3 ms·
> There is no such thing in general as "too many people for the economy". Sure there is. If nothing else, at some point you have more people than can be physic
by roenxi 6y ago
> There is no such thing in general as "too many people for the economy".
Sure there is. If nothing else, at some point you have more people than can be physically fed with the available land.
Each additional person uses up a certain amount of resources. If the marginal resource gain of adding another worker is smaller than that; then economically there are too many people. There is no principle saying that cannot happen.
- brazzy 6y agoI did explicitly explain that the economy can be bottlenecked on other things (which is where that "in general" comes from) and why the one that seems to apply in the case of Japan has nothing to do with there being too many people.
- chii 6y ago> If nothing else, at some point you have more people than can be physically fed with the available land. The malthusian argument has been used since the old ages to argue for fewer people because of resource shortages (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism#Modern_Malthusianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism#Modern_Malthusia...). It has not eventuated. The more people there are, the more minds there are at looking for solutions to problems, the more able the human race will be. But of course, these people need investment to obtain benefit - they can't just be empty mouths to feed.
- roenxi 6y agoWhat is the argument there, that I can't point to Japan as an example of Malthusianism because you don't believe in Malthusianism? There is a physical limit somewhere. Just because we didn't find it in the last hundred years doesn't mean we won't in the future. Real growth in % terms eventually stops because it hits a physical limit; that isn't a controversial idea. It is almost too obvious to state. Humanity can't maintain 1% Year-on-year growth in crop yield indefinitely. At some point; the improvements stop. The longer the improvements have been going on for the more likely it is they will stop.
- brazzy 6y agoYes (and you can take that argument to deliciously absurd levels by pointing out that eventually humanity would have to form a sphere whose radius expands faster than light speed). But concerning the actual topic at hand, Japan's labor market problems have nothing whatsoever to do with a resource or land shortage.
- roenxi 6y agoThey probably have something to do with that. At the moment, for Japan has a tiny handful of iron mines [0]. So if they want to produce a steel widget, they have to justify someone transporting the iron either through the Chinese mainland or up the coast, past a lot of people who are learning to do wonderful things with steel. They import a lot of coal from Australia but China has relatively easy access overland from provinces like Inner Mongolia. I'm not sure how much of an advantage they gain from having very easy port access by virtue of being an island (probably quite a big one, I assume). But it is hard to accept they wouldn't be having a much easier time if they had easy access to something like the Saudi oil fields, the US oil fields, the Chinese coal fields, etc etc. They are a long way away from the good sources of natural resources. And they struggle to be self sufficient in food in the first result I found [1]. That is pretty different from somewhere like the US. There is a real risk of war in East Asia, so I imagine they'd be quite uncomfortable with that. They have completely different resource-use problems than the economies that are larger than they are. The idea that the US would have to exert itself to be self sufficient in food is rather weird, as is the idea that China would struggle to justify transporting resources to the country from Mongolia, etc. It is obvious to me what could be done with more people in the US or China. In Japan there is probably something, but it does require actual ability to find instead of just "dig more, grow more, build more, forge more" that their competitors for the best-economy crown can manage. Japan needs transformative technological improvements to grow. The US needs warm bodies. China needed to stop the Great Leap Forward and put competent leaders in charge. The Japanese challenge is much greater. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mines_in_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mines_in_Japan [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture,_forestry,_and_fishing_in_Japan#Land_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture,_forestry,_and_fis...
- inglor_cz 6y agoWell, water shortages in some places are coming dangerously close to the Malthusian problem eventuating. Drought has contributed to the Syrian civil war and Egypt threatened Ethiopia with war over their megadamming project on the Blue Nile. Places like Yemen have an order of magnitude more people than in 1950 while relying on the same water resources. This is not an easy problem to solve, water is too heavy to transport in significant amounts to places like Sanaa (elevation 7000 ft, over a million people, mild desert climate).