3 ms·
I'm just surprised there are still a lot of mainstream accessories that aren't available in USB-C. I bought a Logitech C920 webcam the other day (the most poup
by crazygringo 6y ago
I'm just surprised there are still a lot of mainstream accessories that aren't available in USB-C.
I bought a Logitech C920 webcam the other day (the most pouplar model)... and it's still only available in USB-A. If you want a Logitech webcam with USB-C, you've got to pay over twice as much for a model like their StreamCam.
I'm happy to use dongles for HDMI or Ethernet when I have to. But the fact that I still have to use dongles with brand-new devices that are still only made in USB-A seems ridiculous. At this rate, I don't see how we're ever going to move on.
- warmwaffles 6y ago> it's still only available in USB-A That's because it is still the most common type of port out there and it doesn't require a huge bandwidth that USB-C provides. If anything it would be overkill and over priced for what you get. I think logitech is waiting for USB-C to become more prevalent and the cost to manufacture to drop.
- crote 6y agoThe interesting thing is that for small-bandwidth applications, USB C isn't that difficult to add. Compared to USB A, it's literally a different connector and two additional resistors on the CC pins. The power / data pins of USB C are completely compatible with USB 2.0.
- pantalaimon 6y agoMost computers only have 1-2 USB-C ports, but plenty USB-A ones. You would not want to 'waste' a high-speed port for a webcam.
- crote 6y agoYeah, it's a chicken-and-egg problem. As long as most devices are A, most ports will be A as well. And until C ports are more common, it's no use making C devices. That's made even worse because adapters for C female to A male are explicitly forbidden by the specs, so there's no cheap way to support both. A manufacturer could put a female C port on the device and ship both C-to-C and C-to-A cables, but that's expensive.
- crazygringo 6y agoSo after more than 5 years, USB-C is still too expensive and "overkill"? That might be true, but then it's a massive failure. The entire point of USB-C is for the whole computing ecosystem to migrate. If that's prohibitively expensive for a common webcam, then it's an utter design failure. But I have a hard time believig it actually is true, since I can also find a bunch of cheap USB-C stuff on Amazon as well. So I hope it's not true, at least.
- dspillett 6y ago> So after more than 5 years, USB-C is still too expensive and "overkill"? Yes, if you already have a working design that uses USB-A and you don't want to mess around with the manufacturing process. Also three are a log of people out there with no USB-C ports on their machine or existing USB-C chargers so you end up needing to provide at least an A->C adaptor (OK, these aren't expensive, but it costs >$0 to include one) or if your device charges too slowly off non-PD ports then you need to provide a wall-wart where you otherwise might get away with being cheap and not. Furthermore, I know some people who are actively avoiding USB-C (seems odd, but true) as they already have a pile of devices/wallwarts/batteries/cables that are based on the older connectors.
- zajio1am 6y agoEven today, new desktop mainboards have 6-8 USB-A ports and zero or one USB-C ports. So it is not surprising that accessories (especially ones for desktops) are offered with USB-A connectors.
- falcolas 6y agoAnd that doesn't even get into Keyboards, Mice, USB Headphones/sound cards, printers, USB storage keys, bluetooth/gaming keyboard dongles... The list of peripherals not broadly (if at all) available in USB-C is nuts.
- rubatuga 6y agoA USB-C male to USB-A female adapter is to spec, but a USB-A male to USB-C female is not allowed. This asymmetry is the reason why USB-A is the common denominator.