16 ms·
Looking at the experience of black Britons through an American lens
- waheoo 6y ago+1 from Australia. Our police kill more white people in custody per capita than black. I'm so over hearing about this bullshit here. The aboriginal people of Australia face real problems. The police isn't one of them. PS, keep your debates to yourselves too. Nobody cares and your media cutting Trump out of context is obvious and gross. You are literally becoming the fake news he always said you were.
- doctor_eval 6y agoRight, because there are 10x more aboriginal people in prison, that's not racist policing, that's just natural, is that what you're saying? “There is a sadly high level of Indigenous incarceration, I think it’s about 30% compared to 3% of the population,” Mitchell said, while interviewing the prime minister on Thursday. “But black deaths in custody, I mean, that’s, that’s a furphy, isn’t it? I mean, since the royal commission, as I saw it, there have been fewer Indigenous people, per head of prison population, dying in custody than have white people?” Morrison replied: “That is welcome news.” However, the death rate per prisoner is only part of the story. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are 10 times more likely to die in custody than non-Indigenous people in Australia." https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/deaths-inside-how-we-track-indigenous-deaths-in-custody-and-why-we-do-it https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/death...
- waheoo 6y agoNo, that isn't racist at all. Unfortunate, an injustice, a tragedy, a disaster, a systemic failure to integrate, yes. But racist? You're going to have to spell that one out for me. Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist. Thats a symptom of a problem that predates most of us sitting here in our armchairs. Talk about the real problem not the symptom, but whatever you do, don't start calling all white people racist for being nothing but white, all that does is alienate allies and make you look like a moron.
- doctor_eval 6y agoYeah, a tragic injustice that only happens to aboriginal people. If only we could do something. Edited to respond to your edits: > Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist. Unqualified statements asserting that a specific racial group "just commit more crime" is pretty much an applied definition of the word "racist". Isolated statistics about aboriginal behaviour used to buttress your assertion that you are not racist, just seem to underline the fact that perhaps you have much to learn. If you'd said, "statistically, aboriginal people commit more crime. Studies have shown that this is because of chronic health and economic issues which have never been adequately addressed by any Australian government", that would probably not be racist, but I'd want to defer to an aboriginal person before putting my neck out too far on that one either. One of the difficult things about racism is that it does not matter how we (ie, people of European descent) feel about it, but how the people we're talking about feel about it. > Thats a symptom of a problem that predates most of us sitting here in our armchairs What problem are you talking about? The problem that we invaded their land, shot them, stole their children, and to this day oppress them both economically and legally? > all that does is alienate allies and make you look like a moron No ally of mine is going to be alienated or offended by simple statements of truth.
- apexalpha 6y agoOne of the difficult things about racism is that it does not matter how we (ie, people of European descent) feel about it, but how the people we're talking about feel about it. For what it's worth you are doing the EXACT same thing the post in this article is about: you are pushing a very American view on racism. First of all, racism is absolutely not White -> Black. Or White -> Aboriginal. If you think that I'd assume you haven't met a lot of people form other parts of the world. Racism is everywhere and it's not a White-only issue. That's a very American view. Second of all, it absolutely DOES matter what 'we' (white people) think of it. Saying only people we talk about get to have a say in this is also a very American viewpoint. We really don't need to "defer to an aboriginal person", as you say. Just like this article states you are now assuming that all aboriginal people agree on this subject. Saying we aren't qualified to say what's racist but we need a minority for that is the kind of generalizations the article pushes against.
- HowFarFallen 6y agoWhy they commit crime at such higher rates than the White population would be an interesting conversation to have. Unfortunately, it seems as if you're implying that we shouldn't police them equally because of their race. I cannot endorse that, and I would urge you to consider their victims (most of whom are also Aboriginals, if they are your concern).
- doctor_eval 6y agoIf aboriginal people were policed equally, there wouldn't be a problem.
- wesleywt 6y ago-1 for Australia. Its a pretty racists country. And you forget FoxNews is a transplant of the Rupert Murdoch's empire that he established in Australia. Thier propaganda in support of Trump is obvious and gross. But you as an Australia probably grew up with this type of media surrounding you.
- fiblye 6y agoI don’t think trying to argue against racism while lumping an entire country of tens of millions of people together is productive.
- fastball 6y agoTFA is talking about racism as if it can be seen through the lens of how an entire nation feels about and handles racism, so that seems like a reasonable way of talking about it in this thread.
- remote_phone 6y agoThat’s what they’re doing with the US though.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post flamewar comments to HN. We don't want flamewars here, and you did it repeatedly in this thread. Not cool. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- throwaway23555 6y agoAre you able to comment about what's happening here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24652987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24652987 All of the comments are getting flagged and killed. I don't see any rule breaking.
- dang 6y ago1. Repeatedly creating accounts to circumvent bans is not ok. 2. Nothing good is going to come out of adding to that flamewar. 3. It crosses into personal attack, which is particularly not ok. 4. Please email hn@ycombinator.com with questions like this, rather than posting off-topic comments. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- waheoo 6y agoLol, correcting people taking me out of context and calling me racist is trying to start a flamewar? Ok dude?
- Kednicma 6y agoIn addition to the entirety of the author's examples and experiences, we need to recall that the UK/British view of race is heavily influenced by the fact that skin color is not the only way in which folks in the UK experience racial discrimination. For centuries, the Scottish and Irish natives have been variously oppressed by the British, creating a racial context which is distinct from one wholly concerned with skin tone. Not less racist, not more racist, just differently racist.
