6 ms·
Paying ransomware demands could land you in hot water with the feds
- Avtomatk 6y agoGreat, now with the same logic the US Treasury Department should impose fines on parents who want to pay the ransom for their kidnapped children, because obviously (paying the ransom) benefits and promotes the illicit objectives of the kidnappers... Jesus Christ. Anyone have any reasonable explanation for this? Wouldn't it be better to fine companies that don't have a security standard for their data? edit: An example with apples: Jhon is a guy who does not care about the security of his company and does not create backups, suddenly he receives a ransomware attack and all his data is now encrypted, he has no option but to pay the ransom or all his intellectual property will be unusable , so he pays, and since he paid the criminals, he also pays a fine for incentivizing ransomware ... At the end of the day nothing was fixed and the ransomware groups are happier than ever. In a parallel universe we have an improved system, here it is regulated that all companies have either a backup of their information or a very robust system without back doors. Here Jhon also does not care about the security of his company, then it is discovered that Jhon does not have a backup copy and he is fined, Jhon pays and is forced to improve the security of his company, then he does it, then he receives an attack of ransomware, but Jhon refuses to pay because his company already has better security ... At the end of the day Jhon paid a fine, but the ransomware teams didn't get what they wanted, the problem was fixed here.
- viraptor 6y agoNot the same logic. At least not until we can recover kids from backups.
- NeutronStar 6y agoWhy haven't you produced a DNA backup of your kids yet?
- Avtomatk 6y agoOh yes, all companies have backups. I think you didn't understand the point.
- viraptor 6y agoNot all companies have backups, but it's not possible to check this at scale. You can't verify everyone's software environment and verify that the DR plans actually work. Also some cases don't care about data loss - there are areas where you can repave everything and ignore the incident happened. Where it's actually required, we already have checks like PCI-DSS, data retention laws, government policies, etc. and you'll be audited. But again - this is very selective to make it realistic. Can you imagine there's a government entity which can come to your independent company at any point and say "show us your recent backups, how you restore it, and validate it's complete"? There's no way anyone would agree to this, or fund it. What we know is that backups are the lowest barrier and if you don't have them for data you're prepared to pay for, you are pretty much sponsoring the ransomware business.
- xoa 6y ago>Oh yes, all companies have backups. I think you didn't understand the point. I assume you're using sarcasm in the first part there, but that in turn it's you who aren't getting the point. All companies may not have backups, but all companies could have backups. And the industry as a whole could be taking far more measures to mitigate ransomware, it's not some impossible problem. As well as prevention measures, ransomware is quite detectable actively because it necessarily changes the entropy of stored data in extremely obvious ways that a watchdog could detect. Or there could just be automated systems that constantly sample backups and verify they're restorable. If companies don't do that and choose to externalize some of the costs onto society (by funding criminals who will go on to hurt others in this case) it's completely appropriate for government to step in and stop them. There are lots of situations where people and organizations are expected to exercise reasonable diligence or face the consequences. In contrast, at least for now backing up humans is not in fact an option. People aren't being lazy or failing to make reasonable efforts by failing to back themselves or their dependents up because that just doesn't exist. It's not the "same logic" at all, and how you made the mental leap of equating perfectly reproducible digital data with children is a real question.
- TP4Cornholio 6y agoHuman life and children in particular are also much more valuable than data.
- viraptor 6y agoYes. Exactly. But if we could recover them from backups, they would be just about the same.
- labster 6y agoThat depends on what the kidnappers do with their copy of the brain. I wouldn’t be happy if there was a copy of me forced to listen to Coldplay 24/7.
- Avtomatk 6y agoIt is an example, I am not comparing children with data.
- desdiv 6y ago>the US Treasury Department should impose fines on parents who want to pay the ransom for their kidnapped children Some countries does actually criminalize paying ransom for kidnapped children. The logic being that if society make it harder to pay ransoms (both via criminalization and strong currency controls at the bank), then less kidnappers will get paid, which leads to less kidnapped children (hopefully). The vast majority of people in this thread probably disagree with such a law. I certainly do. But on the other hand I realize that if I had been born in one of these countries and lived there my whole life, I would probably be a fervent defender of such a law.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoFrom my cursory reading of the topic, three is basically no precedent for jailing such ransom-paying parent, and securing a conviction with a jury is very unlikely
- desdiv 6y agoYes, I should probably clarify: the point of such a law is to _discourage_ the behavior, but not to actually _punish_ the ransom payer, since no jury is going to vote on putting grieving parents in jail. So you end up deterring ransom payments without actually introducing negative externalities.
- jart 6y agoThe Hacker News vocal minority gives off this vibe that they'd rather have something like the fda stop by at your office each week with an inspector who logs into the backup system and checks off boxes if your local tech union is complying with the regulations. I feel like I'm going to gag.
- bigbubba 6y agoI believe paying ransoms for people already is illegal, at least in circumstances where the payment would be going to terrorist organizations. I'm under the impression this is the case in both the US and UK.
