8 ms·
Alright, time to be contrarian: so what. Ok, it's interesting that the law in Ireland requires a 2% or less baker's weight of sugar. And I do enjoy a good sou
by samatman 6y ago
Alright, time to be contrarian: so what.
Ok, it's interesting that the law in Ireland requires a 2% or less baker's weight of sugar. And I do enjoy a good sourdough, which isn't made with any sugar, or just a pinch.
But my favourite sandwich bread is Japanese milk bread, it's soft, lovely crumb, and it browns beautifully in the pan.
It's got a lot of sugar in it, that's the secret. A random recipe I found says 18% baker's weight, which seems accurate.
Are we pretending that polysaccharides are the staff of life, but when you get down to disaccharides they become the Devil? The glycemic index of white flour is dire, I doubt adding sugar is going to move the needle.
Sugar in dough makes it soft, with a giving crumb, and a crust which can be brown without becoming hard.
Exactly what you want in a sandwich filled with toppings, so that they don't shoot out the back when you bite into it.
Clutch your pearls all you want about 'Subway misrepresenting healthy food'! They publish the macros of their sandwiches. It's not nearly so healthy as eggs scrambled in butter, there's a ton of carbs and not nearly enough fat.
Unless you think it's the other way around that's healthy. It's your stomach, you get to pick.
- dmead 6y agoI really hate this comment, it's trying to remind me how good sugar is, while making it seem like a government action to do anything to protect it's people is silly. Thanks, I hate it.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoSee also Pizza[1] [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/food/1988/05/11/whos-minding-the-store/2af04559-d212-4a64-bc6e-b3b7adb7f49f/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/food/1988/0...
- ravar 6y agoSugar isn't just a glucose disacharide, its got fructose, which is functionally not a carb. It can only be metabolized in the liver, and in large enough quantities your liver is forced to metabolize fructose into fat, which taken far enough leads non alcoholic fatty liver disease. Glucose won't do that to you.
- killjoywashere 6y agoFructose is definitely a carb. It's not a direct reactant in Kreb's cycle, but there are plenty of ways to move fructose through the metabolic pathways so the oxidation of those carbons results in the production of ATP. Also, I wouldn't use "It can only be metabolized by the liver" as evidence of fructose's carbohydrate status: a) that has nothing to do with the definitions, and the statement is true for a very large number of molecules.
- ravar 6y agoEmphasis on my wording, functionally not a carb. Its not treated how carbs normally are.
- just-juan-post 6y agoCould you elaborate? I'm reading this on wikipedia: > Under one percent of ingested fructose is directly converted to plasma triglyceride.[2] 29% - 54% of fructose is converted in liver to glucose, and about a quarter of fructose is converted to lactate. 15% - 18% is converted to glycogen.[3] Glucose and lactate are then used normally as energy to fuel cells all over the body. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fructolysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fructolysis
- ravar 6y agoI can't find my source[1], but the amount of fructose converted to glucose is highly dose dependent. Over 30 grams (if i remember correctly) it basically all gets shunted to fat. edit: [1]https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/joim.12993 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/joim.12993
- samatman 6y agoYes, I'll grant you that fructose and glucose aren't bio-identical foods. A human can only absorb about 30 grams of fructose in an hour, and it looks like if we get well north of 120 grams in a day, bad things can happen. That's sixty grams of sugar, or about 55 of high fructose corn syrup. Can't be more than 200 grams of flour in a twelve-inch subway, so twenty grams of sugar? You'll be fine. Just, maybe don't get that fountain drink to go with it...
- seanieb 6y agoYou didn’t read the article...
- nightfly 6y agoFor a bread that's gonna last more than a few days, yeah milk + more sugar seems to help with the flavor a _lot_. For freshly baked bread like that you're gonna eat within a few hours of baking, it's still pretty tasty even without it.
- lostlogin 6y agoIf honey is used rather than sugar, you get more sweetness per unit weight, and also get more browning. This is good or bad depending on what you like. Thick dark crusts are what I’m after, so honey is a straight win.
- hvidgaard 6y agoThat only true if you want pure white bread. If you bake with more whole grain (> 30%) higher hydration (> 70%) and use preferments or even better sourdough, a bread can easily last a week, as long as you can toast it once it's more than 2-3 days old.
- connectsnk 6y agoVery well constructed argument. Please see here that the court is preventing subway from claiming tax breaks by classifying their product as staple food (bread). They are not preventing people from eating it.
- plazmatic 6y agoThere's not even an argument here. It's just stream of consciousness, starting with "let me be the contrarian here..." Jesus. Hacker news is becoming useless with replies like this being top voted.
- samatman 6y agoAh yes, I did read the article, and even comment that the Irish tax angle is of some interest. My riposte here is that the Irish definition of bread doesn't comport with many delicious baked goods I would be happy to call bread, and eat with cheese and some cold cuts. I'm glad you appreciated it. This isn't that unusual; Germans refuse to call many tasty beverages 'beer', and I'm sure this suits the Irish just fine.