- gambiting 6y agoAmericans also conveniently forget that Irish people have been discriminated against there nearly as badly as black people, despite being the whitest shade of white. From the outside perspective, it seems like that kind of discrimination just doesn't fit the narrative so of course isn't mentioned.
- morelisp 6y ago> Americans also conveniently forget that Irish people have been discriminated against there OK. > nearly as badly as black people Nah, fuck off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_slaves_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_slaves_myth
- subsubsub 6y agoIn the last 10 years have a lot of Scottish, Irish or Black people been murdered by UK police officers? 20 years? 30? I'm sure you can think of a few examples, but the idea that the UK is equally as racist as the US is laughable. To be clear: I am not saying that racism doesn't exist in the UK or that it isn't a problem - but the kind of false equivalence you put forward doesn't really advance the conversation.
- dghf 6y ago> In the last 10 years have a lot of Scottish, Irish or Black people been murdered by UK police officers? 20 years? 30? How many people of any colour or ethnicity have been killed by UK police in the last 10, 20, 30 years? It doesn't happen very often, principally because they're not routinely armed. > I'm sure you can think of a few examples, but the idea that the UK is equally as racist as the US is laughable. In some ways, sure. But in other ways, the UK is behind the US: the UK has (and has had) no Black generals, admirals, or supreme court judges, for example.
- 3np 6y agoI have a strong feeling (though no data to back it up) that this holds at least as much for debate and polarisation around feminism, gender equality, trans rights and LGBT(Q+) issues.
- Tainnor 6y agoTo some extent maybe, but in some sense LGBTQ issues are a bit more universal, because LGBTQ people exist and have grown up in every country (they just have different visibility and different rights etc.), whereas with racism/xenophobia every country has their own, different pattern of immigration, social inequalities, etc.
- Macha 6y agoAlso because many of the issues that race presents in the US (historically marginalised/discriminated against groups having poor opportunities leading to poor outcomes leading to poor opportunities for their descendents) are present in those countries as class problems without the racial undertones.
- 3np 6y agoKind of like the article; I'm not saying other countries don't have systemic issues, just that they aren't equivalent to the issues in the US.
- rramadass 6y agoOh, there is a lot of data. You simply have to look at the uptick in the number of news reports from other countries dealing with the above subjects over a period of time. Now all of these are important but they are nowhere near as important as the discussion/outrage needed over poverty alleviation, social ills, economic development etc. in my country. A good example is the recent "Me too" movement. Our entire media jumped on this bandwagon while all other essential news disappeared from the channels. This is a great way to divert people's attention and hide actual problems.
- watwut 6y ago
- OwlsParlay 6y agoAmerican culture in general overrides local news. The debates are front-page news despite me having no vote or influence. Same with Trump's impeachment.
- gambiting 6y agoThe problem exists elsewhere too, because of the extremely widespread proliferation of American media - I see the Polish media taking american talking points about race, sexuality, religion, and just transplanting them wholesale into the Polish frame of reference as if they were equally important here - more often than not, they simply aren't. While racism is a problem in Poland, it's not a systematic racism like in the US, and treating it as if it was does more harm than good - we have to do better, but suddenly Polish people watching American news and for instance adopting "all cops are bastards" attitude is just dumb in so many ways I could probably write a whole article about it. In general I lament the americanization of worldwide media, as if America is some kind of paragon of behaviour that everyone should emulate, and whatever social phenomenon is happening there it must be valid elsewhere. That's simply not true.
- jacobush 6y agoI know very little about Poland, but can't help but see a similarity between attitudes to the former serfs in Poland and the Irish in Great Britain. This article touches on it: https://wachtyrz.eu/antisemitism-in-poland-each-pole-is-a-jew-too/ https://wachtyrz.eu/antisemitism-in-poland-each-pole-is-a-je...
- rramadass 6y ago>In general I lament the americanization of worldwide media, as if America is some kind of paragon of behaviour that everyone should emulate, and whatever social phenomenon is happening there it must be valid elsewhere. That's simply not true. Well said! I would wager that this has become true in almost all countries and the effects are very insidious. Many real problems are often obfuscated and sidelined by the latest media export from the US which has no or at best marginal relevance in their local countries.
- jtbayly 6y ago> Many real problems are often obfuscated and sidelined by the latest media export from the US which has no or at best marginal relevance in their local countries. Or in their local counties (in the US).
- nathias 6y agoI never even heard of anyone being as racist as americans are when trying not to be.
- vinay427 6y agoI really hope you mean today, as in people who are currently alive. Have you read about any history, perhaps including European colonization abroad?
- m1sta_ 6y agoWere they conquering because of race or something else?
- lordwarnut 6y agoWell they certainly used racism as an excuse to justify their colonial ambitions. They were conquering for the same reasons any country conquers: money, land, prestige.
- simonklitj 6y agoProbably money, but that doesn't exclude the obvious racism it created. In Denmark, we had Africans in cages displayed in the Tivoli amusement park in central Copenhagen, so people could look at the spectacle that was the black person (https://nyheder.tv2.dk/samfund/2017-03-31-de-sendte-bud-efter-to-negerboern-og-udstillede-dem-i-bur-i-tivoli https://nyheder.tv2.dk/samfund/2017-03-31-de-sendte-bud-efte..., in Danish). While this was not the intent of our colonization and slavery-business, it inevitably caused it, imo. Or, the racism caused the success of colonialism, because it justified it.