- csense 6y ago> with the same logic the US Treasury Department should impose fines on parents who want to pay the ransom for their kidnapped children, because obviously (paying the ransom) benefits and promotes the illicit objectives of the kidnappers This is actually sound logic. If 90% of parents pay ransom, kidnappers will kidnap a hundred kids a year. 90 will come home whole, 10 will have their fingers, toes, eyeballs, and various other body parts mailed home one per week in plastic baggies, or whatever unpleasant fate awaits kidnap victims who can't come up with their ransom. Then what happens if we make ransom illegal, and we have the police watching the bank accounts of kidnapped kids' families like hawks so usually even if parents try to flout the law, the police can successfully freeze a transfer before the funds get to the kidnappers? In that case kidnappers will kidnap three or four kids, most likely none of the parents will pay. Those kids will be horribly murdered, but then the kidnappers will decide it's not profitable and give up. Horrible if you're the parent of one of the 3 kids, especially if you end up in jail for trying to save your child's life. But from a standpoint of social policy, having 3 kids get horribly murdered and then no more is a way, way better outcome for society as a whole than having 10 kids a year get horribly murdered, plus 90 kids a year get kidnapped and their parents have to pay ransom. The problem is the 3 kids that actually get murdered have names and faces and sad / angry / incarcerated parents. The 7 kids a year who were saved from coming home in baggies, and the 90 kids a year who were saved from being kidnapped but ransomed, and the 90 sets of parents who weren't impoverished paying a giant ransom when their kids were kidnapped? They're statistical and unknowable. I suppose it's a variant of the trolley problem: Is it ethical to save a specific person whose name and face you know, if by doing so you're condemning to death many others, whose identities are currently completely unknown since they will be randomly chosen at a future date? You could also make an argument in the other direction from individual rights. Society shouldn't sanction a person who's trying to save a family member being directly threatened with death, even if their actions indirectly cause the deaths of many others. The right to protect your family is important and should be protected. I guess it depends on whether you have a utilitarian perspective (3 dead kids is better than 10 dead kids full stop) or a rights-based perspective (you always have a right to protect the life of a threatened family member full stop.)
- luckylion 6y ago
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y ago> Anyone have any reasonable explanation for this? Wouldn't it be better to fine companies that don't have a security standard for their data? Well, your second question is basically impossible to do, as "security standards" are a constantly evolving landscape and being compliant with whatever the latest certification will not necessarily prevent you from being hacked. Also, it is much more difficult and expensive and potentially unconstitutional to enforce such a law, whereas enforcing a law that requires companies not to transfer money to certain countries or organizations is comparatively easier. It's also easier tell which side of the bright line any given action is on. The explanation for the law is obvious and you seem to know it from the previous paragraph so I'm not sure what the question is. Is it controversial? For sure. Is it without any logic? By your own admission, there is an argument to be made.
- Avtomatk 6y agoIn my comment above I talked about applying security standards or backups, I see that forcing companies to have backups is more viable... To better understand my point of view, read my example above and the comment of "luckylion ". Companies are simply not going to report because their intellectual property becomes more valuable than the ransom payment. This law does not mitigate anything, instead a backup regulation would mitigate the problem (because it would not be necessary to pay the ransom, if you need such explicit help to understand things).
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoAll this will do is incite lawsuits against the feds
- vmception 6y agoYou’d be surprised what gets awarded in the Court of Federal Claims. Odd to me that it doesn't make the news cycle. The logic is simple: If fed caused loss, then get paid It could be the most esoteric or even antiquated status quo regulation, just go argue it
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sergefaguet 6y agoAnyone with a modicum of sense will just ignore these laws and act in accordance with their best judgment. History is full of examples of bullshit regulations.
- austincheney 6y agoAll the comments so far seem incredibly hostile to this idea so I will play devils advocate. * Paying a ransom is literally facilitating a criminal enterprise which is already illegal in almost all other aspects in most of the world. * In a ransomware attack there is no guaranteed assurance the criminal enterprise will restore the data once paid, because this an unreported expenditure to a criminal party. * Legally compelling parties to cooperate with law enforcement provides addition investigative materials for future law enforcement investigations. * The more frequently reported a crime becomes the more investigative attention it receives with increased investigative budget. Federal investigators aren’t compelled to take this problem seriously so long as it is drastically under reported. * The Justice Department is compelled to criminalize ransomware payments as a consumer protection, because the loss of data ultimately hurts the impacted consumers most.
- trhway 6y ago>* Paying a ransom is literally facilitating a criminal enterprise which is already illegal in almost all other aspects in most of the world. giving your wallet when you're being robbed at the gun point falls into that category too. And if the robbery proceeds are used for buying drugs, how about charging you with drug financing?
- austincheney 6y agoThe differentiator is immediacy of choice. Putting a gun to your head isn’t there for your benefit of choice. It’s there so that the criminal is liable for robbery instead of a capital crime, because they could more easily kill you and take the wallet off your body.
- rightbyte 6y agoA better analogy would be the police buying back the wallet from the robber over postorder.
