old products, you actually made a contract with them. Don't call it recycling if there is any chance at all that you may instead resell. We learned that the hard way.
- btrask 6y ago> Believe it or not, if you tell customers you will recycle old products for them, you'd better not sell them instead. Legally, I'm sure you're right. But on a practical level, what do you think recycling is? If you fish something out of the trash and reuse it, congratulations, you have recycled it in the most efficient way possible. It's like these recyclers are "too good" at their jobs. I thought market forces were supposed to make sure of that. The really disgusting thing is Apple coopting "recycling" for "destroying unused product to maintain brand value." If you have an old Apple product and you want to be good to the environment, do not take it to an official Apple recycling dropoff!
- alexfringes 6y agoI say to you: “mind throwing this battery in the recycling on your way out, I care about its harmful materials not seeping into the environment” and you say “yes” but then decide “this battery could still power my nephew’s toy car for a bit”. But then your nephew throws it in the regular trash eventually. You’ve broken your promise to me. If you’re also the world’s most valuable public company you’ve made that promise to your shareholders and used it to increase your brand perception. It seems reasonable that you’d like to make sure you keep it, no?
- cblconfederate 6y agoI wonder what that contract said. "These devices are to be recycled in a way that creates the maximum amount of CO2"
- birdyrooster 6y ago“These devices may not be resold or refurbished.” Maybe?
- mumblerino 6y agoI really hope this makes the news internationally because it’s shameful on Apple’s part. The best way to recycle is to reuse.
- pier25 6y agoNot allowing the resale of used devices should be illegal. Not only because of the environmental impact but also because this is a way for Apple to control the market.
- ascot_attn_atol 6y agoReselling devices is good. Taking devices that were sent to you to be recycled and then reselling them is bad.
- black_puppydog 6y agoThat's, like, your opinion, man. In my opinion (and I see many sharing the sentiment here) if apple are gonna send perfectly usable devices for recycling instead of reselling them, then that is bad. Hence I would argue that their right to have a contract upheld weighs lower here than literally everyone else's right on the planet to not waste resources. We have many things you simply are not allowed into contracts. High interest loans, organ sales, you name it. Forcing someone to destroy a usable device, polluting the environment and using up resources as a result just might become one of those. I'd be in favor actually. I don't value apple's stock more than the planet. But then I also don't own any of it, so there's that...
- R0b0t1 6y agoReselling is basically recycling. Did the contract specify they had to be munched or stripped?
- entropicdrifter 6y agoIn many markets it is illegal. Heck, in Europe, Valve got in trouble for not allowing the resale of used software on Steam ( https://www.polygon.com/2019/9/19/20874384/french-court-steam-valve-used-games-eu-law https://www.polygon.com/2019/9/19/20874384/french-court-stea... )
- qppo 6y agoThat would kneecap first party recycling and trade-in discounts. Apple's incentive to provide those services is to reduce the size of the secondary market.
- psim1 6y agoPlease use the original title rather than editorialize: Apple catches electronics recycler illegally reselling over 100,000 iPhones, iPads, Apple Watches
- rat9988 6y agoThe original is highly editorialized. It's too partisan.
- dang 6y agoI'd say that title rewrite was within the site guidelines because the original was arguably baity and it doesn't seem particularly editorialized. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- fortran77 6y agoThat title is too long. I did what I could to shorten it and keep the spirit of the title.
- tonywastaken 6y agoAt face value, it seems like Apple is choosing not to reuse the devices. Apple determined that the devices were beyond repair and needed to be recycled for a reason (Potentially safety-related reasons). Geep decided to reuse them anyway, disregarding any potential safety reasons that Apple found not to be repairable. As much as I'd like to say that Apple is in the wrong here, I trust Apple's quality control guidelines over some device recycling company executives trying to make some extra cash.
- sschueller 6y agoSafety? You mean like the latest Apple update that has many laptops running at 100% CPU because of Apples's poor software testing?