- throwaway11291 6y ago> Probably money, but that doesn't exclude the obvious racism it created. This! In history, a lot of racism has been created to justify wars, economical exploitation, slavery, creating political scapegoats and so on. Demonizing an enemy is the most basic method to polarize people. This type of "psyops" was extremely common during WW2. People often don't really want to look at the root of racial, ethnic, political discrimination because it has to do with economic and political power.
- jacobush 6y agoAnd I think probably Americans could sometimes do well to stop imposing American views about Race on themselves.
- raziel2p 6y agoI think one of the reasons this simplification is happening, is that nuance generally has failed to gain traction in the past. A large part of why the far right / racist movement has grown a lot the past 20 years or so is that their narrative is so simple: "Immigrants have higher crime rates and we're taking in more immigrants, which is bad." Fighting this with nuance and trying to say that statistics is more complicated than that hasn't worked. I would say that the public education system needs a complete overhaul to fix this (critical thinking, media literacy and such), but even if that were to happen, it would take 20-30 years. Also, in the end, I don't think these type of views causes that much harm. Okay, so a group of people end up being "fake" anti-racists, but it's still raising awareness and it might cause people to make slightly different choices in their day-to-day lives. This isn't comparable to Kony 2012 where people changed their profile picture on Facebook for literally no effect.
- throwawayinfo 6y ago> Immigrants have higher crime rates and we're taking in more immigrants, which is bad. This statement isn't the issue. What is an issue is that the establishment isn't willing to have a real discussion on this topic (illegal immigration, cultural dilution, economic benefits, etc...). The rise of far right and far left rhetoric is an expected response to the status quo, where people feel pushed into opposing tribes.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoWell, it makes sense that these views (which are generally unexamined by those who repeat them) are catching on outside of America for the same reason they catch on inside America: fixating on a simplistic target is alluring, people saying nonsensical things they don't really believe in order to avoid being called racist, etc. You could make the same points inside America as well that the article makes, like examining Nigerian success in America. Keep trotting the article out and you have a case for why these racial essentialist views shouldn't be imposed on anyone, not just brits. And certainly not on our children.
- lewispollard 6y ago> All the individuals listed are American, but most of the people who have shared this on my timeline are British. In trying to express their solidarity with black Britons Aren't they trying to express their solidarity with black Americans? Just because it's happening outside of your country of residence, doesn't mean your compassion and empathy ends at the border.
- meiraleal 6y agoMaybe because it was Britain that started all this mess with slavery and human trafficking, so Britons should indeed try to repent, or some day face the wrath of the whole world.
- jl6 6y agoBritain did more to end slavery than to start it (though it did also benefit greatly from it in between).
- meiraleal 6y agoThat's probably what makes you feel better, but nope, your kingdom was built through exploitation, killing and looting.
- vixen99 6y agoYou forgot to mention rape. I'm told that 1 in 200 people on this planet can claim genetic heritage with Ghenghis Khan. That happened via rape together with the 'exploitation, killing and conquest' but no one in their right mind wishes to visit this mind-numbing inglorious fact on his descendants and not just because that would be impossible. Who knows? Maybe you and I are one of those descendants. Familiarity with world history will tell you that there are no groups of superior beings anywhere who abstained from the activities mentioned. Some won and some lost. The latter, not for the want of trying.
- m1sta_ 6y agoNah mate. You need to keep reading.
- vergessenmir 6y agoI'm not sure that american views are being imposed on US (I'm in the UK). Rather they are being adopted by us without criticism. This makes conversation about race a confused jumbled incoherent mess. The bigger problem as I see it is more class-oriented than race centric. This should be a discussion on social mobility, which in my opinion is the best in the western world for minority communities. The race discourse in recent years has distracted from improving social mobility and hurting said communities more.
- luckylion 6y agoI believe the author didn't mean to say that the US imposes the views, but that the UK media and elites do. The same is true in Germany to a large degree, and it's equally weird. Americanization of everything is a good description, I think. Of course it's very important what happens in the US, it's the heart of the empire after all. But it's given so much weight that I sometimes feel like our media are covering US domestic politics more than our domestic politics.
- ahartmetz 6y agoUS politics is good soap opera material. The thinking person's celebrity gossip.
- secondcoming 6y agoAdopted or pushed? The BBC is fully on board with importing the US leftist narrative.
- optimalsolver 6y agoNot surprising. Just look at what they named themselves.
- secondcoming 6y agolol
- 6y ago
- Tainnor 6y agoThere's a general sense in which all the social justice debates are always filtered through a US american lens, probably because of the media presence and because the people leading these debates are more active in global online communities. But it does feel to me that often we frame the discourse in a way that is not useful for the specific problems we have in a specific country/region. There was some of the ACAB sentiment in Germany, but it quickly died down, since most people here (even left-wing people) generally trust the police - and while I'm sure there are still problems with underrepresentation, racial profiling, etc., it's nowhere on the scale that it appears to be on the US. Also most countries simply don't have a recent history of slavery inside their own country like the US does; black people in Germany, for example, are almost all immigrants, which does create entirely different dynamics, and we have (had) a lot more immigration from different cultures, especially Turkish people. None of this means racism and xenophobia don't exist, but the discourse and potential solutions are not the same as in the US.