- mantap 6y agoThe point of the classification is to not unduly burden the poor by taxing staple foods, such as bread. It's not about being snobby, everybody can agree that on the outside of a subway sandwich there is bread. But subway is fast food. The ingredients are selected to make you buy and buy more. I wouldn't really call it a staple.
- hyperpape 6y agoMy opinion is that this is a bad policy. We could just tax it all equally (plenty of folks making good money eat at Subway) and ensure that the people have enough money to get by. But instead, governments around the world create these Rube Goldberg machines that require a court to define what bread is.
- 6y ago
- op03 6y agoGood. I have been thinking of giving up bread entirely for cake.
- samatman 6y agoSwapping four slices of bread a day for one slice of cake is a perfectly reasonable thing to do!
- drawfloat 6y agoSo....sugar bread isn't an essential/staple food therefore doesn't qualify for a tax break? Whether it's healthy or not has nothing to do with it, there's a specific cut off to prevent brioche/cakes qualifying and it's over it.
- tus88 6y ago> Are we pretending that polysaccharides are the staff of life, but when you get down to disaccharides they become the Devil? Yes, the insulin response of the second is orders of magnitude greater. It's poison.
- usrusr 6y ago> Are we pretending that polysaccharides are the staff of life, but when you get down to disaccharides they become the Devil? Devil or not devil is off topic: it's not about not-devil or devil, it's about the difference between bread and cake. Which isn't a value judgement at all. But that is a line that will unsurprisingly be drawn differently in different cultures. The legal issue isn't putting too much sugar in a product, it's putting much sugar in there and then labeling that product in a way that is deceptive in the local language (and in this case a tax angle, but it could be a court issue even without that).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andi999 6y agoIts about legal definitions. In Germany a lemondaid is getting banned (not allowed to be called lemonaid) because of too low sugar. These were introduced a long time ago to protect the consumer.
- vincnetas 6y agoSimilary if butter does not contain 82% of milk fat you cant call it a butter in Lithuania.
- bouncycastle 6y agoI can't stand Japanese bread, mainly for the sweetness. No thanks... Give me a nice crispy and freshly baked French baguette any time. I'd even eat it without any toppings as the main meal!
- straw11 6y agoJust because it has bread in its name does not mean anything. Or you consider shortbread a bread? Certainly the Irish won't. Pleased stop taking things literally.
- bad_user 6y agoAlso, the glycemic index is bullshit, as it won't predict the blood glucose response of an individual to a meal, because that depends on the person's health (diabetic or not), time of day (e.g glycogen stores depleted or not), or food combinations. Also, eating sugar in a healthy person (non-diabetic) is only bad when it leads to overeating calories, not because of the blood sugar response, which is perfectly normal. There's nothing wrong with getting some sugar in your blood, and avoiding foods on such meaningless criteria is a recipe for eating disorders (orthorexia). The carbohydrate-insulin model is complete bullshit.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elipsey 6y agoindustrial sugar is a cheap filler. it is the rightful role of government to regulate the externalities imposed on consumers by producers that use asymmetries of information to sell adulterated staple foods like "bread" with a large amount of corn syrup in it. it is now necessary for buyers to spend a considerable amount of time and intellectual energy to avoid such things, and that imposes a real cost on consumers. if i want to know whether my food has added sugar, i now have to read the labels of every atomic "ingredient" that i buy, like canned tomatoes, or corn. i only trade with subway because it is the closest thing to food i can buy at the airport or by the freeway. without consumer access to complete information, i doubt that i will have access to products that are not adulterated with cheap, harmful ingredients. this seems to me like a canonical example of the sort of case where regulation would make a more efficient market.
- jlarocco 6y agoOn one hand I agree with you, but I also think it's besides the point. What you and I call it doesn't matter - for legal (and tax) purposes, bread with too much sugar stops being a "staple food" and becomes cake. It's just the way the law is written, and whether it's a good idea or not, it's common for tax laws to promote certain lifestyle choices like eating healthy or not smoking. The business in the article tried to use a loophole to avoid taxes and got slapped down by another loophole.
- ramblerman 6y ago> It's your stomach, you get to pick. That's missing the point, Ireland isn't banning subways. You are still free to go and eat there. The point is to have some common labels that define what a substance is, and some minimum quality control. If I go and buy milk I would hope it comes from a cow, and isn't just water with artificial coloring.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoNo, I think the meaning of the court's decision is that you can't call a product with more than 2% sugar, bread, in Ireland.
- orwin 6y agoIt depends on the fructose quantity when the saccharide is cut fown. 1-1 fructose-glucose is objectively worse than 3-4, even if it's not much, but objectively better than 4-3. So, sugar is objectively worse than white flour.
- nazka 6y ago> So what? Because after that it’s technically not a bread, it’s a brioche. As much as applesauce starts to be an Apple jelly. Yes it’s your stomach and you pick what you want to eat but it is deceiving. The Irish court is not saying to stop to eat at Subway but to give the right info to me as a customer about what I am going to eat.