- alexfringes 6y agoHow exactly does a bug in a background process, which then executes within the same thermal performance limits as any other demanding task, present a safety issue? Product quality? Sure. Safety? How?
- IntelMiner 6y agoExcept that exact same argument applies to Apple. Making it harder to reuse perfectly serviceable existing hardware simply puts an invisible hand on the balancing scale toward "buy the new shiny thing"
- tonywastaken 6y agoI think we are overestimating how much scale tipping consumers need in order to want to buy the shinny new thing. Also, we don't know the full story on either side, so our arguments are both valid.
- rasz 6y agoIts the other way around. Apple determined it was detrimental to their bottom line to repair and resell devices older than Iphone X. Devices with cracked screens, requiring battery/ charging port/ case/ button replacement, of fully working traded in https://www.apple.com/shop/trade-in https://www.apple.com/shop/trade-in ones. What do you think happens to perfectly working iphone 8 plus worth ~$300 after its been traded in? Its not being resold https://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished/iphone https://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished/iphone , it goes into a blender https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYshVbcEmUc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYshVbcEmUc
- yalogin 6y agoWhy are we assuming that these are usable devices? Apple recycled them for a reason. They are obviously cosmetically fine and so people bought them. Who knows what is going on with those devices and what issues they will create for the user.
- rasz 6y agoApple recycles motherboards in need of a Fuse replacement.
- ksk 6y agoOne of the reasons Apple does this is to block repair companies from buying broken Apple products to stock up on parts. They choke the repair supply chain by forcing parts manufacturers to only sell to them.
- temp667 6y agoGood for apple. The way this scam often works - you send your device in, they say there is a flaw and the device is not eligible for trade-in credit because it can't be re-used. Then they offer to "recycle" it for you. Then, instead of recycling they sell it. This is the consumer side of the scam. It can also be run against manufacturer like apple. Apple can offer trade in credit to consumers, then send it to these guys who evaluate the device. If can be resold apple gets the $100 or whatever average per device from the recycler (who can then make a moderate profit selling for $150 or whatever). If it can't be resold the recycler promises to recycle it and doesn't have to pay out anything. There seems too often to be a push on HN to support scams of almost every type. The outrage when apple worked to alert users when folks put the cheapo third party batteries in before reselling an iphone to make battery life look good for a few weeks (HN comments = total outrage when apple alerted users) is illustrative. Do these "geep" executives sound like the role models you want to do business with? For many folks, myself included, the answer is heck no. Reading hacker news, and the total hate towards apple for asking others to just do basic / fair things is really interesting. Following contracts and agreements is for idiots and chumps apparently. Be a scary world if the Zuckerbergs and other growth hacking developers end up in charge! Consumer trust in apple is going to continue to go up - you just realize how slimy the rest of the tech world is - scammer after scammer after cheater.
- michaelmrose 6y agoDo you have any evidence that the contracts are structured as you describe?
- temp667 6y agoBrightstar is probably one of the major US players you could look at. Take a look at their relationship with T-Mobile - they handle the trade-in piece (and reverse logistics) which is revenue generating for T-Mobile. With experience the trade-in provider can offer a fixed rate per sku / consumer reported quality once it has a sense of statistical quality of items and screening procedures for store trade-ins. This actually looks more like a situation where apple had already assessed as not reselable under their policies - so these were perhaps all for recycling only?
- jessehorne 6y agoNice.
- solarkraft 6y ago> Apple also notes that the number of stolen and resold devices must logically be greater than 103,845 since iPads and Apple Watches are only Wi-Fi compatible and cannot be noticed on carrier networks. How is that a logical necessity? It's noting other than extrapolation.
- rasz 6y ago> it was obligated to have recycled >when it was supposed to take them apart and recycle the components afaik Apple "Recycle" agreements stipulate grinding stuff down to dust. No taking apart, no recycling components, pure destruction.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]