- emXdem 6y agoTotally different... in that firebombing and violence did not occur? https://www.refworld.org/docid/469f388ec.html https://www.refworld.org/docid/469f388ec.html
- xondono 6y agoI’m going to pull an unimaginable outside-of-the-box thinking for these times and propose something: if people want to be doctors and not actors, let them do what they want to do. I’m getting very tired of this US mania with nudging everyone to their preferred outputs.
- HowFarFallen 6y ago>I have privilege as a White person because I can do all of these things without thinking twice about it … I can go jogging (#AmaudArbery). I can relax in the comfort of my own home (#BothemSean and #AtatianaJefferson). I can ask for help after being in a car crash (#Jonathan Ferrell and #RenishaMcBride). I can have a cellphone (#StephonClark). I can leave a party to get to safety (#JordanEdwards). I can play loud music (#JordanDavis). I can sell CDs (#AltonSterling). I can sleep (#AiyanaJones). I can walk from the corner store (#MikeBrown). Who really says this? Michael Brown could've had a regular visit to the store too. Instead, he chose to brazenly steal whatever he wanted and waltzed out despite the owner's protestations, strutted down the middle of the street with his stolen goods, wrestled a pistol from the attending police officer and discharged a shot in the struggle, and then - having made a little distance in his getaway - chose to turn around and charge at the officer even as he demanded cooperation. Arbery could've had a pleasant jog too. Instead he chose to enter a stranger's house, flee when confronted by concerned neighbours, and very nearly wrestle away his firearm - and we all know how that would've ended - creating a life or death situation for the good Samaritan. Why, if this is such a terrible phenomenon, must we lie to create martyrs? I don't even disagree with the scourge of brutality, especially having seen a 17 year old White boy shot and killed by police today in a welfare check. But why is it so common in the BLM movement to rally behind violent criminals on the receiving end of justifiable responses? I understand the black incentives for doing so, but why are Whites perpetuating these myths so enthusiastically? Why aren't they rioting for the White victims instead of (or at the very least, as well as) these black thugs?
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoIt's an (american) election year, so that would explain most of the politics and propaganda behind that.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoUnfortunately it's been going on for a long time. For example, why was OJ Simpson's verdict met with adulation when everyone knew he was guilty? That's the first thing that popped in my head when I read their last paragraph about lying to ourselves, though I admit I just listened to a podcast where Sam Harris or John McWhorter bring OJ up: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPHUu9sAGKo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPHUu9sAGKo ("Sam Harris' podcast: The New Religion of Anti_Racism")
- jl6 6y ago+1 for the plea for nuance, consideration and rational discussion.
- pritovido 6y agoBritain is not America. In some ways is worse. Britain made lots of money for centuries from two main sources: 1. Piracy. 2. Slavery trade. It is very interesting that they critizice S
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 6y agoI don't know where US Americans got the idea about social justice and all these tangential topics related to it. In my view the result is that social justice nearly stands for race segregation, inclusion and diversity is almost synomymous with banning outsiders and heretics, methods of societal analysis lead to the worst kind of dogmatism. At first I honestly thought the teachings of some proponents were to troll in the original sense of the word, but they were completely serious about it. 'Social justice' is far better than 'justice' in my opinion, but it can never be an argument to demand solidarity because that will inevitably lead to totalitarianism. The "classical" US citizen that proudly swings their flag, shoots holes in the sky and idolizes freedom is a much more attractive alternative.
- 082349872349872 6y ago"Solidarity" is a big thing in my country, even on the centre right, yet we still get high marks (9+) from the Economist's Democracy Index. Wang fo kowmang unte kowmang fo wang. Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3qaA6FdAUsk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3qaA6FdAUsk (imposing the writers' inaccurate views about agriculture on us)
- netcan 6y agoAmerican cultural influence has always been substantial, but since Trump and the hyper-interesting reality TV politics of recent years... it's on a hole new level. Here (in Ireland), the Brexit show (slightly receding) and Trump show have eclipsed local politics by a long shot. ROI politics are a distant fourth (after NI), in terms of affecting the local political conversation. It has become truly absurd. The average person can name far more politicians in the US or UK than locally.
- Macha 6y agoI think it depends on your social circles. Recent Irish politicians my experience is that most people know: Michael D, Leo Varadkar, Micheal Martin, Mary Lou, Simon Coveney, Phil Hogan, Paul Murphy, Ming Recent UK politicians my experience is that most people know: Boris Johnson, Theresa May, Bercow, Arlene Foster, Jeremy Corbyn Recent US politicians that most people know: Trump, Hilary Clinton, Ted Cruz, Joe Biden, Obama People who follow politics more closely might also know Irish politications like Simon Harris or Stephen Donnelly, Eamon Ryan or their local TDs, UK politicians like Gove, Rees-Mogg and Nicola Sturgeon, and US politicians like AOC or Mitch McConnell. And of course you get people who look way more closely into politics with a much broader view of things or much deeper for a specific country. But also in terms of potential impact on Ireland, the reality is that the order is: 1. COVID-19 2. Brexit 3. Anything else the coalition government is likely to get passed. So it's not surprising that Brexit and consequently UK politics have had such an outsized influence these past few years.
- netcan 6y agoThere is a practical aspect to it, but a lot of it is pure drama. Yes, Brexit affects us. Brexit was also extremely dramaful. I agree that it depends on social circles, but IMO, Boris or Trump animate much stronger & livelier opinions than Leo or Martin. Moreover, they can probably identify their political positions on more issues.