- dannyw 6y ago1. It's possible for the advantages of restoring data to outweigh the societal cost of facilitating a criminal enterprise. For example, a patient has died in a hospital due to a ransomware attack. Would you prioritise saving human lives over sending some Bitcoin to some malware writer? 2. While there's no guarantee, it is exceedingly demonstrated that if you pay the ransom, you will get your data back. Ransomware writers have a collective reputation to uphold (strange, huh), and a typical negotiation involves requesting decryption of a few files to prove this capability exists. 3. Parties can legally comply with law enforcement AND pay a ransom (see #1 and #2). When paid with bitcoin, it leaves a strong and permanent evidence trail, especially with Bitcoin de-mixing techniques discovered all the time. 4. The solution to your problem is mandatory and visible disclosure of security breaches, you do not need to criminalise paying ransoms to get here; nor does it achieve as much as a broad "obligation to disclose". 5. By criminalising ransomware payments, the Justice Department has already made hundreds of corporations criminals. We know this Justice Department is known for selective prosecution: it is entirely plausible, if not likely, for companies against the current political party (e.g. donations to other candidates) to receive enhanced scrutiny and criminal charges. Point 5 is not "conspiracy theory": we know the Qwest CEO was arrested on selectively enforced "insider trading" charges because he refused to spy on his customers for the NSA.
- cortesoft 6y agoThis is a really good example of both a prisoner's dilemma (more precisely a collective action problem), and a common way to try to overcome the suboptimal equilibrium that a prisoner's dilemma naturally ends up in. Society as a whole will be better off if no one pays the ransom. If truly no one paid, ransom attacks would end. However, if you are attacked by a ransom attack, your best individual course of action is likely to pay; your paying or not (as an individual) isn't going to be the deciding factor in the ransom industry continuing, and the ransom is likely cheaper than the cost of not paying. The rational response as an individual is to pay. You therefore end up with a suboptimal overall situation, even though everyone is making the rational choice. One way to break out of the prisoner's dilemma is to place an outside cost on 'defecting' from the socially optimal choice; in this case, the government announces loudly that they will fine companies more than their losses if they pay. The idea is to shift the equilibrium to not paying a ransom being the logical choice, which will, in the long run, will put an end to ransoms. Of course, it really sucks for the people caught by ransom attacks in the meantime, and requires consistent and predictable enforcement of the outside penalty.
- longadeseo 6y agoindeed. however the single biggest area is when lower it companies choose to skimp and get pwned.. paying 50k is better than filing chapter 13 even if the govt charges you another 25k pound of flesh.
- ComodoHacker 6y ago>the government announces loudly that they will fine companies more than their losses if they pay. No, they do it to enforce sanctions, not to break out of the prisoner's dilemma. Criminals not connected with sanctioned subjects will happily continue their ransom attacks, now that the government has crippled their most capable rivals.
- spurdoman77 6y agoOr the sanctioned individuals just set up a new identity.
- 6y ago
- Oricle 6y agoWho do you think sets them ransom demands up? Lol. Talk about problem, reaction, solution! That's how it All works! And everyone goes along with it. Idiots, which is a Greek word for people who do not understand or follow polotics. All Greeks knew what was going on more due to them paying attention and understanding that polotics is involved in everything g you and others do. Today, your just all dump has a block of ice! True idiots today, who like to think of people back then as stupid! Oh, the irony!
- ozim 6y agoBasically it will be an issue if a company wants to pay ransom and keep it secret. Which is really reasonable and probably if authorities won't be able to help you and last option will be paying it is not going to be a problem. "OFAC will also consider a company’s self-initiated, timely, and complete report of a ransomware attack to law enforcement to be a significant mitigating factor in determining an appropriate enforcement outcome if the situation is later determined to have a sanctions nexus."
- hexbinencoded 6y agoTested, offsite, cold backups Fully-automated deployment Never pay ... ransomware becomes moot
- fludlight 6y agoRansomers also threaten to post the unencrypted data on the internet.
- cm2187 6y agoBut you will have paid twice as much in heavy infrastructure and staff. For small companies, what we really need is built in ways of doing daily versioning in the popular NAS solution they use.
- jart 6y agoIf you're a small business just put your data in the cloud dude. For example if you use online email services then a robot will put your data on a tape cassette and a guy will load it on a truck and drive it to a mountain made of iron for free. Ryuk can't ransom that.
- ryanlol 6y agoYeah, because fuck your employees and customers. Right? Backups do nothing against contemporary ransomware attacks where the MO is to publish stolen information if the company doesn’t pay up. If you’re a hospital or say a school district “never pay” is simply an unconscionable attitude.
- rl3 6y agoWhy not just legalize the ransom payments? In a world where the IC was directed to fuck ransomware authors up, the money could be clawed back in most cases, or even fronted by the taxpayers as bait for CNE: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20971785 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20971785 Heck, foreign APTs probably already masquerade as ransomware profiteers.
- COVardsStayHome 6y agoI have a great fucking idea - keep the government away from it.
- WhyNotHugo 6y agoWhen a guy comes at me with a knife and asks for my money and my phone, I'd usually comply since I kinda dislike the idea of being stabbed. Isn't that also equally "enabling criminals"?