3 ms·
Investors are much more likely to worry about IP lawsuits than the nitty-gritty of development libraries and methodology. If people start being sued for using t
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
Investors are much more likely to worry about IP lawsuits than the nitty-gritty of development libraries and methodology. If people start being sued for using the Linux kernel, your investors are going to expect a pretty solid explanation for why you won't be one of them.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> If people start being sued for using the Linux kernel, your investors are going to expect a pretty solid explanation for why you won't be one of them. So follow the license? If you built a business on pirating Windows, nobody would be surprised when MS murdered you in court. Why should Linux be any different?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt shouldn't be! Linux devs have every right to enforce the license as strongly as they'd like. I'm just saying that it's silly to expect that this won't impact usage, or that investors will insist on Linux because of their deep and principled commitment to good development standards.
- ramshorns 6y agoIs usage the goal? I would think it's better to have, say, 80 devices on the market that use Linux and comply with the GPL and give software freedom to their users, along with 20 devices whose vendors chose to avoid the hassle and used a proprietary or permissively licensed kernel, than to have 100 devices that all use Linux and violate the GPL and give the users no ability to share or modify the software.
- jariel 6y agoSpicy is right though. Whatever the movement is 'trying to do' is not the point so much as 'what will happen' because of the incentives and thinking process (ie risk mitigation) at most companies. Most of these licences are untested in court and that's a very bad thing for everyone. So in a way, a bunch of clear and settled cases would provide the 'best path forward' because then we'd know where the lines are - but - a bunch of 'weird outcomes' that cost other companies bazillions would probably hurt a lot and it will strike fast. You won't be able to get your investment if your flirting with a situation in which some other corp got banged for $2B, even if technically you are in the clear. It's probably a very bad idea to 'sue for money'. The objective of the legal cases should be 'clarity' and the cases should be chosen on that basis if the open source community really wants to thrive.
- andi999 6y agoit is not just that the licences are untested in court in one legal system, dont they need to be tested in all jurisdictions? I mean what jurisdiction applies to the licence? (GPL might not be such a problem, since it is very restrictive, but what about LGPL? I ship a system with my software using an LGPL lib to country A, while I am located in country B and the developers of the lib were from country C,D and E)
- jariel 6y agoTo some extent this is true, yes. But legal jurisdictions defer to one another, to the point wherein that is even becoming more formalized, especially for smaller countries [1]. And it's possible that an IP ruling in 'some important place' sets the material precedent anyhow. If the US or EU rules one way, then others will be influenced by that on some level. A lot of this could possibly be more clarified by legislation, but I only think the EU and maybe the UK really have the wherewithal or importance to make an impact. Germany possibly but I see them wanting to do that at the EU level. I don't see anything on the horizon for the US. I would definitely double down on my heretofore down-voted statement: if you care about open source, you really, really want to have 'good, clean cases' pushed through and tested in the courts. If Open Source proponents leave it to the wind, patent trolls, or big corps - you may see 'bad cases' go through the system and set really bad precedent that hinges on weird corners cases. Do not underestimate how much of a big deal this is. IP is a discussion at every point along the way when contemplating investing in independent or internal projects and 'ambiguity' is a huge factor in risk aversion. All of these IP licences are just 'ideas' waiting to be 'more or less law' when they face legal scrutiny, so if I were the 'God of Open Source' I'd be looking to find cases to build a favourable pipeline to the Supreme Court. Major rulings will have a beneficial impact for everyone. [1] https://www.loc.gov/law/help/domestic-judgment/canada.php https://www.loc.gov/law/help/domestic-judgment/canada.php
- andi999 6y agoI care about open source, but I also think these litigations might be harmful, I mean if the software is the product companies cannot publish the source. What probably works (and the GPL is good for) is dual licensing, one free GPL version and one paid version. If you do not want to do this, then maybe some clearly permissive license like MIT or putting it into public domain might be a good alternative.