- goto11 6y agoThe American brand of racism is very much obsessed about skin color. Historically European racism is quite different. The Nazis were deeply racist, but didn't care much about skin color in particular - they hated and murdered Slavs and Jews and Roma, groups not identified by skin color. Europe have to acknowledge and engage with this horrible past, but things like obsessing about the Dutch "Zwarte Piet" tradition is totally missing the point IMHO.
- thinkingemote 6y agoThis will get flagged when most of the US wake up, or when users get fed up with yet another cultural war submission that leads to flame.
- bregma 6y agoAre you saying being woken will not make you woke?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- drumhead 6y agoAdele, the singer, was photographed at the Nottinghill Carnival (a massive Carribean street festival over the August bank holiday in London) with her hair in Bantu Knots and wearing a bikini top in the colours of the Jamaican flag. As soon as it was on twitter the you started getting tweets from Black Americans about cultural appropriation, but this was met in turn by fierce opposition from African and Carribean posters from the Uk and Africa who thought she looked great and were incredibly pissed off at the Americans for appointing themselves the global arbiters of what parts of African or Carribean culture were allowed or not allowed to be used by non-Africans or Carribeans. They found the proscriptions to be silly or highanded behaviour. Cultural appropriation doesnt seem to be a problem anywhere else but the USA.
- apexalpha 6y ago"Cultural appropriation doesnt seem to be a problem anywhere else but the USA." This is usually referred to as cultural exchange or sharing of culture. The fact that cultures shouldn't be shared is indeed a new phenomenon, one that I personally don't agree with.
- thiht 6y agoYeah, because cultural appropriation is not a thing. It doesn't make any sense.
- dkdbejwi383 6y agoAs a British person with Caribbean family background, I found the reaction to this from the internet so strange. In Britain it's normal that the different cultures here mix. Shops selling Baltic bread, next to shops selling jerk chicken, across the road from a traditional English pub. People of all colours and backgrounds frequenting all of them. From an outside perspective, people in the USA seem very pre-occupied with continuing a culture of segregation, where black and white people live different lives and mixing is frowned upon. I see this attitude on both sides.
- somerandobrit 6y agoExactly, compare the prison systems: America’s is segregated by race. You can’t mix with the other race or borrow something from them, or even sit on their table. In Britain the races mix, there’s no strict segregation, if there is any, it’s more segregated by town and county and areas.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mothsonasloth 6y agoI used to think Britain and the USA had a dominant but equal share in exporting culture since the 50s. We had the Beatles, they had Elvis. We had Jaguars, they had Mustangs. (this is deliberately simplified example) However the internet has made everything smaller and the dominant force in tech is in the USA. Sure there are spikes in influence of Asian and other cultures (Gangam K-pop etc.) but most of it gets churned out from celebs, artists, influencers, bloggers, writers and thinkers in the liberal east and west coasts. Do we all want to hear what these people have to say, no, but when everyone else is wanting to follow them then it becomes easier to be influenced directly or indirectly. The last cultural influence that stood in opposition to "Western culture", was communism, but that died on 1990 with the first McDonald's in Moscow. Sure the idea of communism isn't dead; you might see a few random people still promote it online or outside a shopping centre with a shabby looking stall, but these people are seen as weird or uncool (communism isn't cool btw). So back to the topic, do we just want to be cool, is BLM cool, will it be forgotten, after the main proponents find another flag to wave? Are we all just inadvertently programmed to consume and conform due to our DNA and society by those at the top, or do we risk being an outcast by going against them? What happens when China takes the reigns as a new culture to oppose and compete with this idea of "Americanized Western Culture"? Will we eventually have a Blade Runner like culture with a Chinese European blend in the future? Will we all homogenise in the end? Will I see someone in the Amazonas eating KFC and wearing Adidas just like the person in the township in Johannesburg? I don't know the answer.
- 082349872349872 6y ago> communism isn't cool btw These communists might beg to differ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPeLF-qi6X0&t=11 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPeLF-qi6X0&t=11 (but tbh they're nominally communists in a country with billionaires, hedge funds, and retail investors, while the nominally capitalist US is a surveillance state doing its utmost to pursue industrial policy with public means, so I'm not sure how one is supposed to be able to tell the difference anymore. That's part of why I've decided, for my own idiolect, to use Eastasia and Oceania, respectively.) Edit: I guess they'd say 牛逼 instead of cool. Maybe 酷?
- spdionis 6y ago
- DanBC 6y agoA mostly good article. > There has, for example, been a lot of concern about the underrepresentation of black Britons in professions like the arts and publishing. But why would you choose to go into theater or journalism—rather than law, medicine or finance—if you are a talented child of ambitious but not well off immigrants? A really weird point. There's plenty of concern about under-representation of black people in law, and medicine, and finance. In law there is a lot of effort spent getting more black lawyers and judges into the system, and we've recently seen the experience of Alexandra Wilson who was mistaken for a defendant at least 3 times in one day in her place of work. https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/investigation-launched-after-black-barrister-mistaken-for-defendant/5105752.article https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/investigation-launched-aft... In healthcare we have NHSWRES (NHS Workforce Race Equality Standard) who are trying to increase representation in NHS exec and non-exec teams. > In a country in which black people make up only three percent of the population, for example, six percent of junior doctors are black. They got this information from here: https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/workforce-and-business/workforce-diversity/nhs-workforce/latest#by-ethnicity https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/workforce... If we're looking at racism we don't want to compare junior doctors with journalists. We want to compare junior doctors to consultants and senior leaders. We also want to compare the different levels of junior doctors to each other to see if the ratio of black:white doctors changes. https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/workforce-and-business/workforce-diversity/nhs-workforce/latest https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/workforce... > a higher percentage of junior doctors were from the Black, Chinese, Mixed and Other groups than senior doctors We can see that 6.2% of junior doctors are black, but only 3.5% of consultants are black. Where did all those juniors go?
