5 ms·
There's a whole mix of real issues here. Number one for me is that money won't buy quality and its quality we're sorely lacking on "journalism" today.
by LatteLazy 6y ago
There's a whole mix of real issues here. Number one for me is that money won't buy quality and its quality we're sorely lacking on "journalism" today.
- BurningFrog 6y agoMoney buys quality in almost every other field. What makes journalism different?
- TuringNYC 6y agoSpot on. My news landscape today is far better than what existed 15 or 20yrs ago. There are new challenges, but also many new solutions. I particularly love things like Substack where journalists can be paid for good content w/o layers of middlemen.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoPrimary revenue source of journalism is exposure, which is easier to achieve by low quality, emotionally captivating, cookie-cutter garbage - so there's little incentive for changing the business model into one that would support "money buys quality". Related to that is that free-with-ads is essentially an alpha predator among business models; honest businesses can't compete with it - so it's doubly hard for a quality publisher to exit the equilibrium in which the whole industry sits.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIn most cases, money buys quality when the person paying cares and can tell. If you can't tell quality, money doesn't buy it (eg used cars for the average buyer). Also, if the person paying isn't the one using the product (or they don't care for some other reason), you stop getting quality (eg government cheese). Google arnt the ones reading articles so they don't suffer if quality falls. You also can't really quantify quality of journalism can you (of the million articles Google sponsors, which were good?). There are exceptions to this, the BBC for instance. But on the whole the US is very bad at this and even if it weren't, it's hard to do. This is also the reason journalism has collapsed in general: when customers paid for stories by buying papers the stories had to be good. But now advertisers are paying for clicks and any journalism that happens is purely co-incidental... There's also a big issue with censorship and control when Google literally own the news. I'm actually pretty pro Google, but given the amount of grilling they get, it would be really easy to just cancel some stories about them and push some about senators who dislike them etc.
- josefx 6y agoNobody cares for good journalism when you can make up a story that sounds good and supports your political views. In Germany Class Relotius[1] made a living out of faking and dramatizing his stories, winning several journalism prices before a coworker went against management to uncover it. [1]https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claas_Relotius https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claas_Relotius Note: I link the German wikipedia page since the English one only mentions that the Spiegel "was unaware of anyone helping him" while the German one explicitly cites several sources that confirm that dramatization over reality is openly encouraged as a style choice.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoExactly. What makes journalism different is that it comes with middlemen (publishers) taking almost all the profits. Other content creators are starting to find ways to reach their audience in a more direct way. E.g. novelist self publish via the Amazon Store. Vloggers self publish on Youtube. Agents/publishers still get involved but only after proven success and at that point for fair compensation. There are plenty of independent writers and journalists getting next to nothing because they have no way to monetize other than via these middlemen who pay them pennies per word. Google came along a long time ago and made them a lot less valuable than they used to be by basically becoming the primary distribution channel for stuff that was originally exclusive to their channel. So, publishers have been slowly losing cash for years and basically most remaining newspapers are shadows of their former self in terms of editorial staffing, in house (i.e. employed) writers producing good content, etc. If you are not e.g. the New York times or one of a handful of other publishers, the value add is diminishing rapidly. What journalists need is new channels. The smart thing for Google to do would be to compete directly and start paying content creators. That would of course piss everybody off which is why they don't. But it does mean that there is a business model waiting to happen out there for somebody to step up. Google of course did this successfully on Youtube already and it has helped that platform grow without having to license a lot of external content like e.g. Netflix and Amazon Prime have to do. Some kind of Netflix/Spotify/whatever for news is what is needed. I'd pay for it even. I pay for these things as well but I haven't bought a news paper in more than a decade.
- marcosdumay 6y agoTell that to the people discussing TV ads on those other threads today. As a matter of fact, I do have a hard problem to get power supply unities and rechargeable batteries. I just settled on treating those things as semi-disposable, because they all are.
- philipkglass 6y agoPaying more money is often not sufficient to get more quality, though it may be necessary to get more quality. Without visiting Consumer Reports and digging deep into Reddit, I don't know whether a $2000 refrigerator is better than the $1500 model standing next to it. I'd guess that this situation is more common than knowing that a higher priced product will be a higher quality product. In the case of newspapers, in-depth investigative reporting was never profitable on its own. Newspapers had geographically limited oligopolies over some common kinds of advertising in the 20th century. They bundled expensive investigative reports with low cost content like sports scores and weather forecasts. They interleaved display ads through all of it. Winning a Pulitzer could raise their prestige but it was revenue from bundled, mostly low cost content that made the business profitable. Classified advertising was particularly valuable because newspapers charged high rates and had to do no information gathering to fill those pages of the paper. Classified advertisers paid to show ads, and some newspaper buyers purchased the whole bundle just to see those ads. Craigslist was therefore the first big blow against the old newspaper revenue model. If Google News didn't exist, I believe that some other system would have further eroded the newspaper revenue model. Maybe it would be Reddit's news subreddits, Wikipedia's Current Events portal, or a lightweight "CraigsNews" aggregator. In any case, global discovery and reach online mean that most regional news organizations have fewer, less valuable eyeballs to advertise to than they did in the 20th century. Google gets blamed because it indexes news and has a lot of money. I don't think that Google has a lot of money because it indexes news. If Google shut down Google News and deindexed every news site, the news organization revenue problem would probably not be any better 5 years from now. The economic inefficiencies and geographic barriers of the 20th century news system produced a few positive externalities that people miss now. Legislators could try to directly fund news from taxes but they can't make people buy a newspaper to get weather forecasts again.
- aww_dang 6y agoAgreed. This money will only go to the publishers that Google features. Thereby further subsidizing establishment voices. News.google.com has gone downhill over the past decade. I almost never visit this site anymore. All of the suggested articles are irrelevant to me. Especially the entertainment and 'technology' subheadings. The older site allowed for more personalization.