- henrikschroder 6y ago> We can see that 6.2% of junior doctors are black, but only 3.5% of consultants are black. Where did all those juniors go? If 3% of the population is black, then having 3.5% of consultants being black means they're still overrepresented! Regression to the mean is the most likely explanation.
- Macha 6y ago
- cirrus-clouds 6y agoTo add some numbers to this debate - the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) published a survey (Nov 2018) that examined the experiences of almost 6,000 people of African descent in 12 EU Member States. The report includes survey results from Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Malta, Portugal, Sweden and the UK. It paints a varied picture across the countries surveyed. Summary of weighted results across all surveyed countries (taken from the report): https://imgur.com/a/gcHR5dk https://imgur.com/a/gcHR5dk Full report: Being Black in the EU: https://fra.europa.eu/en/publication/2018/being-black-eu https://fra.europa.eu/en/publication/2018/being-black-eu News report from the BBC: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-46369046 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-46369046
- phatfish 6y agoI'm pretty sure this correlates heavily to the size of the black population in each country. The UK having the largest and most well integrated black population shows in the lower instances of reported harassment. This rings true for me, certainly there is disenfranchisement and other forms of racism, but outright harassment is not something you see often (saying this as a white person). Honestly I would expect Polish and other eastern Europeans to face more harassment. France I feel has a reasonably large black population but probably not as well integrated.
- pftburger 6y agoThe article briskly skips over the indisputable fact that Britain’s colonial expansion enslaved, tortured and exterminated people of color everywhere on this planet for longer than a the US has existed in its current form. It attempts to delegitimize the people in the ex-colonies claim to the wealth generated during their exploration using the currently drawn geopolitical boundaries. For most of the people labeled as immigrants by the author, tracing their lineage with direct link to suffering under colonialization is a direct formal requirement for immigration. To not acknowledge this comes across as massively tone deaf and makes the article read too much like denial of responsibility.
- hotz 6y agoJust to add, they also had white Afrikaans women and children in concentration camps in the Boer wars of South Africa. We can only learn from history and be better for it. People in general should stop crying about events that happened a hundred years or more ago. That's no way to live your life.
- lm2s 6y agoAs Rammstein said: We're all living in America.
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoDid you know that Rammstein is named after Ramstein, the biggest US military base in Germany?
- dingaling 6y agoThey're actually named that because of the air show crash at Ramstein involving the Italian Frecce Trcolori, not because of the base itself. 70 people were killed and over 300 wounded so it was a controversial & intentionally shocking name.
- 082349872349872 6y ago"I don't sing my mother's tongue"
- bloodorange 6y ago"Coca-Cola, sometimes war"
- 082349872349872 6y agoAt least we get sugar and not corn sweetener in our Coca-Cola :-) Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9nE2spOw_o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9nE2spOw_o
- zimablue 6y agoAnother key difference is that we don't have the right to own guns. Whether you're for or against gun rights you can't argue that they don't seem to incentivise more militarized police. Militarized police means that you get tragic and divisive police killings but I guess it also causes more general distance from and distrust of police. We also I don't think have the American civil war history and Jim Crow stuff, so it's not as much of a political football and the history of oppression diminishes MUCH earlier.
- somerandobrit 6y agoYou can illustrate this point by comparing prison systems. In America is segregated by race, blacks, whites, Mexicans etc. In the U.K all races mix, towns and counties may stick together more but that’s it.
- secondcoming 6y agoI'd be interesting to compare snapshot of upvotes/downvotes in this thread from between now and when the US gets out of bed. It'd a good measure of how much control the US has over other types of media.
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoTalking about bigotry in the UK without mentioning colonialism is a bit like talking about racism in the USA without mentioning slavery. Different history, different consequences, different present, different context. A few weeks back historian John Dolan pointed out that all the iconoclasm recently occurring in Britain was targeting statues of people who had participated in the Atlantic slave trade. This is curious, because while some British were involved in the Atlantic slave trade it ranks pretty low on the list of Horrible Things the British Empire Did. The fact that Cecil Rhodes statues weren't getting dumped in rivers says about all you need to know on this subject. Rhodes was a monster. Look him up. Yet his statue continues to stand at Oxford. There is a movement to get it and other statues to Rhodes torn down, check out #RhodesMustFall on Twitter for example. But by and large British society refuses to engage with their genocidal past.
- pif 6y ago> But Britain is not America. Actually, the rest of the world is not the USA. But it looks like too many people in theUSA are too thick to get it.
- Avalaxy 6y agoThis annoys me a lot as well. Especially when people here in the Netherlands protest against "police violence", which is a thing that barely even exists in our country.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 6y agoMany americans (including journalists, thinkers, politicians, etc) can't imagine that there's any legitimate culture, or any issues, and preoccupations, other than their own. Or that their views are not the pinnacle of civilization, and they're not the white knights humanity waits to be saved by. It's part of the traditional exceptionalism...
- choward 6y agoWho is this addressed to? From the article it seems addressed to British people using social media to share American specific viewpoints. But the comments here make it seem like it's Americans doing the imposing of views.
- Macha 6y agoFor europeans, working in the tech industry increases people's exposure to Americans and American points of view significantly. So I think it's likely true in general that as the author represents, this is is mostly people making the change in their own country, people on this forum are going to have disproportionately more experience with it coming from the US because of their greater dealings with the US. Hence most of the discussion here being about US-imposed incidents.
- Macha 6y agoI remember American trainers for company sponsored training basically making the implication that there being no black people in most of the groups (of 10-15) being a sign of the institutionalised racism keeping them out of tech. Not considered was the ~1% black population in the country where the training took place. Having 3/80ish black engineers was actually significantly more diverse than if you'd just grabbed a random subset of the population. (ditto for Polish, Indians and Chinese, the actual sizable minorities in the country). Now had he been talking about the 15-20% of female engineers participating, he may have had a point, but the american perspective was "wow, there should be way more Black people because America has more Black people"
- bregma 6y ago(1) Yes, Americal cultural hegemony is widespread, especially in the English-speaking world (second language or first). (2) Yes, your country has racism, including systemic racism. Denial is one of the privileges that marks you as a member of the dominant group. Your job is not to deny the racism, but to try to identify it an root it out. The crux of the biscuit is that the American concept of 'race' is so very very nebulous. Since there is no hard definition of 'race', there is no way to definitively sort an individual into a 'race.' It's entirely subjective and relies on an individual's prejudice.
- LockAndLol 6y agoYes, thank you for this opinion piece. I do believe however that we non-Americans are also to blame. We consume American media like there's no tomorrow and don't support our local media even barely enough. The great advantage America has for spreading their culture is its single official language. It's able to echo within the country, gain a large following and then spread outside of its borders. Europe has done nothing like that. Ever since the European Union was made, there has been no successful attempt to find a common language in order to unify the countries lingually. It's not a surprise due to the divisive history, but I strongly believe that Esperanto could've been that language. Of course, it's too late now and English (especially American English) has become the virtual lingua franca, but that means Europe (and other countries) should learn from the U.S. What the U.S has is practically a large propaganda machine that blasts its views across the world. The entertainment industry (film, music, news) is large and the major window into American life. It's available everywhere at either no cost or when the demand is large, at a premium. I'd say other countries should: - subsidize their entertainment industry heavily - expand their education to provide world-wide - do away with geo-blocking and exclusivity - have free national programs to help learn their language from anywhere in the world and last, but definitely most importantly: educate their populace to think logically and to broaden their horizons to think out of the box. Culture, tradition and language are in a product in today's capitalistic world. If you do not make your product attractive, appealing, and available, people will not buy it. The U.S has understood that and are doing a mighty fine job at exporting it.
- lowdose 6y agoWe should all switch to English in Europe.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoHilarious that people here are so brainwashed that they think the global media is "American..." Ya they're such hamburger-eating, gun-toting, tradition, church-going... Oh wait, no, they're from a tiny minority tribe with dual citizenship if things go south! And they curse you with the word "anti-semitic" (or similar) if you stray outside of the Overton window in really any direction.
- henrikschroder 6y agoThe one thing I took away from seeing all the BLM protests in Europe this summer, and all the discussions among my friends and family back home about it is that Europeans in general do not understand how incredibly racist the US was, and still is. At one point in the 1800's, slave labour contributed over half of the US GDP, and to protect that economy, to protect that business, the states who benefited the most from it were completely drenched in absolutely brutal amounts of racist propaganda. The slave economy of the US necessitated the institutionalised racism, because that was the only way you could get ordinary people to put up with the practice. And Europe has never experienced anything like that, so for the average European, there are no frames of reference, no shared history, nothing. Sure, there's been slave economies in Europe, but the last ones were a thousand years ago. Sure, there's racism in Europe, plenty of it, but it looks completely different, and it's never been as hyperfocused on skin colour like racism in the US is. Racism in Europe is more about ethnocentrism, and some of the worst atrocities in the continent's history have been committed by super white people against other super white people. Another thing that Europeans do not understand is how the police works in the US. Where I'm from, the police consists of two national organisations, 700 years of history, and an origin as the city watch, making sure cities in the middle ages didn't catch on fire. Whereas in the US, the police consists of some 16000 decentralised wildly different organisations, federal, state, county, local, all with a much shorter history, wildly different histories, wildly different scopes of law enforcement. But most importantly, some of those local police organisations were explicitly founded to enforce slave laws, to enforce racial segregation, to enforce Jim Crow laws, and they were founded by the local KKK leaders. The situation is completely different, the history is completely different, the racial divides are completely different. And then people try to import the US discourse on racism, and nothing fits, nothing makes sense, but people still don't want to be seen as racists, so they try to make it fit, try to agree, and it's all just weird. You can stand in solidarity with BLM no matter where you live, that's fine, but if you're European, please stop there. Don't try to deal with uniquely US issues in your own country, because I promise you, they don't exist. You have other issues to deal with.
- paesant 6y agothis post will get absolutely rekt because east coast americans are waking up
- romanoderoma 6y ago> but that doesn't mean we don't have racism Absolutely right! We do have racism. But "systemic racism" is on a whole another level in US. It's in the system means "you can be shot and killed just because you are of some ethnicity" by those that sworn to protect and serve. I'm scared only thinking about it. I would live in constant fear. Plus, it is true that Europe society is not racism free, it is also true that US society is not racism free as well. At least in Europe we don' t have to fight against police racism on the same scale. p.s.: my reference to the police brutality is linked to what's said in the article "to be black is to live in perpetual terror of being murdered by the state. But Britain is not America"
- akvadrako 6y ago> But "systemic racism" is on a whole another level in US. You have a very skewed view of race relations in the US. Racist police is a popular media narrative, but it's not backed up by evidence. Cops are more likely to kill a white fugitive then a black one; black cops are just as likely to kill as white cops; many victims of police violence are white; etc...
- romanoderoma 6y ago> Racist police is a popular media narrative, but it's not backed up by evidence. What I posted earlier IS evidence. It comes from official statistics https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6080222/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6080222/ Victims were majority white (52%) but disproportionately black (32%) with a fatality rate 2.8 times higher among blacks than whites I imagined people from the US knew their country better than me, that am from Italy, where police doesn't kill us anyway, regardless of the colour of our skin, and in those rare cases when it happens, because sometimes it happens here too, nobody take the killer's side. If we needed more proof on what's wrong in US culture, your line of thinking - or should I call it bury the head in the sand? - is one. Genuine question: what would it take for you to admit it? I mean, if you tell me "in Italy you have mafia" I would answer, "yes, and I am ashamed of it". I wouldn't try to hide it, like you tried to do with the police brutality in your country (large part of the system racism in US is the fact that some ethnicities are more in danger of being killed or victimized by the police, having their lives and careers prospects ruined forever).
- apexalpha 6y agoThe average black American in the United States can trace his ancestry further back than the average white American. Most black Americans are descended from enslaved Africans. Their forebears suffered through the segregation and racial terror of the Jim Crow era. The majority of black people in the United Kingdom, by contrast, are immigrants or the children of immigrants. Though many of them have certainly had harrowing experiences with injustice or discrimination, they do not have the same history of racist disadvantage. This is a key bit here that also applies to the Netherlands. Most, if not all, black (and Moroccan, Turkish etc) Dutch people are either immigrants or children of immigrants. This sheds a whole different light on statistics, imho. If you move a big chunck of Dutch people to Turkey it would not be weird if their kids wouldn't be CEO's, high level politicians or so. That's just not how that works, especially when your parents were lower educated, and in many cases can't (couldn't) read any Latin based language. Yet the debate here around racism "borrows" arguments form the US, where black people have been living for 400 years sometimes and STILL aren't even close to representation in the 'top' layer of society. Just like in the UK, Dutch media is bloody obsessed with the US.
- nix23 6y agoI fix the title: Please Stop Imposing American Views about everything on Us.
- tiago_o 6y agoIt saddens me to see this in Portugal too. Last week some celebrities and online publications decided to highlight how proud we should be of having a black man with dreadlocks as a TV anchor. No reference or acknowledgement of anything else about him, just "congratulations for being black". At least for a decade race had been as noteworthy as eye color, until now. Fortunately, a good chunk of the population can still see how backwards it is to reduce an individual to the color of their skin. But I must admit I'm not very hopeful for future generations when I see schools incorporating intersectional activism in their curriculum and people gathering to protest police brutality in what must be one of the most peaceful countries in the world. It's a sad reality that so many people exist in this Goldilocks zone of damage, where they are in positions of power and influence while being ignorant and lazy enough to parrot American media without context or critical thought.
- jamisteven 6y agoEven in the US it doesnt ring true to many, many people. And I am not just talking about privileged white people not seeing the point, the people spreading these PC views on everyone are a minority and are the same ones always playing the victim, bitching and complaining for one reason or another.
- MrsPeaches 6y ago.
- thefz 6y agoI'd be really really careful stating that "you can't be racist against whites" outside the US. According to where you say it in Europe, such a bold claim can get you in quite the discussion. I'll never get why the all-encompassing "racism is the discrimination on the basis of race" must be corrected by narrower american version of "no, only if it's systemic". But that is already included in the original definition... or is it a shortcut to hate on whites?
- zach_garwood 6y agoBrits complaining about a foreign power imposing their culture on them from across the globe seems deliciously ironic.
- charlescearl 6y agoI think that the article was so insightful in complexifying the experience of racism that Black people still encounter across this planet. There are a 100 million ways of existing in a Black body in this world. I am reading Yaa Gyasi’s amazing novel Transcendent Kingdom which in a semi-autobiographical way, explores the complexity of a Ghanaian scientist who grew up in a Pentecostal family in Alabama. I would also recommend listening to the author’s recent Fresh Air interview. There are many threads here in the manner of “the American obsession with racism”. Different does not mean “does not exist”. I wonder if the commenters have digested C.L.R. James or Walter Rodney. Haiti is still waiting on reparations from France, Namibia is still waiting on reparations from Germany for genocide. The list is long.
- rbecker 6y ago> The debate is worth having. But in the place of that debate, there have only been pious paeans to diversity. Whatever could have made people unwilling to publicly debate these issues?
- Perenti 6y agoThis reminds me of when I was in San Diego in 2000. A neighbour (African American) told me how in the early 90s he was in Sydney and decided to see how he could support the "people of colour". He went to Redfern and found that all the dark people were giving him the hate stare. He found this confusing. I pointed out to him that to our Indigenous people, being coloured didn't make him a brother (usually "cousin" amongst Aboriginal Australians), in fact he was just another invader. Assumptions about colour don't always apply in different countries.